'Ontology Design Patterns' - User contributions [en]

'Ontology Design Patterns':Events

2018-02-02T12:15:10Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Workshops */ added links to the 2017 and 2018 editions

[[Image:Event.png|70px]]

===Workshops===
* [[WOP:2018|7th Workshop on Ontology Patterns (WOP) - at ISWC 2018]]
* [[WOP:2017|7th Workshop on Ontology Patterns (WOP) - at ISWC 2017]]
* [[WOP:2016|7th Workshop on Ontology Patterns (WOP) - at ISWC 2016]]
* [[WOP:2015|6th Workshop on Ontology Patterns (WOP) - at ISWC 2015]]
* [[WOP:2014|5th Workshop on Ontology Patterns (WOP) - at ISWC 2014]]
* [[WOP:2013|4th Workshop on Ontology Patterns (WOP) - at ISWC 2013]]
* [[WOP:2012|3rd Workshop on Ontology Patterns (WOP) - at ISWC 2012]]
* [[Odp:WOP2010|2nd Workshop on Ontology Patterns (WOP) - at ISWC 2010]]
* [[Odp:KIELD2010|1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection and and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD) - at EKAW 2010]]
* [[WOP:2009|1st Workshop on Ontology Patterns (WOP) - at ISWC 2009]]

===GeoVocabularyCamps with focus on ontology design pattern modeling===

* [http://vocamp.org/wiki/GeoVoCampSB2012 Geo Vocabulary Camp Santa Barbara 2012], 3-5 February 2012 at University of California, Santa Barbara, CA
* [http://vocamp.org/wiki/GeoVoCampDayton2012 Geo Vocabulary Camp Dayton 2012], 15-17 September 2012 at Wright State University, Dayton, OH
* [http://vocamp.org/wiki/GeoVoCampSOCoP2012 Geo Vocabulary Camp SOCoP 2012], 29-30 November 2012 at USGS National Facility, Reston, VA
* [http://vocamp.org/wiki/GeoVoCampSB2013 Geo Vocabulary Camp Santa Barbara 2013], 20-22 March 2013 at University of California, Santa Barbara, CA
* [http://vocamp.org/wiki/GeoVoCampDC2013 Geo Vocabulary Camp DC 2013], 18-19 November 2013 at the National Science Foundation in Ballston, VA
* [http://vocamp.org/wiki/GeoVoCampSB2014 Geo Vocabulary Camp Santa Barbara 2014], 14-16 March 2014 at University of California, Santa Barbara, CA
* [http://vocamp.org/wiki/GeoVoCampSOCoP2014 Geo Vocabulary Camp SOCoP 2014], 1-3 December 2014 at USGS National Facility, Reston, VA
* [http://vocamp.org/wiki/GeoVoCampSB2015 Geo Vocabulary Camp Santa Barbara 2015], 23-25 March 2015 at University of California, Santa Barbara, CA
* [http://vocamp.org/wiki/VoCampND2015 Geo Vocabulary Camp Notre Dame 2015], 18-19 May 2015 at University of Notre Dame, IN

===Tutorials===
* [http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/wiki/ISWC2016Tutorial Ontology Design Patterns for Linked Data Publishing at ISWC 2016]
* [[Training:Tutorial:_Modular_Ontology_Modeling_with_Ontology_Design_Patterns_at_ESWC2017|Modular Ontology Modeling with Ontology Design Patterns Tutorial at ESWC 2017]]

=== XD camps ===

* [[Odp:AMICamp2| AMI Ontology Camp II]]

=== Face to Face meetings ===

* [[Odp:EB-1st-f2f-2009Feb23| First f2f editorial board meeting]]

WOP:2018

2018-02-02T12:07:48Z

VojtechSvatek: /* WOP2018 Chairs */

= 9th Workshop on Ontology Design and Patterns - WOP2018 =

This is the ninth edition in a series of workshops addressing the topic of '''ontology and semantic web patterns as best practices''', related to the [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) |''ontologydesignpatterns.org'']] initiative.

The Workshop on Ontology Design and Patterns targets topics relating to high quality ontology design. The workshop series addresses topics centered around quality in ontology design as well as ontology design patterns (ODP) in Semantic Web data and ontology engineering. ODPs have seen a sharp rise in attention in the past few years, both pertaining to this workshop series and other related events. Patterns can benefit knowledge engineers and Semantic Web developers with a direct link to requirements, reuse, guidance, and better communication. They need to be shared by a community in order to provide a common language, hence the aim of this workshop is twofold: 1) providing an arena for discussing patterns, pattern-based ontologies, systems, datasets, etc., and 2) broadening the pattern community by developing its own 'discourse' for discussing and describing relevant problems and their solutions. Related to the latter aim we see that it is an opportune time to open up the workshop to other approaches focusing on high quality ontology design, e.g. other methods and tools, with the intention to cross-fertilise these with the ODP idea.

For more background on the workshop series, see the [[WOP:Main | main page]].

WOP2018 is a ''full-day workshop'' consisting of three parts: paper presentations, pattern presentations and posters, and an interactive pattern writing and/or discussion session. The poster session will feature pattern posters, i.e. presentations of patterns submitted according the [[WOP:2018#Call_for_Patterns| call for patterns]].

__TOC__

== Venue and dates ==
The ninth edition of WOP will be held in conjunction with [http://iswc2018.semanticweb.org ISWC 2018] in Monterey, California ,USA, on 8th or 9th of October 2018.

== WOP 2018 Program ==

'''Venue:''' TBD

=== Paper presentations session ===

* Keynote talk
* Research paper presentations
* Coffee break
* Research paper presentations continued

=== Lunch ===

=== Poster session ===

=== Breakouts session ===

* Breakout sessions
* Coffee break
* Breakout sessions continued
* Breaktout session reports

=== Social Dinner ===

'''TBD'''

== Call for Papers - Topics ==
Submission of research papers (including position papers) is via the [https://easychair.org/conferences/?conf=wop2018 WOP 2018 EasyChair] page. Detailed submission instructions can be found on the [[WOP:2018/Submission | WOP 2018 submission page]].

The main aim of the workshop is to discuss and collect solutions to recurrent problems that matter to researchers and practitioners of the Semantic Web field, and that impact on design and engineering of ontologies, linked data, knowledge extraction, and other semantic web applications. We invite the submission of original research results related to the focus areas of the workshop. '''Research papers (maximum 15 pages LNCS style)''' should present mature work and document established results. '''Short papers (maximum 5 pages LNCS style)''' may present proposed research directions, novel ideas, or more general positions or discussions.

We particularly welcome contributions considering how one can develop high-quality ontologies in general, with or without the help of ODPs. Nevertheless, as usual we also welcome pattern descriptions of all sorts, including patterns geared towards applications in specific domains, such as geosciences, biomedical science, as well as digital humanities. The main topics of interest are:

* Ontology design patterns, analyses of ODP use, and analyses of pattern-based ontologies
* Correspondence patterns for ontology matching and integration
* Knowledge patterns and knowledge reengineering based on patterns
* Antipatterns and their relations to ODPs
* Methods and tools for developing high-quality ontologies, including ontology engineering by domain experts
* Analyses of quality attributes in ontologies and ontology engineering, and quality assurance approaches for ontology engineering
* Pattern-based ontology design and knowledge engineering
* Pattern-based ontology evaluation and selection
* Ontology pattern extraction
* Pattern-based information extraction, ontology learning, and relation to NLP
* Patterns and Linked data (usage, emerging patterns, pattern-driven data publishing, etc.)
* Quality assurance for Linked Data vocabularies
* Web semantics from a pattern perspective
* Reasoning with, or using, patterns
* Contextual reasoning and patterns as context
* Pattern-based methods and methodologies for development of semantic applications
* Patterns for streaming data and evolving knowledge, as well as processes and services
* Patterns for Big Data integration, data lakes, conceptual modeling, ontology-based data access, and business intelligence
* Patterns in semantic social networks, semantic wikis, semantic blogs
* ODPs development and use in specific domains including geosciences, life sciences, digital humanities, cultural heritage, e-history, IoT, smart homes & cities, smart agriculture etc.

== Call for Patterns ==
Submissions should be made via the [https://easychair.org/conferences/?conf=wop2018 WOP 2018 EasyChair] page. Detailed instructions for submitting your pattern can be found at the [[WOP:2018/Submission | WOP 2018 submission page]].

We invite the submission of research results in the form of ontology design patterns (ODPs).
Patterns submitted should have a general relevance to the ontology engineering field, or specific interest within a knowledge domain. Patterns should solve some particular modelling problem, and be of significant interest for discussion at the workshop. Patterns should be original, in the sense that they are the intellectual product of the author(s), however they may still be based on the collective experience of a community.

Pattern submissions for the pattern session will be collected:

* through the [http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/wiki/Submissions:SubmitAPattern ODP portal] and
* by submitting a description of the pattern (pattern description) via EasyChair.

Detailed instructions for patterns submission, including how to submit via the ontologydesignpatterns.org portal, are found at the [[WOP:2018/Submission | submission page]]. Note that an account in the ODP portal is needed for submitting patterns; thus, authors should take care to request an account at least one week before their intended submission.

Pattern submissions can be made in any type of ODPs. Currently, portal templates for submission are provided for the following types of patterns (see general [[OPTypes|typology]] for explanation of the types):

* Content patterns
* Structural patterns: logical and architecture patterns.
* Correspondence patterns: re-engineering and alignment patterns.

For other types of patterns, the author is welcome to submit only a pattern description.

== Submission and Important Dates ==
Submissions should be made via the [https://easychair.org/conferences/?conf=wop2018 WOP 2018 EasyChair] page. Submissions should be in the Springer Lecture Notes in Computer Science (LNCS) format. [ftp://ftp.springer.de/pub/tex/latex/llncs/latex2e/llncs2e.zip Latex] and [ftp://ftp.springer.de/pub/tex/latex/llncs/word/splnproc1703.zip Word] templates are available. Detailed submission requirements can be found on the [[WOP:2018/Submission | WOP 2018 submission page]].

=== Important dates ===
* Abstract submission (required):
* Submission date: June 1st, 2018
* Author notifications: June 27th, 2018
* Camera-ready papers:
* Workshops will be held on: 8th or 9th of October, 2018 (TBD)

=== Best Poster Award ===
The best poster award for WOP 2018 is awarded based on voting by the workshop chairs (excluding those workshop chairs who themselves authored or co-authored a poster). The best poster award takes into account criteria such as the quality of the submission, the relevance and significance of patterns or pattern usages presented, the presentation of the poster during the session, and the level of involvement of the author during the revision phase and poster session discussions during the workshop.

==Proceedings==

WOP 2018 proceedings will be published via [http://ceur-ws.org CEUR Workshop Proceedings].

== WOP Organisation ==

==== WOP2018 Chairs ====

* Chairs:
** [http://www.cs.put.poznan.pl/alawrynowicz Agnieszka Ławrynowicz], Poznan University of Technology, Poland (general chair)
** [http://folk.uio.no/martige Martin G. Skjæveland], University of Oslo, Norway (papers co-chair)
** [http://volweb.utk.edu/~yhu21 Yingjie Hu], University of Tennessee, Knoxville, USA (papers co-chair)
** [http://www.karlhammar.com Karl Hammar], Jönköping University, Sweden (patterns co-chair)
** [http://nb.vse.cz/~svatek/welcom_e.htm Vojtěch Svátek], University of Economics, Prague, Czech Republic (patterns co-chair)

For general inquiries, please contact [http://www.cs.put.poznan.pl/alawrynowicz Agnieszka Ławrynowicz]

==== Steering Committee ====

The WOP Steering committee - the [http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/wiki/ODPA Board of the Association of Ontology Design and Patterns] - consists of:

Regular members:

* Eva Blomqvist, Linköping University (chair)
* Pascal Hitzler, Wright State University (vice chair)
* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR (vice chair)
* Aldo Gangemi, ISTC-CNR
* Krzysztof Janowicz, University of California, Santa Barbara
* Agnieszka Lawrynowicz, Poznan University of Technology
* Adila Krisnadhi, Wright State University

Members with special appointments:

* Andrea Nuzzolese, ISTC-CNR
* Karl Hammar, Jönköping University

==== Program Committee ====

(Some to be confirmed)

'''Alessandro Adamou''' Knowledge Media Institute, The Open University 
'''Luigi Asprino''' University of Bologna and STLab (ISTC-CNR) 
'''Victor de Boer''' Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam 
'''Marilena Daquino''' University of Bologna 
'''Mauro Dragoni''' Fondazione Bruno Kessler - FBK-IRST 
'''Aldo Gangemi''' Université Paris 13 & CNR-ISTC 
'''Karl Hammar''' Jönköping University 
'''Yingjie Hu''' University of Tennessee Knoxville 
'''Krzysztof Janowicz''' University of California, Santa Barbara 
'''Tomi Kauppinen''' Department of Computer Science, Aalto University School of Science 
'''Adila A. Krisnadhi''' Wright State University & Universitas Indonesia 
'''Piotr Kulicki''' John Paul II Catholic University of Lublin 
'''Jose Emilio Labra Gayo''' Universidad de Oviedo 
'''Agnieszka Lawrynowicz''' Poznan University of Technology 
'''Steffen Lohmann''' Fraunhofer 
'''Andrea Giovanni Nuzzolese''' STLab, ISTC-CNR 
'''Francesco Poggi''' Università di Bologna 
'''María Poveda-Villalón''' Ontology Engineering Group. Departamento de Inteligencia Artificial. Universidad Politécnica de Madrid 
'''Valentina Presutti''' CNR - Institute of Cognitive Sciences and Tecnologies 
'''Cogan Shimizu''' Wright State University 
'''Monika Solanki''' University of Oxford 
'''Gem Stapleton''' University of Brighton 
'''Mari Carmen Suárez-Figueroa''' Universidad PolitÃ©cnica de Madrid 
'''Samson Tu''' Stanford University 
'''Charles Vardeman Ii''' University of Notre Dame 
'''Jennifer Warrender''' Newcastle University 

[[Category:Event]]
[[Category:WOP]]
{{Event
|Name=WOP 2018
|HasStartDate=2018/10/08
|HasEndDate=2018/10/09
}}
{{Submission deadline
|deadline=2018/06/01
|expired=TBA
|intime=TBA
}}

WOP:2018/Submission

2018-02-02T12:07:15Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Detailed Instructions for Pattern Submissions */

== Submission Instructions for WOP 2018 ==
This page contains instructions for submitting to [[WOP:2018|WOP 2018]]. There are two main categories of papers:

* Research papers: [https://easychair.org/conferences/?conf=wop2017 https://easychair.org/conferences/?conf=wop2018]
* Patterns: through the ODP portal + pattern paper (primarily a pattern description) through [https://easychair.org/conferences/?conf=wop2018 https://easychair.org/conferences/?conf=wop2018]

== Research Paper Submissions ==

We invite the submission of original research results related to the focus areas of the workshop. Research papers (maximum '''15 pages''' LNCS style) should present mature work and document established results, or be short papers presenting proposed research directions and novel ideas (maximum '''5 pages''' LNCS style).

'''Submission guidelines'''
* Research papers should be no longer than 15 pages (including references), following the Springer LNCS formatting style (see [http://www.springer.com/computer/lncs?SGWID=0-164-6-793341-0 LNCS style templates]). Note that papers not adhering to the style guidelines or the maximum page limit will be rejected without review.
* Short research papers should be no longer than 5 pages, following the same template.
* Submissions should be in English, and non-native speakers are encouraged to seek assistance from native English speakers to ensure a correct language.
* Submission of the papers should be done through [https://easychair.org/conferences/?conf=wop2018 https://easychair.org/conferences/?conf=wop2018].

'''Review process and publication'''

Each paper will be reviewed by at least two reviewers, final accept/reject decisions are made by the chairs based on these reviews. Acceptance is conditional, meaning that only accepted papers that perform the changes requested by the reviewers (this will be checked carefully by the chairs) and where at least one author registers for the workshop, will be included in the proceedings and in the workshop program. These papers will be made available online from the workshop webpage. Please note that ISWC usually do NOT allow "workshop-only" registrations, i.e. registering for the workshop will therefore mean to register for the main conference + WOP.

Instructions for accepted papers, presentations, and post-proceedings will be provided later.

== Detailed Instructions for Pattern Submissions ==
We invite the submission of new Ontology Design Patterns. Submissions will be composed of a pattern and a short paper (between 5 and 12 pages in LNCS style) describing it.

The following is a list of detailed instructions that authors have to take into account in order to submit their patterns:
* [[Special:RequestAccount | Request an account at the ODP portal]], in case you do not have already one. Note that account requests are processed by hand, so do this step with a few days to spare before the submission deadline.
* Go to the ODP portal [[Submissions:SubmitAPattern | pattern submission page]].
* Submit your pattern by following the instructions, and make sure you enter as much information about your pattern as possible (clarity and completeness of the information will be a review criteria for patterns), i.e. fill out '''all''' applicable fields.
* Once created, edit your pattern page (edit tab at the top of the page) and under the "Submit for event" tab enter "WOP:2018".
* Go back to [[WOP:2018/Submission#Pattern_Submissions | this page]] and check that your pattern appears in the table below.
* Write a document briefly describing your pattern ('''between 5 and 12 pages''', depending on the complexity or topic of the pattern, in LNCS style), and submit this pattern description through [https://easychair.org/conferences/?conf=wop2018 https://easychair.org/conferences/?conf=wop2018].
* If you are experiencing any problems, or have questions about how to submit patterns, please contact the chairs.

'''Review Process'''

Each submission will be reviewed by at least two members of the Pattern PC (in case of disagreement a third reviewer will be assigned). Note that all reviews and discussions of patterns done in [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) | ODP portal]] are '''public''' and '''not''' anonymous, hence, all visitors of the portal can see the reviews and any subsequent discussion. Your pattern will be reviewed based on the following set of criteria:

* the practical utility and reusability of the pattern by a community,
* the relevance of the problem addressed by the pattern,
* if the pattern encodes some best practice within a community,
* and the completeness and clarity of the pattern submission, i.e., if all fields have been filled and all aspects properly explained.

Accepted patterns have to be improved based on the review comments, i.e., an update of the patterns in the ODP portal is mandatory. Accepted patterns will be presented at the workshop as posters in the pattern session. After the workshop, the patterns may be considered for certification in the ODP portal.

Reviews:VojtechSvatek about EventProcessing

2013-08-07T13:51:25Z

VojtechSvatek: New page: {{Content OP Proposal Review Template |CreationDate=2013/8/7 |SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek |ContentOPUnderReview=EventProcessing |RevisionID=11646 |Score=1 - needs minor revision |ReviewSumma...

{{Content OP Proposal Review Template
|CreationDate=2013/8/7
|SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek
|ContentOPUnderReview=EventProcessing
|RevisionID=11646
|Score=1 - needs minor revision
|ReviewSummary=Pattern description conforming to the usual standards of the portal, with only minor details missing.
|ReviewConfidence=I am not expert in sensors, and haven't been even extensively involved in event modeling. My familiarity with ODPs in general is however solid.
|ReviewProblems=I don't see any major problems. Only some details of the pattern should be clarified to ensure its proper use.
The diagram also lacks classes SensorOutput and EventObjectPart, which are listed in the glossary.
|ReviewRelevance=The pattern looks quite relevant for the sensor community.
|ReviewBestPractice=The pattern builds on existing upper-level ontologies, adding a lightweight extra layer. It could thus become a part of best practices.
|ReviewReusability=The pattern is highly generic and thus well-reusable.
|ReviewRelations=There are already some patterns in the catalog that deal with temporality, but not really with capturing information about events.
|ReviewUnderstandability=The pattern is relatively clear. Obviously, its presentation at such small space raises some questions. (I listed them rather in the paper review.)
|ReviewClearProblem=Although the modeling problem is clear, it is not explicitly stated how the pattern would contribute to proper inferencing in an application.
|ReviewClearRelevance=The pattern is relatively simple, and its use doesn't seem to have dramatic consequences.
|ReviewFigures=The figure is OK, except two missing classes. There is an illustrative OWL fragment available. The notation is standard.
|ReviewMissing=Two missing classes in the diagram.
}}

Reviews:VojtechSvatek about PeriodicInterval

2012-08-31T06:58:44Z

VojtechSvatek: New page: {{Content OP Proposal Review Template |CreationDate=2012/8/31 |SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek |ContentOPUnderReview=PeriodicInterval |RevisionID=11172 |Score=0 - needs major revision |ReviewSum...

{{Content OP Proposal Review Template
|CreationDate=2012/8/31
|SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek
|ContentOPUnderReview=PeriodicInterval
|RevisionID=11172
|Score=0 - needs major revision
|ReviewSummary=The problem is important, but needs much more careful and systematic treatment, see below.

|ReviewConfidence=High in ODPs in general; not particularly deep in temporal modelling, yet I believe the pattern is unsophisticated enough for me to confidently evaluate it.
|ReviewProblems=It is necessary to distinguish between 'gap' (the distance between an end and a start, for subintervals) and 'period' (normally, the distance between *two* starts or *two* ends).
In fact, the given pattern could be generalized to that of a periodic interval with regular starts and variable length - e.g. an executive meeting that always starts on Wednesday 1pm but takes as much time as needed. One could even imagine the opposite case, e.g. preparation of coffee for the meeting can start (variably) in advance but always ends when the meeting starts - for it to be drunk suitably warm :-)

In the pattern description it is not even clear if the 'start' and 'end' refer to start/end of the whole non-convex interval (start: Tuesday, x-th January, 2010, 0:00) or of the subinterval (start: Tuesday, 0:00; with year 2010 as externally defined context).
|ReviewRelevance=Highly relevant. Temporal modelling is one of the hottest issues.
|ReviewBestPractice=The alternatives should be explicitly described.
|ReviewReusability=Highly reusable (after thorough revision...).
|ReviewRelations=Missing, although there are other temporal patterns on the portal.
|ReviewUnderstandability=Partial, see the Problems section.
|ReviewClearProblem=Yes
|ReviewClearRelevance=Not quite clear consequences at the moment; alternative solutions should be explored.
|ReviewFigures=OK
|ReviewMissing=See above.
}}

Reviews:VojtechSvatek about Reactor pattern

2012-08-31T06:09:20Z

VojtechSvatek: New page: {{Content OP Proposal Review Template |CreationDate=2012/8/31 |SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek |ContentOPUnderReview=Reactor pattern |RevisionID=11175 |Score=0 - needs major revision |ReviewSumm...

{{Content OP Proposal Review Template
|CreationDate=2012/8/31
|SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek
|ContentOPUnderReview=Reactor pattern
|RevisionID=11175
|Score=0 - needs major revision
|ReviewSummary=On the positive side, the pattern is sound and neatly described.

On the negative side:
- it doesn't bring much novelty, as its design is rather straightforward; it seems to me that an ontology author could, with relatively high probability, use this kind of modelling anyway when dealing with processes in a certain domain
- it doesn't position/link this pattern with respect to related CODPs already in the repository

From the conceptualisation viewpoint, the author doesn't make clear that the pattern is actually meant to model *types* of processes rather than individual processes. This only cames out when looking at the use case.
|ReviewConfidence=I have solid background in ODPs in general. Not particularly in process modelling, however, the pattern doesn't raise any sophisticated issues.
|ReviewProblems=I did not notice any technical problem proper. The modelling seems sound.
|ReviewRelevance=As said above, the pattern is intuitive. Therefore, on the one hand there is no mental threshold for its adoption. On the other hand this decreases its utility, as I would expect that many modellers would use this kind of modelling anyway; the added value then only consists in reusing the 'standard' entities from the portal, which would then be traded off for possible inconvenience when one would need to deviate from the pattern a bit, in a specific setting.
|ReviewBestPractice=Alternative solutions are not discussed.
|ReviewReusability=The reusability is high.
|ReviewRelations=Other relevant CODPs from the portal are neither reused nor discussed.
|ReviewUnderstandability=Good.
|ReviewClearProblem=Clear.
|ReviewClearRelevance=The consequences of pattern use are not properly discussed, as no modelling alternatives are compared.
|ReviewFigures=OK
|ReviewMissing=None aside what mentioned above.
}}

'Ontology Design Patterns':KIELD2010

2010-10-14T16:30:06Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Program */

== Welcome to the 1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data ==

The first Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data is a co-located event with [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010], [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/conference-venue.html held in Lisbon (Portugal)]. It will be held on 15th October 2010.

'''News: [[Odp:KIELD2010#Workshop_Program| Workshop program]] is available.'''

'''News: [http://ftp.informatik.rwth-aachen.de/Publications/CEUR-WS/Vol-631/ CEUR proceedings] is available.'''

__TOC__

== Motivation and objectives ==
The first workshop on Knowledge Injection to and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD2010 at [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010]) will gather three prominent sub-communities of Knowledge Engineering and Management: Knowledge Modelling, Knowledge Discovery and Linked Data. The rapid growth of the Linked Data cloud, in parallel with on-the-fly design of relevant vocabularies, presents new opportunities for traditional research disciplines.

Most notably:
* Although the popular vocabularies reflect today needs, they sometimes lack deeper ontological reflections. State-of-the-art knowledge modelling, especially the pattern-based ontology design principles, could help connect Linked Data vocabularies to more sophisticated models, while keeping themselves simple. Furthermore, collaborative ontology design methodologies could find their way to the process of vocabulary design, currently undertaken by VoCamp communities and stand-alone groups.
* The linked data themselves represent a large and growing resource woven from numerous components. Empirical knowledge discovery in linked data, carried out by machine learning and data mining algorithms, could reveal interesting patterns on frequently used structures, which could then be fuelled back to the vocabulary design. Existing techniques for mining network-structured data, such as graph databases or web links, are likely to require adaptation so as to take account of links that are typed according to semantically rich and heterogeneous schemata.

Aside the [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010] conference itself, the workshop is informally associated with the series of [[WOP:2009|WOP workshops - Workshops on Ontology Patterns]]. Participants of the previous successful WOP (1st edition at ISWC2009) are encouraged to submit to KIELD 2010.

By this interdisciplinary nature KIELD2010 aims at being of high interest for both researchers and practitioners of all three areas mentioned above. Furthermore, it will give space to ongoing and pioneering research activities, which would still be too preliminary as conference publications, although extremely hot as topics in the semantic technology field.

== Key topics ==

The workshop welcomes research, application, and position papers on the following topics (non-exclusive):

=== Ontology engineering for Linked Data ===
* Methodologies
* Ontology patterns extraction
* Ontology patterns identification and discovery
* Pattern-based triplification
* Anti-patterns or worst practices

=== Data mining from Linked Data ===
* Entity recognition
* Link prediction
* Pattern mining
* Sequential patterns
* Rule mining

=== Linked Data in use ===
* Domain applications based-on linked data
* Linked data exploitation
* Interaction with linked data

== Program ==

13.00-13.10 Welcome by Organizers

13.10-14.10 Invited talk (chair: Vojtech Svatek)
* ''Martin Hepp:'' Ontology Engineering for Linked Data: What Makes For A Good Ontology?

14.10-15.20 Session 1 (chair: Aldo Gangemi)
* ''Benjamin Adrian:'' Potentials of enriching the Web of Documents with Linked Data by generating RDFa markup (late breaking news)
* ''Andrea Giovanni Nuzzolese, Aldo Gangemi, Paolo Ciancarini and Valentina Presutti:'' Semion: a smart triplification tool (research paper)
* ''Miroslav Vacura and Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontological Analysis of Human Relations for Semantically Consistent Transformations of FOAF Data (research paper)

15.20-15.50
Coffee break

15.50-16.30 Session 2 (chair: Vojtech Svatek)
* ''Andrea Nuzzolese, Alessandro Adamou:'' Construction of virtual communities by pattern-based WikiNews refactoring. (late breaking news)
* ''Thomas Markotschi and Johanna Voelker:'' GuessWhat?! (research paper)

16:30-17.40 Session 3 (chair: Valentina Presutti)
* ''Miroslav Vacura, Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontology of Ontology Patterns as Linked Data Integration Tool (late breaking news)
* ''Laura Dragan, Alexandre Passant, Tudor Groza and Siegfried Handschuh:'' Linking Personal Semantic Notes (research paper)
* ''Francesco Valle, Mathieu d'Aquin, Tommaso Di Noia and Enrico Motta:'' LOTED: Exploiting Linked Data in Analyzing European Procurement Notices (research paper)

17:40 - 18:00 Wrap-up

== Keynote Talk ==

* ''Martin Hepp:'' Ontology Engineering for Linked Data: What Makes For A Good Ontology?

The talk will discuss the impact of ontology design choices and ontology quality criteria on the overall impact of the linked data initiatives.
In particular, it will analyze whether there are good and bad ontologies from a practical standpoint, what quality criteria will matter the most, and how this relates to the "raw data now" movement in the community.

== Paper Submission ==

Two types of submissions will be accepted: full papers presenting recent research results, and position papers presenting either research in progress or key issues in the scientific discussion.

All submissions have to be formatted according to the Springer LNCS format, in PDF. Full papers are limited to 12 pages and position papers to 6 pages.

== Accepted Papers ==

* ''Laura Dragan, Alexandre Passant, Tudor Groza and Siegfried Handschuh:'' Linking Personal Semantic Notes
* ''Francesco Valle, Mathieu d'Aquin, Tommaso Di Noia and Enrico Motta:'' LOTED: Exploiting Linked Data in Analyzing European Procurement Notices
* ''Thomas Markotschi and Johanna Voelker:'' GuessWhat?!
* ''Miroslav Vacura and Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontological Analysis of Human Relations for Semantically Consistent Transformations of FOAF Data
* ''Andrea Giovanni Nuzzolese, Aldo Gangemi, Paolo Ciancarini and Valentina Presutti:'' Semion: a smart triplification tool
* ''Claudio Baldassarre:'' Semantic Skin: from flat textual content to interconnected repositories of semantic data (Demo paper) '''Withdrawn'''

The accepted papers will be published in workshop notes, under CEUR.

== Late breaking news ==

We invite submissions in the form of 2-pages extended
abstracts in LNCS style presenting work relevant to the workshop topics.
Interesting results to be submitted could be either non-mature promising recent work, or already published results e.g. accepted to another venue (journal or conference).
The goal of the session is to gather the community interested
in the KIELD themes, stimulate discussions, and favor exchange of ideas.
Instead of regular review process, these submissions will
just undergo a relevance check. The abstracts will be part of the
electronic workshop proceedings (CEUR) as a special section.
A short oral presentation from by the authors will be scheduled during the workshop day.

=== Late breaking news Submission ===

Submissions must be sent to [mailto:kield2010@inrialpes.fr KIELD chairs] by August 27th (midnight CET).

== Program Committee ==

* Eva Blomqvist, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Ciro Cattuto, ISI Foundation, Italy
* Claudia d'Amato, University of Bari, Italy
* Mathieu d'Aquin, KMI Open University, UK
* Nicola Fanizzi, University of Bari, Italy
* Aldo Gangemi, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Alfio Gliozzo, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Marko Grobelnik, Jozef Stefan Institute, Slovenia
* Tom Heath, Talis, UK
* Luigi Iannone, Manchester University, UK
* David Jensen, University of Massachusetts Amherst, USA
* Agnieszka Lawrynowicz, Poznan University of Technology, Poland
* Pascal Poncelet, LIRMM, Université Montpellier 2, France
* Marko Rodriguez, AT&T, and Vrije Universiteit Brussels, Belgium
* Steffen Staab, University of Koblenz-Landau, Germany

== Organizers ==

* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR Rome, Italy
* E-mail: valentina.presutti_at_cnr.it

* Francois Scharffe, INRIA Grenoble Rhone-Alpes, France
* E-mail: francois.scharffe_at_inria.fr

* Vojtech Svatek, University of Economics, Prague, Czech Republic
* E-mail: svatek_at_vse.cz

== Important dates ==

*<strike> July 20th: Paper submission deadline (deadline extended) </strike>
*<strike> August 14, 2010: Paper acceptance notification </strike>
* August 27, 2010 (midnight CET): Camera-ready versions of papers
* August 27, 2010 (midnight CET): Late breaking results deadline
* October 15th: Workshop day

[[Category:Event]]
{{Event
|Name=1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD2010)
|HasStartDate=2010/10/15
|HasEndDate=2010/10/15
}}
{{Submission deadline
|deadline=2010/07/21
|expired=The submission deadline has expired!
|intime=You are in time for submitting your paper.
}}

'Ontology Design Patterns':KIELD2010

2010-10-14T10:57:19Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Accepted Papers */

== Welcome to the 1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data ==

The first Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data is a co-located event with [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010], [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/conference-venue.html held in Lisbon (Portugal)]. It will be held on 15th October 2010.

'''News: [http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/wiki/Odp:KIELD2010#Workshop_Program Workshop program] is available.'''

'''News: [http://ftp.informatik.rwth-aachen.de/Publications/CEUR-WS/Vol-631/ CEUR proceedings] is available.'''

__TOC__

== Motivation and objectives ==
The first workshop on Knowledge Injection to and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD2010 at [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010]) will gather three prominent sub-communities of Knowledge Engineering and Management: Knowledge Modelling, Knowledge Discovery and Linked Data. The rapid growth of the Linked Data cloud, in parallel with on-the-fly design of relevant vocabularies, presents new opportunities for traditional research disciplines.

Most notably:
* Although the popular vocabularies reflect today needs, they sometimes lack deeper ontological reflections. State-of-the-art knowledge modelling, especially the pattern-based ontology design principles, could help connect Linked Data vocabularies to more sophisticated models, while keeping themselves simple. Furthermore, collaborative ontology design methodologies could find their way to the process of vocabulary design, currently undertaken by VoCamp communities and stand-alone groups.
* The linked data themselves represent a large and growing resource woven from numerous components. Empirical knowledge discovery in linked data, carried out by machine learning and data mining algorithms, could reveal interesting patterns on frequently used structures, which could then be fuelled back to the vocabulary design. Existing techniques for mining network-structured data, such as graph databases or web links, are likely to require adaptation so as to take account of links that are typed according to semantically rich and heterogeneous schemata.

Aside the [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010] conference itself, the workshop is informally associated with the series of [[WOP:2009|WOP workshops - Workshops on Ontology Patterns]]. Participants of the previous successful WOP (1st edition at ISWC2009) are encouraged to submit to KIELD 2010.

By this interdisciplinary nature KIELD2010 aims at being of high interest for both researchers and practitioners of all three areas mentioned above. Furthermore, it will give space to ongoing and pioneering research activities, which would still be too preliminary as conference publications, although extremely hot as topics in the semantic technology field.

== Key topics ==

The workshop welcomes research, application, and position papers on the following topics (non-exclusive):

=== Ontology engineering for Linked Data ===
* Methodologies
* Ontology patterns extraction
* Ontology patterns identification and discovery
* Pattern-based triplification
* Anti-patterns or worst practices

=== Data mining from Linked Data ===
* Entity recognition
* Link prediction
* Pattern mining
* Sequential patterns
* Rule mining

=== Linked Data in use ===
* Domain applications based-on linked data
* Linked data exploitation
* Interaction with linked data

== Workshop Program ==

13.00-13.15 Welcome by Organizers

13.15-14.15 Invited talk
* ''Martin Hepp:'' Ontology Engineering for Linked Data: What Makes For A Good Ontology?

14.15-15.15 Research papers 1
* ''Andrea Giovanni Nuzzolese, Aldo Gangemi, Paolo Ciancarini and Valentina Presutti:'' Semion: a smart triplification tool
* ''Miroslav Vacura and Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontological Analysis of Human Relations for Semantically Consistent Transformations of FOAF Data

15.15-15.45
Coffee

15.45-17.15 Research papers 2
* ''Laura Dragan, Alexandre Passant, Tudor Groza and Siegfried Handschuh:'' Linking Personal Semantic Notes
* ''Thomas Markotschi and Johanna Voelker:'' GuessWhat?!
* ''Francesco Valle, Mathieu d'Aquin, Tommaso Di Noia and Enrico Motta:'' LOTED: Exploiting Linked Data in Analyzing European Procurement Notices

17.15-17.45 Late breaking news
* ''Benjamin Adrian:'' Potentials of enriching the Web of Documents with Linked Data by generating RDFa markup
* ''Andrea Nuzzolese, Alessandro Adamou:'' Construction of virtual communities by pattern-based WikiNews refactoring. (Due to a problem on the side of the organizers, this text is not included in the workshop notes.)
* ''Miroslav Vacura, Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontology of Ontology Patterns as Linked Data Integration Tool

17:45 - 18:00 Wrap-up
== Keynote Talk ==

* ''Martin Hepp:'' Ontology Engineering for Linked Data: What Makes For A Good Ontology?

The talk will discuss the impact of ontology design choices and ontology quality criteria on the overall impact of the linked data initiatives.
In particular, it will analyze whether there are good and bad ontologies from a practical standpoint, what quality criteria will matter the most, and how this relates to the "raw data now" movement in the community.

== Paper Submission ==

Two types of submissions will be accepted: full papers presenting recent research results, and position papers presenting either research in progress or key issues in the scientific discussion.

All submissions have to be formatted according to the Springer LNCS format, in PDF. Full papers are limited to 12 pages and position papers to 6 pages.

== Accepted Papers ==

* ''Laura Dragan, Alexandre Passant, Tudor Groza and Siegfried Handschuh:'' Linking Personal Semantic Notes
* ''Francesco Valle, Mathieu d'Aquin, Tommaso Di Noia and Enrico Motta:'' LOTED: Exploiting Linked Data in Analyzing European Procurement Notices
* ''Thomas Markotschi and Johanna Voelker:'' GuessWhat?!
* ''Miroslav Vacura and Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontological Analysis of Human Relations for Semantically Consistent Transformations of FOAF Data
* ''Andrea Giovanni Nuzzolese, Aldo Gangemi, Paolo Ciancarini and Valentina Presutti:'' Semion: a smart triplification tool
* ''Claudio Baldassarre:'' Semantic Skin: from flat textual content to interconnected repositories of semantic data (Demo paper) '''Withdrawn'''

The accepted papers will be published in workshop notes, under CEUR.

== Late breaking news ==

We invite submissions in the form of 2-pages extended
abstracts in LNCS style presenting work relevant to the workshop topics.
Interesting results to be submitted could be either non-mature promising recent work, or already published results e.g. accepted to another venue (journal or conference).
The goal of the session is to gather the community interested
in the KIELD themes, stimulate discussions, and favor exchange of ideas.
Instead of regular review process, these submissions will
just undergo a relevance check. The abstracts will be part of the
electronic workshop proceedings (CEUR) as a special section.
A short oral presentation from by the authors will be scheduled during the workshop day.

=== Late breaking news Submission ===

Submissions must be sent to [mailto:kield2010@inrialpes.fr KIELD chairs] by August 27th (midnight CET).

== Program Committee ==

* Eva Blomqvist, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Ciro Cattuto, ISI Foundation, Italy
* Claudia d'Amato, University of Bari, Italy
* Mathieu d'Aquin, KMI Open University, UK
* Nicola Fanizzi, University of Bari, Italy
* Aldo Gangemi, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Alfio Gliozzo, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Marko Grobelnik, Jozef Stefan Institute, Slovenia
* Tom Heath, Talis, UK
* Luigi Iannone, Manchester University, UK
* David Jensen, University of Massachusetts Amherst, USA
* Agnieszka Lawrynowicz, Poznan University of Technology, Poland
* Pascal Poncelet, LIRMM, Université Montpellier 2, France
* Marko Rodriguez, AT&T, and Vrije Universiteit Brussels, Belgium
* Steffen Staab, University of Koblenz-Landau, Germany

== Organizers ==

* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR Rome, Italy
* E-mail: valentina.presutti_at_cnr.it

* Francois Scharffe, INRIA Grenoble Rhone-Alpes, France
* E-mail: francois.scharffe_at_inria.fr

* Vojtech Svatek, University of Economics, Prague, Czech Republic
* E-mail: svatek_at_vse.cz

== Important dates ==

*<strike> July 20th: Paper submission deadline (deadline extended) </strike>
*<strike> August 14, 2010: Paper acceptance notification </strike>
* August 27, 2010 (midnight CET): Camera-ready versions of papers
* August 27, 2010 (midnight CET): Late breaking results deadline
* October 15th: Workshop day

[[Category:Event]]
{{Event
|Name=1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD2010)
|HasStartDate=2010/10/15
|HasEndDate=2010/10/15
}}
{{Submission deadline
|deadline=2010/07/21
|expired=The submission deadline has expired!
|intime=You are in time for submitting your paper.
}}

'Ontology Design Patterns':KIELD2010

2010-10-06T12:49:56Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Welcome to the 1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data */

== Welcome to the 1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data ==

The first Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data is a co-located event with [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010], [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/conference-venue.html held in Lisbon (Portugal)]. It will be held on 15th October 2010.

'''News: [http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/wiki/Odp:KIELD2010#Workshop_Program Workshop program] is available.'''

'''News: [http://ftp.informatik.rwth-aachen.de/Publications/CEUR-WS/Vol-631/ CEUR proceedings] is available.'''

__TOC__

== Motivation and objectives ==
The first workshop on Knowledge Injection to and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD2010 at [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010]) will gather three prominent sub-communities of Knowledge Engineering and Management: Knowledge Modelling, Knowledge Discovery and Linked Data. The rapid growth of the Linked Data cloud, in parallel with on-the-fly design of relevant vocabularies, presents new opportunities for traditional research disciplines.

Most notably:
* Although the popular vocabularies reflect today needs, they sometimes lack deeper ontological reflections. State-of-the-art knowledge modelling, especially the pattern-based ontology design principles, could help connect Linked Data vocabularies to more sophisticated models, while keeping themselves simple. Furthermore, collaborative ontology design methodologies could find their way to the process of vocabulary design, currently undertaken by VoCamp communities and stand-alone groups.
* The linked data themselves represent a large and growing resource woven from numerous components. Empirical knowledge discovery in linked data, carried out by machine learning and data mining algorithms, could reveal interesting patterns on frequently used structures, which could then be fuelled back to the vocabulary design. Existing techniques for mining network-structured data, such as graph databases or web links, are likely to require adaptation so as to take account of links that are typed according to semantically rich and heterogeneous schemata.

Aside the [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010] conference itself, the workshop is informally associated with the series of [[WOP:2009|WOP workshops - Workshops on Ontology Patterns]]. Participants of the previous successful WOP (1st edition at ISWC2009) are encouraged to submit to KIELD 2010.

By this interdisciplinary nature KIELD2010 aims at being of high interest for both researchers and practitioners of all three areas mentioned above. Furthermore, it will give space to ongoing and pioneering research activities, which would still be too preliminary as conference publications, although extremely hot as topics in the semantic technology field.

== Key topics ==

The workshop welcomes research, application, and position papers on the following topics (non-exclusive):

=== Ontology engineering for Linked Data ===
* Methodologies
* Ontology patterns extraction
* Ontology patterns identification and discovery
* Pattern-based triplification
* Anti-patterns or worst practices

=== Data mining from Linked Data ===
* Entity recognition
* Link prediction
* Pattern mining
* Sequential patterns
* Rule mining

=== Linked Data in use ===
* Domain applications based-on linked data
* Linked data exploitation
* Interaction with linked data

== Workshop Program ==

13.00-13.15 Welcome by Organizers

13.15-14.15 Invited talk
* ''Martin Hepp:'' Ontology Engineering for Linked Data: What Makes For A Good Ontology?

14.15-15.15 Research papers 1
* ''Andrea Giovanni Nuzzolese, Aldo Gangemi, Paolo Ciancarini and Valentina Presutti:'' Semion: a smart triplification tool
* ''Miroslav Vacura and Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontological Analysis of Human Relations for Semantically Consistent Transformations of FOAF Data

15.15-15.45
Coffee

15.45-17.15 Research papers 2
* ''Laura Dragan, Alexandre Passant, Tudor Groza and Siegfried Handschuh:'' Linking Personal Semantic Notes
* ''Thomas Markotschi and Johanna Voelker:'' GuessWhat?!
* ''Francesco Valle, Mathieu d'Aquin, Tommaso Di Noia and Enrico Motta:'' LOTED: Exploiting Linked Data in Analyzing European Procurement Notices

17.15-17.45 Late breaking news
* ''Benjamin Adrian:'' Potentials of enriching the Web of Documents with Linked Data by generating RDFa markup
* ''Andrea Nuzzolese, Alessandro Adamou:'' Construction of virtual communities by pattern-based WikiNews refactoring. (Due to a problem on the side of the organizers, this text is not included in the workshop notes.)
* ''Miroslav Vacura, Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontology of Ontology Patterns as Linked Data Integration Tool

17:45 - 18:00 Wrap-up
== Keynote Talk ==

* ''Martin Hepp:'' Ontology Engineering for Linked Data: What Makes For A Good Ontology?

The talk will discuss the impact of ontology design choices and ontology quality criteria on the overall impact of the linked data initiatives.
In particular, it will analyze whether there are good and bad ontologies from a practical standpoint, what quality criteria will matter the most, and how this relates to the "raw data now" movement in the community.

== Paper Submission ==

Two types of submissions will be accepted: full papers presenting recent research results, and position papers presenting either research in progress or key issues in the scientific discussion.

All submissions have to be formatted according to the Springer LNCS format, in PDF. Full papers are limited to 12 pages and position papers to 6 pages.

== Accepted Papers ==

* ''Laura Dragan, Alexandre Passant, Tudor Groza and Siegfried Handschuh:'' Linking Personal Semantic Notes
* ''Francesco Valle, Mathieu d'Aquin, Tommaso Di Noia and Enrico Motta:'' LOTED: Exploiting Linked Data in Analyzing European Procurement Notices
* ''Thomas Markotschi and Johanna Voelker:'' GuessWhat?!
* ''Miroslav Vacura and Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontological Analysis of Human Relations for Semantically Consistent Transformations of FOAF Data
* ''Andrea Giovanni Nuzzolese, Aldo Gangemi, Paolo Ciancarini and Valentina Presutti:'' Semion: a smart triplification tool
* ''Claudio Baldassarre:'' Semantic Skin: from flat textual content to interconnected repositories of semantic data (Demo paper)

The accepted papers will be published in workshop notes, under CEUR.

== Late breaking news ==

We invite submissions in the form of 2-pages extended
abstracts in LNCS style presenting work relevant to the workshop topics.
Interesting results to be submitted could be either non-mature promising recent work, or already published results e.g. accepted to another venue (journal or conference).
The goal of the session is to gather the community interested
in the KIELD themes, stimulate discussions, and favor exchange of ideas.
Instead of regular review process, these submissions will
just undergo a relevance check. The abstracts will be part of the
electronic workshop proceedings (CEUR) as a special section.
A short oral presentation from by the authors will be scheduled during the workshop day.

=== Late breaking news Submission ===

Submissions must be sent to [mailto:kield2010@inrialpes.fr KIELD chairs] by August 27th (midnight CET).

== Program Committee ==

* Eva Blomqvist, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Ciro Cattuto, ISI Foundation, Italy
* Claudia d'Amato, University of Bari, Italy
* Mathieu d'Aquin, KMI Open University, UK
* Nicola Fanizzi, University of Bari, Italy
* Aldo Gangemi, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Alfio Gliozzo, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Marko Grobelnik, Jozef Stefan Institute, Slovenia
* Tom Heath, Talis, UK
* Luigi Iannone, Manchester University, UK
* David Jensen, University of Massachusetts Amherst, USA
* Agnieszka Lawrynowicz, Poznan University of Technology, Poland
* Pascal Poncelet, LIRMM, Université Montpellier 2, France
* Marko Rodriguez, AT&T, and Vrije Universiteit Brussels, Belgium
* Steffen Staab, University of Koblenz-Landau, Germany

== Organizers ==

* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR Rome, Italy
* E-mail: valentina.presutti_at_cnr.it

* Francois Scharffe, INRIA Grenoble Rhone-Alpes, France
* E-mail: francois.scharffe_at_inria.fr

* Vojtech Svatek, University of Economics, Prague, Czech Republic
* E-mail: svatek_at_vse.cz

== Important dates ==

*<strike> July 20th: Paper submission deadline (deadline extended) </strike>
*<strike> August 14, 2010: Paper acceptance notification </strike>
* August 27, 2010 (midnight CET): Camera-ready versions of papers
* August 27, 2010 (midnight CET): Late breaking results deadline
* October 15th: Workshop day

[[Category:Event]]
{{Event
|Name=1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD2010)
|HasStartDate=2010/10/15
|HasEndDate=2010/10/15
}}
{{Submission deadline
|deadline=2010/07/21
|expired=The submission deadline has expired!
|intime=You are in time for submitting your paper.
}}

'Ontology Design Patterns':KIELD2010

2010-10-06T12:49:38Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Welcome to the 1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data */

== Welcome to the 1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data ==

The first Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data is a co-located event with [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010], [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/conference-venue.html held in Lisbon (Portugal)]. It will be held on 15th October 2010.

'''News: [http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/wiki/Odp:KIELD2010#Workshop_Program Workshop program] is available.'''
'''News: [http://ftp.informatik.rwth-aachen.de/Publications/CEUR-WS/Vol-631/ CEUR proceedings] is available.'''

__TOC__

== Motivation and objectives ==
The first workshop on Knowledge Injection to and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD2010 at [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010]) will gather three prominent sub-communities of Knowledge Engineering and Management: Knowledge Modelling, Knowledge Discovery and Linked Data. The rapid growth of the Linked Data cloud, in parallel with on-the-fly design of relevant vocabularies, presents new opportunities for traditional research disciplines.

Most notably:
* Although the popular vocabularies reflect today needs, they sometimes lack deeper ontological reflections. State-of-the-art knowledge modelling, especially the pattern-based ontology design principles, could help connect Linked Data vocabularies to more sophisticated models, while keeping themselves simple. Furthermore, collaborative ontology design methodologies could find their way to the process of vocabulary design, currently undertaken by VoCamp communities and stand-alone groups.
* The linked data themselves represent a large and growing resource woven from numerous components. Empirical knowledge discovery in linked data, carried out by machine learning and data mining algorithms, could reveal interesting patterns on frequently used structures, which could then be fuelled back to the vocabulary design. Existing techniques for mining network-structured data, such as graph databases or web links, are likely to require adaptation so as to take account of links that are typed according to semantically rich and heterogeneous schemata.

Aside the [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010] conference itself, the workshop is informally associated with the series of [[WOP:2009|WOP workshops - Workshops on Ontology Patterns]]. Participants of the previous successful WOP (1st edition at ISWC2009) are encouraged to submit to KIELD 2010.

By this interdisciplinary nature KIELD2010 aims at being of high interest for both researchers and practitioners of all three areas mentioned above. Furthermore, it will give space to ongoing and pioneering research activities, which would still be too preliminary as conference publications, although extremely hot as topics in the semantic technology field.

== Key topics ==

The workshop welcomes research, application, and position papers on the following topics (non-exclusive):

=== Ontology engineering for Linked Data ===
* Methodologies
* Ontology patterns extraction
* Ontology patterns identification and discovery
* Pattern-based triplification
* Anti-patterns or worst practices

=== Data mining from Linked Data ===
* Entity recognition
* Link prediction
* Pattern mining
* Sequential patterns
* Rule mining

=== Linked Data in use ===
* Domain applications based-on linked data
* Linked data exploitation
* Interaction with linked data

== Workshop Program ==

13.00-13.15 Welcome by Organizers

13.15-14.15 Invited talk
* ''Martin Hepp:'' Ontology Engineering for Linked Data: What Makes For A Good Ontology?

14.15-15.15 Research papers 1
* ''Andrea Giovanni Nuzzolese, Aldo Gangemi, Paolo Ciancarini and Valentina Presutti:'' Semion: a smart triplification tool
* ''Miroslav Vacura and Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontological Analysis of Human Relations for Semantically Consistent Transformations of FOAF Data

15.15-15.45
Coffee

15.45-17.15 Research papers 2
* ''Laura Dragan, Alexandre Passant, Tudor Groza and Siegfried Handschuh:'' Linking Personal Semantic Notes
* ''Thomas Markotschi and Johanna Voelker:'' GuessWhat?!
* ''Francesco Valle, Mathieu d'Aquin, Tommaso Di Noia and Enrico Motta:'' LOTED: Exploiting Linked Data in Analyzing European Procurement Notices

17.15-17.45 Late breaking news
* ''Benjamin Adrian:'' Potentials of enriching the Web of Documents with Linked Data by generating RDFa markup
* ''Andrea Nuzzolese, Alessandro Adamou:'' Construction of virtual communities by pattern-based WikiNews refactoring. (Due to a problem on the side of the organizers, this text is not included in the workshop notes.)
* ''Miroslav Vacura, Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontology of Ontology Patterns as Linked Data Integration Tool

17:45 - 18:00 Wrap-up
== Keynote Talk ==

* ''Martin Hepp:'' Ontology Engineering for Linked Data: What Makes For A Good Ontology?

The talk will discuss the impact of ontology design choices and ontology quality criteria on the overall impact of the linked data initiatives.
In particular, it will analyze whether there are good and bad ontologies from a practical standpoint, what quality criteria will matter the most, and how this relates to the "raw data now" movement in the community.

== Paper Submission ==

Two types of submissions will be accepted: full papers presenting recent research results, and position papers presenting either research in progress or key issues in the scientific discussion.

All submissions have to be formatted according to the Springer LNCS format, in PDF. Full papers are limited to 12 pages and position papers to 6 pages.

== Accepted Papers ==

* ''Laura Dragan, Alexandre Passant, Tudor Groza and Siegfried Handschuh:'' Linking Personal Semantic Notes
* ''Francesco Valle, Mathieu d'Aquin, Tommaso Di Noia and Enrico Motta:'' LOTED: Exploiting Linked Data in Analyzing European Procurement Notices
* ''Thomas Markotschi and Johanna Voelker:'' GuessWhat?!
* ''Miroslav Vacura and Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontological Analysis of Human Relations for Semantically Consistent Transformations of FOAF Data
* ''Andrea Giovanni Nuzzolese, Aldo Gangemi, Paolo Ciancarini and Valentina Presutti:'' Semion: a smart triplification tool
* ''Claudio Baldassarre:'' Semantic Skin: from flat textual content to interconnected repositories of semantic data (Demo paper)

The accepted papers will be published in workshop notes, under CEUR.

== Late breaking news ==

We invite submissions in the form of 2-pages extended
abstracts in LNCS style presenting work relevant to the workshop topics.
Interesting results to be submitted could be either non-mature promising recent work, or already published results e.g. accepted to another venue (journal or conference).
The goal of the session is to gather the community interested
in the KIELD themes, stimulate discussions, and favor exchange of ideas.
Instead of regular review process, these submissions will
just undergo a relevance check. The abstracts will be part of the
electronic workshop proceedings (CEUR) as a special section.
A short oral presentation from by the authors will be scheduled during the workshop day.

=== Late breaking news Submission ===

Submissions must be sent to [mailto:kield2010@inrialpes.fr KIELD chairs] by August 27th (midnight CET).

== Program Committee ==

* Eva Blomqvist, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Ciro Cattuto, ISI Foundation, Italy
* Claudia d'Amato, University of Bari, Italy
* Mathieu d'Aquin, KMI Open University, UK
* Nicola Fanizzi, University of Bari, Italy
* Aldo Gangemi, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Alfio Gliozzo, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Marko Grobelnik, Jozef Stefan Institute, Slovenia
* Tom Heath, Talis, UK
* Luigi Iannone, Manchester University, UK
* David Jensen, University of Massachusetts Amherst, USA
* Agnieszka Lawrynowicz, Poznan University of Technology, Poland
* Pascal Poncelet, LIRMM, Université Montpellier 2, France
* Marko Rodriguez, AT&T, and Vrije Universiteit Brussels, Belgium
* Steffen Staab, University of Koblenz-Landau, Germany

== Organizers ==

* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR Rome, Italy
* E-mail: valentina.presutti_at_cnr.it

* Francois Scharffe, INRIA Grenoble Rhone-Alpes, France
* E-mail: francois.scharffe_at_inria.fr

* Vojtech Svatek, University of Economics, Prague, Czech Republic
* E-mail: svatek_at_vse.cz

== Important dates ==

*<strike> July 20th: Paper submission deadline (deadline extended) </strike>
*<strike> August 14, 2010: Paper acceptance notification </strike>
* August 27, 2010 (midnight CET): Camera-ready versions of papers
* August 27, 2010 (midnight CET): Late breaking results deadline
* October 15th: Workshop day

[[Category:Event]]
{{Event
|Name=1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD2010)
|HasStartDate=2010/10/15
|HasEndDate=2010/10/15
}}
{{Submission deadline
|deadline=2010/07/21
|expired=The submission deadline has expired!
|intime=You are in time for submitting your paper.
}}

'Ontology Design Patterns':KIELD2010

2010-10-06T12:38:09Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Welcome to the 1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data */

== Welcome to the 1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data ==

The first Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data is a co-located event with [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010], [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/conference-venue.html held in Lisbon (Portugal)]. It will be held on 15th October 2010.

'''News: [http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/wiki/Odp:KIELD2010#Workshop_Program Workshop program] is available.'''

__TOC__

== Motivation and objectives ==
The first workshop on Knowledge Injection to and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD2010 at [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010]) will gather three prominent sub-communities of Knowledge Engineering and Management: Knowledge Modelling, Knowledge Discovery and Linked Data. The rapid growth of the Linked Data cloud, in parallel with on-the-fly design of relevant vocabularies, presents new opportunities for traditional research disciplines.

Most notably:
* Although the popular vocabularies reflect today needs, they sometimes lack deeper ontological reflections. State-of-the-art knowledge modelling, especially the pattern-based ontology design principles, could help connect Linked Data vocabularies to more sophisticated models, while keeping themselves simple. Furthermore, collaborative ontology design methodologies could find their way to the process of vocabulary design, currently undertaken by VoCamp communities and stand-alone groups.
* The linked data themselves represent a large and growing resource woven from numerous components. Empirical knowledge discovery in linked data, carried out by machine learning and data mining algorithms, could reveal interesting patterns on frequently used structures, which could then be fuelled back to the vocabulary design. Existing techniques for mining network-structured data, such as graph databases or web links, are likely to require adaptation so as to take account of links that are typed according to semantically rich and heterogeneous schemata.

Aside the [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010] conference itself, the workshop is informally associated with the series of [[WOP:2009|WOP workshops - Workshops on Ontology Patterns]]. Participants of the previous successful WOP (1st edition at ISWC2009) are encouraged to submit to KIELD 2010.

By this interdisciplinary nature KIELD2010 aims at being of high interest for both researchers and practitioners of all three areas mentioned above. Furthermore, it will give space to ongoing and pioneering research activities, which would still be too preliminary as conference publications, although extremely hot as topics in the semantic technology field.

== Key topics ==

The workshop welcomes research, application, and position papers on the following topics (non-exclusive):

=== Ontology engineering for Linked Data ===
* Methodologies
* Ontology patterns extraction
* Ontology patterns identification and discovery
* Pattern-based triplification
* Anti-patterns or worst practices

=== Data mining from Linked Data ===
* Entity recognition
* Link prediction
* Pattern mining
* Sequential patterns
* Rule mining

=== Linked Data in use ===
* Domain applications based-on linked data
* Linked data exploitation
* Interaction with linked data

== Workshop Program ==

13.00-13.15 Welcome by Organizers

13.15-14.15 Invited talk
* ''Martin Hepp:'' Ontology Engineering for Linked Data: What Makes For A Good Ontology?

14.15-15.15 Research papers 1
* ''Andrea Giovanni Nuzzolese, Aldo Gangemi, Paolo Ciancarini and Valentina Presutti:'' Semion: a smart triplification tool
* ''Miroslav Vacura and Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontological Analysis of Human Relations for Semantically Consistent Transformations of FOAF Data

15.15-15.45
Coffee

15.45-17.15 Research papers 2
* ''Laura Dragan, Alexandre Passant, Tudor Groza and Siegfried Handschuh:'' Linking Personal Semantic Notes
* ''Thomas Markotschi and Johanna Voelker:'' GuessWhat?!
* ''Francesco Valle, Mathieu d'Aquin, Tommaso Di Noia and Enrico Motta:'' LOTED: Exploiting Linked Data in Analyzing European Procurement Notices

17.15-17.45 Late breaking news
* ''Benjamin Adrian:'' Potentials of enriching the Web of Documents with Linked Data by generating RDFa markup
* ''Andrea Nuzzolese, Alessandro Adamou:'' Construction of virtual communities by pattern-based WikiNews refactoring. (Due to a problem on the side of the organizers, this text is not included in the workshop notes.)
* ''Miroslav Vacura, Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontology of Ontology Patterns as Linked Data Integration Tool

17:45 - 18:00 Wrap-up
== Keynote Talk ==

* ''Martin Hepp:'' Ontology Engineering for Linked Data: What Makes For A Good Ontology?

The talk will discuss the impact of ontology design choices and ontology quality criteria on the overall impact of the linked data initiatives.
In particular, it will analyze whether there are good and bad ontologies from a practical standpoint, what quality criteria will matter the most, and how this relates to the "raw data now" movement in the community.

== Paper Submission ==

Two types of submissions will be accepted: full papers presenting recent research results, and position papers presenting either research in progress or key issues in the scientific discussion.

All submissions have to be formatted according to the Springer LNCS format, in PDF. Full papers are limited to 12 pages and position papers to 6 pages.

== Accepted Papers ==

* ''Laura Dragan, Alexandre Passant, Tudor Groza and Siegfried Handschuh:'' Linking Personal Semantic Notes
* ''Francesco Valle, Mathieu d'Aquin, Tommaso Di Noia and Enrico Motta:'' LOTED: Exploiting Linked Data in Analyzing European Procurement Notices
* ''Thomas Markotschi and Johanna Voelker:'' GuessWhat?!
* ''Miroslav Vacura and Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontological Analysis of Human Relations for Semantically Consistent Transformations of FOAF Data
* ''Andrea Giovanni Nuzzolese, Aldo Gangemi, Paolo Ciancarini and Valentina Presutti:'' Semion: a smart triplification tool
* ''Claudio Baldassarre:'' Semantic Skin: from flat textual content to interconnected repositories of semantic data (Demo paper)

The accepted papers will be published in workshop notes, under CEUR.

== Late breaking news ==

We invite submissions in the form of 2-pages extended
abstracts in LNCS style presenting work relevant to the workshop topics.
Interesting results to be submitted could be either non-mature promising recent work, or already published results e.g. accepted to another venue (journal or conference).
The goal of the session is to gather the community interested
in the KIELD themes, stimulate discussions, and favor exchange of ideas.
Instead of regular review process, these submissions will
just undergo a relevance check. The abstracts will be part of the
electronic workshop proceedings (CEUR) as a special section.
A short oral presentation from by the authors will be scheduled during the workshop day.

=== Late breaking news Submission ===

Submissions must be sent to [mailto:kield2010@inrialpes.fr KIELD chairs] by August 27th (midnight CET).

== Program Committee ==

* Eva Blomqvist, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Ciro Cattuto, ISI Foundation, Italy
* Claudia d'Amato, University of Bari, Italy
* Mathieu d'Aquin, KMI Open University, UK
* Nicola Fanizzi, University of Bari, Italy
* Aldo Gangemi, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Alfio Gliozzo, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Marko Grobelnik, Jozef Stefan Institute, Slovenia
* Tom Heath, Talis, UK
* Luigi Iannone, Manchester University, UK
* David Jensen, University of Massachusetts Amherst, USA
* Agnieszka Lawrynowicz, Poznan University of Technology, Poland
* Pascal Poncelet, LIRMM, Université Montpellier 2, France
* Marko Rodriguez, AT&T, and Vrije Universiteit Brussels, Belgium
* Steffen Staab, University of Koblenz-Landau, Germany

== Organizers ==

* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR Rome, Italy
* E-mail: valentina.presutti_at_cnr.it

* Francois Scharffe, INRIA Grenoble Rhone-Alpes, France
* E-mail: francois.scharffe_at_inria.fr

* Vojtech Svatek, University of Economics, Prague, Czech Republic
* E-mail: svatek_at_vse.cz

== Important dates ==

*<strike> July 20th: Paper submission deadline (deadline extended) </strike>
*<strike> August 14, 2010: Paper acceptance notification </strike>
* August 27, 2010 (midnight CET): Camera-ready versions of papers
* August 27, 2010 (midnight CET): Late breaking results deadline
* October 15th: Workshop day

[[Category:Event]]
{{Event
|Name=1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD2010)
|HasStartDate=2010/10/15
|HasEndDate=2010/10/15
}}
{{Submission deadline
|deadline=2010/07/21
|expired=The submission deadline has expired!
|intime=You are in time for submitting your paper.
}}

'Ontology Design Patterns':KIELD2010

2010-10-06T12:37:07Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Welcome to the 1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data */

== Welcome to the 1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data ==

The first workshop on knowledge injection into and extraction from linked data is a co-located event with [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010], [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/conference-venue.html held in Lisbon (Portugal)]. It will be held on 15th October 2010.

'''News: [http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/wiki/Odp:KIELD2010#Workshop_program] is available.'''

__TOC__

== Motivation and objectives ==
The first workshop on Knowledge Injection to and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD2010 at [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010]) will gather three prominent sub-communities of Knowledge Engineering and Management: Knowledge Modelling, Knowledge Discovery and Linked Data. The rapid growth of the Linked Data cloud, in parallel with on-the-fly design of relevant vocabularies, presents new opportunities for traditional research disciplines.

Most notably:
* Although the popular vocabularies reflect today needs, they sometimes lack deeper ontological reflections. State-of-the-art knowledge modelling, especially the pattern-based ontology design principles, could help connect Linked Data vocabularies to more sophisticated models, while keeping themselves simple. Furthermore, collaborative ontology design methodologies could find their way to the process of vocabulary design, currently undertaken by VoCamp communities and stand-alone groups.
* The linked data themselves represent a large and growing resource woven from numerous components. Empirical knowledge discovery in linked data, carried out by machine learning and data mining algorithms, could reveal interesting patterns on frequently used structures, which could then be fuelled back to the vocabulary design. Existing techniques for mining network-structured data, such as graph databases or web links, are likely to require adaptation so as to take account of links that are typed according to semantically rich and heterogeneous schemata.

Aside the [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010] conference itself, the workshop is informally associated with the series of [[WOP:2009|WOP workshops - Workshops on Ontology Patterns]]. Participants of the previous successful WOP (1st edition at ISWC2009) are encouraged to submit to KIELD 2010.

By this interdisciplinary nature KIELD2010 aims at being of high interest for both researchers and practitioners of all three areas mentioned above. Furthermore, it will give space to ongoing and pioneering research activities, which would still be too preliminary as conference publications, although extremely hot as topics in the semantic technology field.

== Key topics ==

The workshop welcomes research, application, and position papers on the following topics (non-exclusive):

=== Ontology engineering for Linked Data ===
* Methodologies
* Ontology patterns extraction
* Ontology patterns identification and discovery
* Pattern-based triplification
* Anti-patterns or worst practices

=== Data mining from Linked Data ===
* Entity recognition
* Link prediction
* Pattern mining
* Sequential patterns
* Rule mining

=== Linked Data in use ===
* Domain applications based-on linked data
* Linked data exploitation
* Interaction with linked data

== Workshop Program ==

13.00-13.15 Welcome by Organizers

13.15-14.15 Invited talk
* ''Martin Hepp:'' Ontology Engineering for Linked Data: What Makes For A Good Ontology?

14.15-15.15 Research papers 1
* ''Andrea Giovanni Nuzzolese, Aldo Gangemi, Paolo Ciancarini and Valentina Presutti:'' Semion: a smart triplification tool
* ''Miroslav Vacura and Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontological Analysis of Human Relations for Semantically Consistent Transformations of FOAF Data

15.15-15.45
Coffee

15.45-17.15 Research papers 2
* ''Laura Dragan, Alexandre Passant, Tudor Groza and Siegfried Handschuh:'' Linking Personal Semantic Notes
* ''Thomas Markotschi and Johanna Voelker:'' GuessWhat?!
* ''Francesco Valle, Mathieu d'Aquin, Tommaso Di Noia and Enrico Motta:'' LOTED: Exploiting Linked Data in Analyzing European Procurement Notices

17.15-17.45 Late breaking news
* ''Benjamin Adrian:'' Potentials of enriching the Web of Documents with Linked Data by generating RDFa markup
* ''Andrea Nuzzolese, Alessandro Adamou:'' Construction of virtual communities by pattern-based WikiNews refactoring. (Due to a problem on the side of the organizers, this text is not included in the workshop notes.)
* ''Miroslav Vacura, Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontology of Ontology Patterns as Linked Data Integration Tool

17:45 - 18:00 Wrap-up
== Keynote Talk ==

* ''Martin Hepp:'' Ontology Engineering for Linked Data: What Makes For A Good Ontology?

The talk will discuss the impact of ontology design choices and ontology quality criteria on the overall impact of the linked data initiatives.
In particular, it will analyze whether there are good and bad ontologies from a practical standpoint, what quality criteria will matter the most, and how this relates to the "raw data now" movement in the community.

== Paper Submission ==

Two types of submissions will be accepted: full papers presenting recent research results, and position papers presenting either research in progress or key issues in the scientific discussion.

All submissions have to be formatted according to the Springer LNCS format, in PDF. Full papers are limited to 12 pages and position papers to 6 pages.

== Accepted Papers ==

* ''Laura Dragan, Alexandre Passant, Tudor Groza and Siegfried Handschuh:'' Linking Personal Semantic Notes
* ''Francesco Valle, Mathieu d'Aquin, Tommaso Di Noia and Enrico Motta:'' LOTED: Exploiting Linked Data in Analyzing European Procurement Notices
* ''Thomas Markotschi and Johanna Voelker:'' GuessWhat?!
* ''Miroslav Vacura and Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontological Analysis of Human Relations for Semantically Consistent Transformations of FOAF Data
* ''Andrea Giovanni Nuzzolese, Aldo Gangemi, Paolo Ciancarini and Valentina Presutti:'' Semion: a smart triplification tool
* ''Claudio Baldassarre:'' Semantic Skin: from flat textual content to interconnected repositories of semantic data (Demo paper)

The accepted papers will be published in workshop notes, under CEUR.

== Late breaking news ==

We invite submissions in the form of 2-pages extended
abstracts in LNCS style presenting work relevant to the workshop topics.
Interesting results to be submitted could be either non-mature promising recent work, or already published results e.g. accepted to another venue (journal or conference).
The goal of the session is to gather the community interested
in the KIELD themes, stimulate discussions, and favor exchange of ideas.
Instead of regular review process, these submissions will
just undergo a relevance check. The abstracts will be part of the
electronic workshop proceedings (CEUR) as a special section.
A short oral presentation from by the authors will be scheduled during the workshop day.

=== Late breaking news Submission ===

Submissions must be sent to [mailto:kield2010@inrialpes.fr KIELD chairs] by August 27th (midnight CET).

== Program Committee ==

* Eva Blomqvist, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Ciro Cattuto, ISI Foundation, Italy
* Claudia d'Amato, University of Bari, Italy
* Mathieu d'Aquin, KMI Open University, UK
* Nicola Fanizzi, University of Bari, Italy
* Aldo Gangemi, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Alfio Gliozzo, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Marko Grobelnik, Jozef Stefan Institute, Slovenia
* Tom Heath, Talis, UK
* Luigi Iannone, Manchester University, UK
* David Jensen, University of Massachusetts Amherst, USA
* Agnieszka Lawrynowicz, Poznan University of Technology, Poland
* Pascal Poncelet, LIRMM, Université Montpellier 2, France
* Marko Rodriguez, AT&T, and Vrije Universiteit Brussels, Belgium
* Steffen Staab, University of Koblenz-Landau, Germany

== Organizers ==

* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR Rome, Italy
* E-mail: valentina.presutti_at_cnr.it

* Francois Scharffe, INRIA Grenoble Rhone-Alpes, France
* E-mail: francois.scharffe_at_inria.fr

* Vojtech Svatek, University of Economics, Prague, Czech Republic
* E-mail: svatek_at_vse.cz

== Important dates ==

*<strike> July 20th: Paper submission deadline (deadline extended) </strike>
*<strike> August 14, 2010: Paper acceptance notification </strike>
* August 27, 2010 (midnight CET): Camera-ready versions of papers
* August 27, 2010 (midnight CET): Late breaking results deadline
* October 15th: Workshop day

[[Category:Event]]
{{Event
|Name=1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD2010)
|HasStartDate=2010/10/15
|HasEndDate=2010/10/15
}}
{{Submission deadline
|deadline=2010/07/21
|expired=The submission deadline has expired!
|intime=You are in time for submitting your paper.
}}

'Ontology Design Patterns':KIELD2010

2010-10-06T12:35:37Z

VojtechSvatek: program added

== Welcome to the 1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data ==

The first workshop on knowledge injection into and extraction from linked data is a co-located event with [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010], [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/conference-venue.html held in Lisbon (Portugal)] on October 2010.

'''News: The list of [http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/wiki/Odp:KIELD2010#Accepted_Papers accepted papers] is available.'''

'''News: The workshop date has been fixed to October 15th, afternoon.'''

'''Martin Hepp will give a [http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/wiki/Odp:KIELD2010#Keynote_Talk keynote talk] at KIELD 2010'''

__TOC__

== Motivation and objectives ==
The first workshop on Knowledge Injection to and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD2010 at [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010]) will gather three prominent sub-communities of Knowledge Engineering and Management: Knowledge Modelling, Knowledge Discovery and Linked Data. The rapid growth of the Linked Data cloud, in parallel with on-the-fly design of relevant vocabularies, presents new opportunities for traditional research disciplines.

Most notably:
* Although the popular vocabularies reflect today needs, they sometimes lack deeper ontological reflections. State-of-the-art knowledge modelling, especially the pattern-based ontology design principles, could help connect Linked Data vocabularies to more sophisticated models, while keeping themselves simple. Furthermore, collaborative ontology design methodologies could find their way to the process of vocabulary design, currently undertaken by VoCamp communities and stand-alone groups.
* The linked data themselves represent a large and growing resource woven from numerous components. Empirical knowledge discovery in linked data, carried out by machine learning and data mining algorithms, could reveal interesting patterns on frequently used structures, which could then be fuelled back to the vocabulary design. Existing techniques for mining network-structured data, such as graph databases or web links, are likely to require adaptation so as to take account of links that are typed according to semantically rich and heterogeneous schemata.

Aside the [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010] conference itself, the workshop is informally associated with the series of [[WOP:2009|WOP workshops - Workshops on Ontology Patterns]]. Participants of the previous successful WOP (1st edition at ISWC2009) are encouraged to submit to KIELD 2010.

By this interdisciplinary nature KIELD2010 aims at being of high interest for both researchers and practitioners of all three areas mentioned above. Furthermore, it will give space to ongoing and pioneering research activities, which would still be too preliminary as conference publications, although extremely hot as topics in the semantic technology field.

== Key topics ==

The workshop welcomes research, application, and position papers on the following topics (non-exclusive):

=== Ontology engineering for Linked Data ===
* Methodologies
* Ontology patterns extraction
* Ontology patterns identification and discovery
* Pattern-based triplification
* Anti-patterns or worst practices

=== Data mining from Linked Data ===
* Entity recognition
* Link prediction
* Pattern mining
* Sequential patterns
* Rule mining

=== Linked Data in use ===
* Domain applications based-on linked data
* Linked data exploitation
* Interaction with linked data

== Workshop Program ==

13.00-13.15 Welcome by Organizers

13.15-14.15 Invited talk
* ''Martin Hepp:'' Ontology Engineering for Linked Data: What Makes For A Good Ontology?

14.15-15.15 Research papers 1
* ''Andrea Giovanni Nuzzolese, Aldo Gangemi, Paolo Ciancarini and Valentina Presutti:'' Semion: a smart triplification tool
* ''Miroslav Vacura and Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontological Analysis of Human Relations for Semantically Consistent Transformations of FOAF Data

15.15-15.45
Coffee

15.45-17.15 Research papers 2
* ''Laura Dragan, Alexandre Passant, Tudor Groza and Siegfried Handschuh:'' Linking Personal Semantic Notes
* ''Thomas Markotschi and Johanna Voelker:'' GuessWhat?!
* ''Francesco Valle, Mathieu d'Aquin, Tommaso Di Noia and Enrico Motta:'' LOTED: Exploiting Linked Data in Analyzing European Procurement Notices

17.15-17.45 Late breaking news
* ''Benjamin Adrian:'' Potentials of enriching the Web of Documents with Linked Data by generating RDFa markup
* ''Andrea Nuzzolese, Alessandro Adamou:'' Construction of virtual communities by pattern-based WikiNews refactoring. (Due to a problem on the side of the organizers, this text is not included in the workshop notes.)
* ''Miroslav Vacura, Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontology of Ontology Patterns as Linked Data Integration Tool

17:45 - 18:00 Wrap-up
== Keynote Talk ==

* ''Martin Hepp:'' Ontology Engineering for Linked Data: What Makes For A Good Ontology?

The talk will discuss the impact of ontology design choices and ontology quality criteria on the overall impact of the linked data initiatives.
In particular, it will analyze whether there are good and bad ontologies from a practical standpoint, what quality criteria will matter the most, and how this relates to the "raw data now" movement in the community.

== Paper Submission ==

Two types of submissions will be accepted: full papers presenting recent research results, and position papers presenting either research in progress or key issues in the scientific discussion.

All submissions have to be formatted according to the Springer LNCS format, in PDF. Full papers are limited to 12 pages and position papers to 6 pages.

== Accepted Papers ==

* ''Laura Dragan, Alexandre Passant, Tudor Groza and Siegfried Handschuh:'' Linking Personal Semantic Notes
* ''Francesco Valle, Mathieu d'Aquin, Tommaso Di Noia and Enrico Motta:'' LOTED: Exploiting Linked Data in Analyzing European Procurement Notices
* ''Thomas Markotschi and Johanna Voelker:'' GuessWhat?!
* ''Miroslav Vacura and Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontological Analysis of Human Relations for Semantically Consistent Transformations of FOAF Data
* ''Andrea Giovanni Nuzzolese, Aldo Gangemi, Paolo Ciancarini and Valentina Presutti:'' Semion: a smart triplification tool
* ''Claudio Baldassarre:'' Semantic Skin: from flat textual content to interconnected repositories of semantic data (Demo paper)

The accepted papers will be published in workshop notes, under CEUR.

== Late breaking news ==

We invite submissions in the form of 2-pages extended
abstracts in LNCS style presenting work relevant to the workshop topics.
Interesting results to be submitted could be either non-mature promising recent work, or already published results e.g. accepted to another venue (journal or conference).
The goal of the session is to gather the community interested
in the KIELD themes, stimulate discussions, and favor exchange of ideas.
Instead of regular review process, these submissions will
just undergo a relevance check. The abstracts will be part of the
electronic workshop proceedings (CEUR) as a special section.
A short oral presentation from by the authors will be scheduled during the workshop day.

=== Late breaking news Submission ===

Submissions must be sent to [mailto:kield2010@inrialpes.fr KIELD chairs] by August 27th (midnight CET).

== Program Committee ==

* Eva Blomqvist, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Ciro Cattuto, ISI Foundation, Italy
* Claudia d'Amato, University of Bari, Italy
* Mathieu d'Aquin, KMI Open University, UK
* Nicola Fanizzi, University of Bari, Italy
* Aldo Gangemi, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Alfio Gliozzo, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Marko Grobelnik, Jozef Stefan Institute, Slovenia
* Tom Heath, Talis, UK
* Luigi Iannone, Manchester University, UK
* David Jensen, University of Massachusetts Amherst, USA
* Agnieszka Lawrynowicz, Poznan University of Technology, Poland
* Pascal Poncelet, LIRMM, Université Montpellier 2, France
* Marko Rodriguez, AT&T, and Vrije Universiteit Brussels, Belgium
* Steffen Staab, University of Koblenz-Landau, Germany

== Organizers ==

* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR Rome, Italy
* E-mail: valentina.presutti_at_cnr.it

* Francois Scharffe, INRIA Grenoble Rhone-Alpes, France
* E-mail: francois.scharffe_at_inria.fr

* Vojtech Svatek, University of Economics, Prague, Czech Republic
* E-mail: svatek_at_vse.cz

== Important dates ==

*<strike> July 20th: Paper submission deadline (deadline extended) </strike>
*<strike> August 14, 2010: Paper acceptance notification </strike>
* August 27, 2010 (midnight CET): Camera-ready versions of papers
* August 27, 2010 (midnight CET): Late breaking results deadline
* October 15th: Workshop day

[[Category:Event]]
{{Event
|Name=1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD2010)
|HasStartDate=2010/10/15
|HasEndDate=2010/10/15
}}
{{Submission deadline
|deadline=2010/07/21
|expired=The submission deadline has expired!
|intime=You are in time for submitting your paper.
}}

Reviews:VojtechSvatek about Faceted Classification Scheme

2010-09-17T06:01:05Z

VojtechSvatek: New page: {{Content OP Proposal Review Template |CreationDate=2010/9/17 |SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek |ContentOPUnderReview=Faceted Classification Scheme |RevisionID=10104 |Score=1 - needs minor revisi...

{{Content OP Proposal Review Template
|CreationDate=2010/9/17
|SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek
|ContentOPUnderReview=Faceted Classification Scheme
|RevisionID=10104
|Score=1 - needs minor revision
|ReviewSummary=A pattern that relatively straightforwardly applies another (more fundamental) pattern submitted in parallel, Normalization. Useful however. Minor presentation issues to be fixed.
|ReviewConfidence=The pattern is fairly generic and I feel confident to review it.
|ReviewProblems=I don't like the phrase 'class that represents a subset of the... class', which the author uses. More formally, we should say that the *interpretation* of one class is a subset of the *interpretation* of the other class (i.e. not of the class itself). Or, most simply (and preferably) in the OWL context, we can say that one class is subclass of another.

While the categories in a FCS are defined as mutually exclusive and exhaustive, the present example does not seem to fulfill this, in particular for the Brand Name and Scent facets, which can hardly be exhaustive.
As concerns mutual exclusivity: the proposal does not explicitly state that the object properties representing the facets (such as hasAgent) have to be functional. Why?

|ReviewRelevance=Pretty relevant.
|ReviewBestPractice=Yes, I would see this pattern as best practice in the given context.
|ReviewReusability=Relatively high. However, it would be worth considering explicitly extending the pattern to systems with *hierarchical* facets.
|ReviewRelations=This (or, the Normalization pattern) actually seems to be a reflection of the construct proposed by A. Rector years ago, as the author (somewhat tacitly) acknowledges.
|ReviewUnderstandability=Yes - the description is perhaps oversophisticated for a generic modeller; however, this is probably due to adaptation to the mindset of specialists in faceted systems, for which the pattern is intended.
|ReviewClearProblem=Yes, the problem is sufficiently elaborated.
|ReviewClearRelevance=Pretty relevant; the consequences are sketched but could be elaborated more.
|ReviewFigures=A minor issue: while the diagram of the Normalization pattern shows the class hierarchy before the property hierarchy, in the example it is the other way around.
|ReviewMissing=Especially that on possible functionality of the object properties, see above.
}}

Reviews:VojtechSvatek about SimpleOrAggregated

2010-09-16T21:29:55Z

VojtechSvatek: New page: {{Content OP Proposal Review Template |CreationDate=2010/9/16 |SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek |ContentOPUnderReview=SimpleOrAggregated |RevisionID=10097 |Score=1 - needs minor revision |ReviewS...

{{Content OP Proposal Review Template
|CreationDate=2010/9/16
|SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek
|ContentOPUnderReview=SimpleOrAggregated
|RevisionID=10097
|Score=1 - needs minor revision
|ReviewSummary=A reasonable pattern with somewhat imprecise description.
|ReviewConfidence=The pattern is quite generic and I feel confident to judge it.
|ReviewProblems=There is at least one inadequacy in the pattern description. The author claims to model that an aggregated individual is "made up of several individuals of the same concept". This is however clearly not (necessarily) the case, as there is no guarantee that the individuals gathered in an aggregated object are of the same class within themselves and/or wrt. the aggregated object!
For each specialization of this pattern, such a requirement would have to be stated explicitly, i.e. not inherited from the pattern itself.

There is a typo: instanciate. I also wonder if Spanish translations within the Elements descriptions are not a bit distracting.

|ReviewRelevance=The pattern is relevant.
|ReviewBestPractice=Could be seen as best practice.
|ReviewReusability=Medium.
|ReviewRelations=I would expect a reference to http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/BestPractices/OEP/SimplePartWhole/.

Importantly, the submitted pattern is based upon a more generic pattern that I have not come across yet: using different mutually equivalent classes to model different partitions (here, the distinction between 'simple' and 'aggregated') of the given class. This pattern should be either explicitly references (if already published) or submitted separately. Interestingly, this pattern may be used for a similar purpose as another submitted pattern, called Normalization: both can be used to dismantle a complex (possibly, multi-)hierarchy.

I also wonder if the Object class can be considered similar as the Object class e.g. in the ObjectRole pattern.
|ReviewUnderstandability=OK
|ReviewClearProblem=OK
|ReviewClearRelevance=Consequences not particularly analysed.
|ReviewFigures=OK
|ReviewMissing=As above
}}

Reviews:VojtechSvatek about Context Slices

2010-09-16T20:57:57Z

VojtechSvatek: New page: {{Content OP Proposal Review Template |CreationDate=2010/9/16 |SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek |ContentOPUnderReview=Context Slices |RevisionID=10058 |Score=1 - needs minor revision |ReviewSumma...

{{Content OP Proposal Review Template
|CreationDate=2010/9/16
|SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek
|ContentOPUnderReview=Context Slices
|RevisionID=10058
|Score=1 - needs minor revision
|ReviewSummary=A reasonable, non-trivial logical pattern.

Some associated modelling decisions should be made more precise. In particular, the domain/range of the new relation is not obvious: is it set to cs:ContextualProjection? How can it be distinguished from the general (factual) relation with the same meaning, which would have natural concepts (such as Company and Person) in domain/range?

To unify terminology, I would prefer to use the name 'Contextual Projection' for the pattern itself, too. (Knowing that Anglo-Saxon people are fond of figurative names such as 'slices' ;-))
|ReviewConfidence=The pattern is quite generic and I feel competent to judge it.
|ReviewProblems=Just as outlined above.
|ReviewRelevance=Yes, it addresses a pretty relevant and important problem.
|ReviewBestPractice=For the problem in question, this (or just slightly modified) pattern seems to be best practice.
|ReviewReusability=Rather generic.
|ReviewRelations=There is obvious relation to the n-ary relation pattern (e.g. by SWBPD) and actually also to RDF reification as kind-of pattern.
|ReviewUnderstandability=Neat description aside the missing details as stated above.
|ReviewClearProblem=Yes, looks clear.
|ReviewClearRelevance=Yes, but the consequences could still be elaboreted a bit more.
|ReviewFigures=Yes.
|ReviewMissing=As above.
}}

'Ontology Design Patterns':KIELD2010

2010-08-23T11:06:32Z

VojtechSvatek: List of accepted papers and workshop date added

== Welcome to the 1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data ==

The first workshop on knowledge injection into and extraction from linked data is a co-located event with [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010], [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/conference-venue.html held in Lisbon (Portugal)] on October 2010.

'''News: The list of [http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/wiki/Odp:KIELD2010#Accepted_Papers accepted papers] is available.'''

'''News: The workshop date has been fixed to October 15th, afternoon.'''

'''Martin Hepp will give a [http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/wiki/Odp:KIELD2010#Keynote_Talk keynote talk] at KIELD 2010'''

__TOC__

== Motivation and objectives ==
The first workshop on Knowledge Injection to and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD2010 at [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010]) will gather three prominent sub-communities of Knowledge Engineering and Management: Knowledge Modelling, Knowledge Discovery and Linked Data. The rapid growth of the Linked Data cloud, in parallel with on-the-fly design of relevant vocabularies, presents new opportunities for traditional research disciplines.

Most notably:
* Although the popular vocabularies reflect today needs, they sometimes lack deeper ontological reflections. State-of-the-art knowledge modelling, especially the pattern-based ontology design principles, could help connect Linked Data vocabularies to more sophisticated models, while keeping themselves simple. Furthermore, collaborative ontology design methodologies could find their way to the process of vocabulary design, currently undertaken by VoCamp communities and stand-alone groups.
* The linked data themselves represent a large and growing resource woven from numerous components. Empirical knowledge discovery in linked data, carried out by machine learning and data mining algorithms, could reveal interesting patterns on frequently used structures, which could then be fuelled back to the vocabulary design. Existing techniques for mining network-structured data, such as graph databases or web links, are likely to require adaptation so as to take account of links that are typed according to semantically rich and heterogeneous schemata.

Aside the [http://ekaw2010.inesc-id.pt/ EKAW 2010] conference itself, the workshop is informally associated with the series of [[WOP:2009|WOP workshops - Workshops on Ontology Patterns]]. Participants of the previous successful WOP (1st edition at ISWC2009) are encouraged to submit to KIELD 2010.

By this interdisciplinary nature KIELD2010 aims at being of high interest for both researchers and practitioners of all three areas mentioned above. Furthermore, it will give space to ongoing and pioneering research activities, which would still be too preliminary as conference publications, although extremely hot as topics in the semantic technology field.

== Key topics ==

The workshop welcomes research, application, and position papers on the following topics (non-exclusive):

=== Ontology engineering for Linked Data ===
* Methodologies
* Ontology patterns extraction
* Ontology patterns identification and discovery
* Pattern-based triplification
* Anti-patterns or worst practices

=== Data mining from Linked Data ===
* Entity recognition
* Link prediction
* Pattern mining
* Sequential patterns
* Rule mining

=== Linked Data in use ===
* Domain applications based-on linked data
* Linked data exploitation
* Interaction with linked data

== Keynote Talk ==

* ''Martin Hepp:'' Ontology Engineering for Linked Data: What Makes For A Good Ontology?

The talk will discuss the impact of ontology design choices and ontology quality criteria on the overall impact of the linked data initiatives.
In particular, it will analyze whether there are good and bad ontologies from a practical standpoint, what quality criteria will matter the most, and how this relates to the "raw data now" movement in the community.

== Accepted Papers ==

* ''Laura Dragan, Alexandre Passant, Tudor Groza and Siegfried Handschuh:'' Linking Personal Semantic Notes
* ''Francesco Valle, Mathieu d'Aquin, Tommaso Di Noia and Enrico Motta:'' LOTED: Exploiting Linked Data in Analyzing European Procurement Notices
* ''Thomas Markotschi and Johanna Voelker:'' GuessWhat?!
* ''Miroslav Vacura and Vojtech Svatek:'' Ontological Analysis of Human Relations for Semantically Consistent Transformations of FOAF Data
* ''Andrea Giovanni Nuzzolese, Aldo Gangemi, Paolo Ciancarini and Valentina Presutti:'' Semion: a smart triplification tool
* ''Claudio Baldassarre:'' Semantic Skin: from flat textual content to interconnected repositories of semantic data (Demo paper)

The accepted papers will be published in workshop notes, under CEUR.

== Late breaking news ==

We invite submissions in the form of 2-pages extended
abstracts in LNCS style presenting work relevant to the workshop topics.
Interesting results to be submitted could be either non-mature promising recent work, or already published results e.g. accepted to another venue (journal or conference).
The goal of the session is to gather the community interested
in the KIELD themes, stimulate discussions, and favor exchange of ideas.
Instead of regular review process, these submissions will
just undergo a relevance check. The abstracts will be part of the
electronic workshop proceedings (CEUR) as a special section.
A short oral presentation from by the authors will be scheduled during the workshop day.

=== Late breaking news Submission ===

Submissions must be sent to [mailto:kield2010@inrialpes.fr KIELD chairs] by August 27th (midnight CET).

== Program Committee ==

* Eva Blomqvist, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Ciro Cattuto, ISI Foundation, Italy
* Claudia d'Amato, University of Bari, Italy
* Mathieu d'Aquin, KMI Open University, UK
* Nicola Fanizzi, University of Bari, Italy
* Aldo Gangemi, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Alfio Gliozzo, STLab ISTC-CNR, Italy
* Marko Grobelnik, Jozef Stefan Institute, Slovenia
* Tom Heath, Talis, UK
* Luigi Iannone, Manchester University, UK
* David Jensen, University of Massachusetts Amherst, USA
* Agnieszka Lawrynowicz, Poznan University of Technology, Poland
* Pascal Poncelet, LIRMM, Université Montpellier 2, France
* Marko Rodriguez, AT&T, and Vrije Universiteit Brussels, Belgium
* Steffen Staab, University of Koblenz-Landau, Germany

== Organizers ==

* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR Rome, Italy
* E-mail: valentina.presutti_at_cnr.it

* Francois Scharffe, INRIA Grenoble Rhone-Alpes, France
* E-mail: francois.scharffe_at_inria.fr

* Vojtech Svatek, University of Economics, Prague, Czech Republic
* E-mail: svatek_at_vse.cz

== Important dates ==

*<strike> July 20th: Paper submission deadline (deadline extended) </strike>
*<strike> August 14, 2010: Paper acceptance notification </strike>
* August 27, 2010 (midnight CET): Camera-ready versions of papers
* August 27, 2010 (midnight CET): Late breaking results deadline
* October 15th: Workshop day

[[Category:Event]]
{{Event
|Name=1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data (KIELD2010)
|HasStartDate=2010/10/15
|HasEndDate=2010/10/15
}}
{{Submission deadline
|deadline=2010/07/21
|expired=The submission deadline has expired!
|intime=You are in time for submitting your paper.
}}

'Ontology Design Patterns':KIELD2010

2010-07-10T20:18:29Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Welcome to the 1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data */

'Ontology Design Patterns':KIELD2010

2010-07-10T20:11:19Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Welcome to the 1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data */

'Ontology Design Patterns':KIELD2010

2010-07-10T20:10:26Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Welcome to the 1st Workshop on Knowledge Injection into and Extraction from Linked Data */

'Ontology Design Patterns':KIELD2010

2010-07-10T20:08:37Z

VojtechSvatek:

'Ontology Design Patterns':KIELD2010

2010-06-12T22:21:10Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Organizers */

'Ontology Design Patterns':KIELD2010

2010-06-12T22:20:14Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Program Committee */ Claudia added

'Ontology Design Patterns':KIELD2010

2010-06-12T19:29:37Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Program Committee */

'Ontology Design Patterns':KIELD2010

2010-06-12T19:28:37Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Paper Submission */

Submissions:ConceptTerms

2009-09-08T20:21:23Z

VojtechSvatek: Review has been created. Annotation 'assigned' has been removed.

{{Content_OP_Proposal_toolbar}}
{{Include Image
|ImageName=ConceptTermsPattern.jpg
}}
{{Content OP Proposal Template
|SubmittedBy=Pierre-YvesVandenbussche
|Name=ConceptTerms
|Intent=This CP allows designers to represent language complexity for concept description (preferred term, synonyms, translation relation,etc.).
|Domain=Linguistic, Vocabulary,
|CompetencyQuestion=How to distinguish a preferred term or label from synonyms in order to name a concept?, How to enable cross language searching?, How to allow adding properties on term?
|ContentODPDescription=A concept is named in a particular language by a preferred term and a set of simple non preferred terms. Those terms artifacts specialize the term entity which owns common properties for terms such as: language, source information (when creating vocabulary from corpora). This list of properties may be extended depending on vocabulary specific needs.
|ReusableOWLBuildingBlock=http://sites.google.com/site/pierreyvesvandenbussche/resources/ConceptTerms.owl
|Consequences=Compare to labels on a concept class, this solution has a higher data load.
|Scenario=Used for terminology representation. For example, a preferred term "car" in english could be translated in "voiture" in french and linked to the same concept. Here translation relation is possible thanks to the term entity.
|ReengineeredFrom=BS8723-5 model: http://schemas.bs8723.org/
}}
{{Element list header}}

{{Scenarios about me}}
{{Reviews about me}}
{{Submission to event
|Event=WOP2009
}}

Reviews:VojtechSvatek about ConceptTerms

2009-09-08T20:21:22Z

VojtechSvatek: New page: {{Content OP Proposal Review Template |CreationDate=2009/9/8 |SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek |ContentOPUnderReview=ConceptTerms |RevisionID=5714 |Score=0 - needs major revision |ReviewSummary=F...

{{Content OP Proposal Review Template
|CreationDate=2009/9/8
|SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek
|ContentOPUnderReview=ConceptTerms
|RevisionID=5714
|Score=0 - needs major revision
|ReviewSummary=First of all, the pattern looks quite unfinished and/or sloppy in terms of documentation. Only when the modelling choices are explained, a true review could be done.
|ReviewConfidence=The pattern is currently so simple that not much special expertise is needed. I am confident in my assessment.
|ReviewProblems=It is not clear what a compound non preferred term looks like and why it is only made of preferred terms.

The reification of the relation between a concept and the terms should be clearly justified.

The scenario is too brief.
|ReviewRelevance=The solution is kind of trivial. There are numerous efforts related to handling lexical aspects of ontologies.
|ReviewReusability=High degree of reuse.
|ReviewRelations=The pattern should probably mention the SKOS vocabulary, which addresses most of the problems in question.
|ReviewUnderstandability=Simple and understandable, except for clearly missing information.
|ReviewClearProblem=Could do, although I would imagine something a bit different under 'language complexity'.
|ReviewClearRelevance=Not much information about consequences.
|ReviewFigures=Only the basic diagram, which looks OK.
|ReviewMissing=Especially information (and examples) on compound non-preferred terms.
}}

Reviews:VojtechSvatek about Classification scheme - adjacency list model - to Taxonomy

2009-09-08T19:44:19Z

VojtechSvatek: New page: {{Content OP Proposal Review Template |CreationDate=2009/9/8 |SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek |ContentOPUnderReview=Classification scheme - adjacency list model - to Taxonomy |RevisionID=5681 |S...

{{Content OP Proposal Review Template
|CreationDate=2009/9/8
|SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek
|ContentOPUnderReview=Classification scheme - adjacency list model - to Taxonomy
|RevisionID=5681
|Score=0 - needs major revision
|ReviewSummary=A reengineering pattern for a predefined type of tabular structure. Semantic aspects are not taken into account. There are some inconsistencies in the description.

However, it is a good starting point for discussion at WOP. I assume it should be explained in the context of reengineering patterns in general.
|ReviewConfidence=The problem is relatively transparent and the domain is generic, so I have high confidence in my assessment.
|ReviewProblems=1) Although the semantics of the hierarchical relation 'may vary depending of the context', there are no alternative modelling options offered; the subclass construct is uniformly used, which has the subset semantics; this may lead to discrepancies if the original resource is e.g. partonomy-oriented. This should at least be commented on, as a limitation of the pattern usage.

2) While the problem description assumes that the original source is structured as tree, the process description has a special provision for non-tree structures. This is confusing.

3) When a new 'ad hoc' class is created, it is not clear if it is to be identified with a standard class such as owl:Thing, or given the URI through some naming convention - I would expect such a convention as natural part of the pattern.

Text-level issues:
- what is caparentID?
- the last diagram (at example level) is trivial and could safely be omitted
|ReviewRelevance=This kind of patterns is naturally important, as reengineering of non-ontological resources is an ubiquitous problem.
|ReviewBestPractice=The problem is simplified such that the current pattern looks like the only straightforward solution. In reality a more complex solution would be needed.
|ReviewReusability=The pattern is specific to a particular category of non-ontological resources. However, its abstract part could be reused for some other categories.
|ReviewRelations=Obviously, the same non-ontological resources could be transformed to a different ontological form (such as instance-level), presumably using an alternative reengineering pattern.
|ReviewUnderstandability=Understandable, even a bit too verbose in places.
|ReviewClearProblem=As mentioned, the problem is oversimplified. The description of the simple problem, i.e. mechanically transforming a table into an ontology, is clear.
|ReviewClearRelevance=Not much.
|ReviewFigures=Clear, and a bit trivial.
}}

WOP:OrganizationNotes

2009-08-06T15:18:31Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Research Papers (regular/short) */

=== Lists where both CFP have been sent ===

* Valentina
** DBWorld
** semantic-web@w3.org
** neon-all@neon-project.org
** ontolog-forum
** iks project list
** university of bologna internal list
** tocai project

* Aldo
** public-lod-request@w3.org

=== Expected submissions ===

==== Research Papers (regular/short) ====

* Valentina
** I am aware of 2 under development from STLab
* Vojtech
** One about naming patterns, UEP with minor contribution from STLab

==== Posters ====

* <Organization member name>
** <expected submission1>
** <expected submission2>
** <expected submission3>
** ...

==== Patterns ====

* <Organization member name>
** <expected submission1>
** <expected submission2>
** <expected submission3>
** ...

WOP:2009

2009-07-28T12:06:39Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Topics */ a para on poster category added

== Welcome to the Workshop on Ontology Patterns - WOP2009 ==
This is the first edition in a series of yearly workshops addressing the emerging topic of ontology patterns as best practices, related to the [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) |''ontologydesignpatterns.org'']] initiative. Patterns need to be shared by a community in order to provide a common language and stimulate pattern usage and development. Hence, the aim of this workshop is twofold; both providing an arena for proposing and discussing good practices, patterns, pattern-based ontologies, systems etc., and broadening the pattern community that will develop its own “language” for discussing and describing relevant problems and their solutions.

The first workshop will be held in conjunction with [http://iswc2009.semanticweb.org/ ISWC], at a [http://iswc2009.semanticweb.org/wiki/index.php/Westfields_Conference_Center venue] in the Washington DC area (US), on October 25th 2009. It will be a full-day workshop consisting of three parts; paper presentations, posters, and “pattern writing” sessions. For the pattern writing sessions ontology design patterns will be submitted and reviewed at [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) |''ontologydesignpatterns.org'']], including the assignment of an advisor for each accepted pattern submission.

----

'''[http://vocamp.org/wiki/VoCampDCOctober2009 WOP supports the October 2009 Vocamp @ Washington D.C., USA.]'''

----

__TOC__

== Workshop Focus and Relevance ==
As interest in the Semantic Web increases and technologies for realizing the semantic web become more mature, the need for high-quality and reusable semantic web ontologies increases. To address the quality and reusability issues, different types of Ontology Design Patterns (ODPs) have emerged. Patterns can supply ontology designers with several kinds of benefits, including a direct link to requirements, reuse, guidance, and better communication. ODPs are well on their way to providing those benefits. ODPs have been [http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/BestPractices/OEP/ proposed by the W3C] and are currently being collected in various repositories, such as the [http://www.gong.manchester.ac.uk/odp/html/index.html catalogue maintained by the University of Manchester] and the ODP portal at [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) |ontologydesignpatterns.org]]. However, pattern catalogues are still small and do not cover all types of patterns and all domains. Semantic Web applications could also benefit from additional types of patterns, such as knowledge patterns and specialized software patterns for semantic applications. In addition, to achieve communication benefits, patterns need to be shared by a community in order to provide a common language for discussing and understanding modeling problems. The workshop can leverage the activities conducted in the ontologydesignpatterns.org initiative, and aims to use the portal as its main means of communication, e.g. for pattern submission, reviewing and discussions outside the workshop schedule.

Reuse has been an important research subject in ontology engineering for many years, and this is also true for the semantic web community. Patterns are an approach to knowledge reuse that has proved feasible and very profitable in many other areas such as software engineering and data modeling. During the past few years, patterns for semantic web ontologies and ontology-based applications have been introduced, and at this point in time we believe that the community would highly benefit from a series of workshops focusing on this particular topic. An earlier workshop, [http://www.research.ibm.com/people/w/welty/OPSW-05/ Ontology Patterns for the Semantic Web] , was arranged at ISWC2005, however at that time the community was considerably smaller. The focus then was on discussing reusable OWL and RDF ontologies addressing general open problems. The WOP series broadens this scope to include all patterns related to ontology design and knowledge engineering for the Semantic Web. This is in line with the successful [http://ekaw2008.inrialpes.fr/ EKAW2008] conference (with the sub-title Knowledge Patterns). Topics of this conference included ontology engineering patterns but also patterns for re-engineering of knowledge resources, process knowledge, social and cognitive aspects of semantics.

A workshop should be a practical and interaction-rich event, hence the workshop will have three parts: regular papers, posters, and “pattern writing”, with a focus on the latter. The inspiration for this model comes from the [http://hillside.net/patterns/patternworkshop.htm pattern writing workshops for software patterns]. The aim is to promote development and review of actual patterns, rather than papers describing patterns. Related events are also [http://vocamp.org/wiki/VoCampIbiza2009 VoCamps] for writing vocabularies for the Semantic Web.

== Topics ==
The main aim of the workshop is to discuss and collect best practices and experiences, hence submissions should focus on some notion of best practices. Original research papers and poster papers are invited to consider the following (non exhaustive) list of topics:

* Good practices of ontology design
* Good practices for Linked Data and related applications
* Good practices for hybridization of semantic web and NLP techniques
* Software patterns for semantic web applications
* Interaction patterns and the Semantic Web

* Good Practices and Patterns of semantic social networks, semantic wikis, semantic blogs
* Pattern-based methodologies for Semantic Web ontologies and software engineering

* Ontology Design Patterns and Linked Data
* Ontology Patterns and Microformats
* Application Profiles
* Patterns for using different vocabularies together e.g. FOAF, SIOC, DC, etc.
* Ontology design patterns (ODPs) for specific knowledge domains e.g. multimedia, fishery and agriculture, user profiling, business modeling, etc.

* Tools support for pattern-based knowledge engineering
* Collaboration patterns in ontology design and engineering
* Pattern-based ontology evaluation and selection
* Domain specific applications based on patterns and successful stories

* Correspondence patterns for ontology matching and integration
* Automatic ontology construction (ontology learning) based on patterns
* Lexico-syntactic patterns
* Reasoning patterns (workflows made of reasoning steps for addressing specific goals)
* Processes and services - process patterns
* Re-engineering patterns for conceptual models, folksonomies, lexicons, thesauri

* Contextual reasoning and patterns as context
* Knowledge patterns and knowledge re-engineering based on patterns
* Pattern-based information extraction
* Problem solving methods and patterns

* Quality evaluation of patterns
* Benefits of ontology patterns and knowledge patterns
* Web semantics from a pattern perspective

The poster category is particularly suitable for descriptions of software tools supporting the design, management, discovery, matching, or any other way of processing ontology patterns. A poster can also provide a high-level description of a research project that has ontology patterns as one of its topics.

Pattern proposals for the “pattern writing” sessions will be collected through the [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) | ODP portal]], and templates for submission are provided for the following types of patterns (see general [[OPTypes | typology]] for explanation of the types):
* Content patterns
* Structural patterns: logical and architecture patterns
* Correspondence patterns: re-engineering and alignment patterns
For other types of patterns, or if the author wishes to elaborate on theoretical rather than practical aspects, a pattern description may be submitted as either a research paper or poster paper.

== Related references ==

* [http://wiki.loa-cnr.it/images/3/31/ERPaperODP.pdf Valentina Presutti and Aldo Gangemi. Content Ontology Design Patterns as Practical Building Blocks for Web Ontologies (ER 2008)]
* [http://www.w3.org/TR/swbp-n-aryRelations/ Natasha Noy and Alan Rector. Defining N-ary Relations on the Semantic Web (2006)]
* [http://books.google.com/books?id=VKXKvlalq5UC&pg=PA262&lpg=PA262&dq=ontology+design+patterns+for+semantic+web&source=bl&ots=HY1qG6-_Bx&sig=-e2MGBjRMWnLhhjsqJHfJK-X9pc&hl=en&ei=7LZASu3gMYW8jAe2_cWQCQ&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=7 Aldo Gangemi. Ontology Design Patterns for Semantic Web Content (ISWC 2005).]
* [http://www.w3.org/TR/swbp-classes-as-values/ Natasha Noy, Michael Uschold, Chris Welty. Representing Classes As Property Values on the Semantic Web (2005)]
* [http://www.w3.org/TR/swbp-specified-values/ Alan Rector. Representing Specified Values in OWL: "value partitions" and "value sets" (2005)]
* [http://www.scharffe.fr/pub/phd-thesis/manuscript.pdf Francois Scharffe. Correspondence Patterns Representation. PhD Thesis (2009)]
* [http://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/pclark/papers/handbook03.pdf Peter Clark, John Thompson, and Bruce Porter. Knowledge Patterns. In Handbook of Ontologies (2003)]
* [http://www.springerlink.com/content/d2lp476v0p281q73/?p=f9d5500ce8b24589b2baf5eef213b0f5&pi=3 Mikel Egaña, Alan Rector, Robert Stevens, Erick Antezana. Applying Ontology Design Patterns in bio-ontologies. (EKAW 2008).]

== Important Dates and Submission ==
For details on how to submit to WOP2009 see the [[WOP2009:Submission | submission page]]. Research papers and poster submissions, as well as extended abstracts describing the accepted patterns, will be published online in the CEUR-Workshop Proceedings.

'''Important dates'''
* Submission deadline (papers and patterns) - '''August 9'''
* Notification of acceptance (papers and patterns) - '''September 7'''
* Camera ready deadline (papers and pattern abstracts) - '''September 21'''
* Upload of final pattern version (patterns) - '''October 9'''
* Online proceedings published (papers and pattern abstracts) - '''October 9'''
* Workshop date - '''October 25'''

== WOP Organisation ==

==== Steering Committee ====

The workshop series is arranged by a fixed steering committee, appointing the chairs and adjusting the focus of the workshop on a yearly basis.

The WOP Steering committee consists of:
* Eva Blomqvist, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Aldo Gangemi, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Alan Rector, University of Manchester (UK)
* Francois Scharffe, INRIA (FR)
* Steffen Staab, University of Koblenz (DE)
* Chris Welty, IBM Watson Research Center (US)

==== WOP2009 Chairs ====

* Paper chair - Kurt Sandkuhl, Jönköping University (SE) [http://www.jth.hj.se/doc/6771 ''contact'']
* Poster chair - Vojtech Svatek, University of Economics, (CZ) [http://nb.vse.cz/~svatek/welcom_e.htm ''contact'']
* Pattern chairs - Eva Blomqvist, ISTC-CNR (IT) [http://stlab.istc.cnr.it/stlab/User:EvaBlomqvist ''contact''] and Francois Scharffe, INRIA (FR) [http://www.scharffe.fr/ ''contact'']

==== Program Committee ====

(To be completed...)

* Alessandro Adamou, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Marie-Aude Aufaure, Ecole Centrale Paris (FR)
* Fabio Ciravegna, University of Sheffield (UK)
* Mathieu D'Aquin, Open University (UK)
* Enrico Daga, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Violeta Damjanovic, Salzburg Research (AT)
* Rim Djedidi, Paris-Sud University (FR)
* Henrik Eriksson, Linköping University (SE)
* Aldo Gangemi, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Jose-Manuel Gomez, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid (ES)
* Gerd Groener, University of Koblenz (DE)
* Luigi Iannone, University of Manchester (UK)
* Holger Lewen, AIFB University of Karlsruhe (DE)
* Pierluigi Miraglia, Gerson Lehrman Group (US)
* Mark Musen, Stanford University (US)
* Natasha Noy, Stanford University (US)
* Wim Peters, University of Sheffield (UK)
* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Alan Rector, University of Manchester (UK)
* Marta Sabou, Open University (UK)
* Guus Schreiber, VU University Amsterdam (NL)
* Steffen Staab, University of Koblenz (DE)
* Mari Carmen Suárez-Figueroa. Universidad Politécnica de Madrid (ES)
* Boris Villazón-Terrazas, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid (ES)
* Holger Wache, University of Applied Sciences Northwestern Switzerland (CH)
* Chris Welty, IBM Watson Research Center (US)
[[Category:WOP]]
{{Event
|Name=WOP2009
|HasStartDate=2009/10/25
|HasEndDate=2009/10/25
}}
{{Submission deadline
|deadline=2009/08/09
|expired=Deadline has expired!
|intime=You are in time for submission!
}}

WOP:2009

2009-06-29T14:30:14Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Related references */ added Egana

== Welcome to the Workshop on Ontology Patterns - WOP2009 ==
This is the first edition in a series of yearly workshops addressing the emerging topic of ontology patterns as best practices, related to the [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) |''ontologydesignpatterns.org'']] initiative. Patterns need to be shared by a community in order to provide a common language and stimulate pattern usage and development. Hence, the aim of this workshop is twofold; both providing an arena for proposing and discussing good practices, patterns, pattern-based ontologies, systems etc., and broadening the pattern community that will develop its own “language” for discussing and describing relevant problems and their solutions.

The first workshop will be held in conjunction with [http://iswc2009.semanticweb.org/ ISWC], at a [http://iswc2009.semanticweb.org/wiki/index.php/Westfields_Conference_Center venue] in the Washington DC area (US), on October 25th 2009. It will be a full-day workshop consisting of three parts; paper presentations, posters, and “pattern writing” sessions. For the pattern writing sessions ontology design patterns will be submitted and reviewed at [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) |''ontologydesignpatterns.org'']], including the assignment of an advisor for each accepted pattern submission.

__TOC__

== Workshop Focus and Relevance ==
As interest in the Semantic Web increases and technologies for realizing the semantic web become more mature, the need for high-quality and reusable semantic web ontologies increases. To address the quality and reusability issues, different types of Ontology Design Patterns (ODPs) have emerged. Patterns can supply ontology designers with several kinds of benefits, including a direct link to requirements, reuse, guidance, and better communication. ODPs are well on their way to providing those benefits. ODPs have been [http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/BestPractices/OEP/ proposed by the W3C] and are currently being collected in various repositories, such as the [http://www.gong.manchester.ac.uk/odp/html/index.html catalogue maintained by the University of Manchester] and the ODP portal at [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) |ontologydesignpatterns.org]]. However, pattern catalogues are still small and do not cover all types of patterns and all domains. Semantic Web applications could also benefit from additional types of patterns, such as knowledge patterns and specialized software patterns for semantic applications. In addition, to achieve communication benefits, patterns need to be shared by a community in order to provide a common language for discussing and understanding modeling problems. The workshop can leverage the activities conducted in the ontologydesignpatterns.org initiative, and aims to use the portal as its main means of communication, e.g. for pattern submission, reviewing and discussions outside the workshop schedule.

Reuse has been an important research subject in ontology engineering for many years, and this is also true for the semantic web community. Patterns are an approach to knowledge reuse that has proved feasible and very profitable in many other areas such as software engineering and data modeling. During the past few years, patterns for semantic web ontologies and ontology-based applications have been introduced, and at this point in time we believe that the community would highly benefit from a series of workshops focusing on this particular topic. An earlier workshop, [http://www.research.ibm.com/people/w/welty/OPSW-05/ Ontology Patterns for the Semantic Web] , was arranged at ISWC2005, however at that time the community was considerably smaller. The focus then was on discussing reusable OWL and RDF ontologies addressing general open problems. The WOP series broadens this scope to include all patterns related to ontology design and knowledge engineering for the Semantic Web. This is in line with the successful [http://ekaw2008.inrialpes.fr/ EKAW2008] conference (with the sub-title Knowledge Patterns). Topics of this conference included ontology engineering patterns but also patterns for re-engineering of knowledge resources, process knowledge, social and cognitive aspects of semantics.

A workshop should be a practical and interaction-rich event, hence the workshop will have three parts: regular papers, posters, and “pattern writing”, with a focus on the latter. The inspiration for this model comes from the [http://hillside.net/patterns/patternworkshop.htm pattern writing workshops for software patterns]. The aim is to promote development and review of actual patterns, rather than papers describing patterns. Related events are also [http://vocamp.org/wiki/VoCampIbiza2009 VoCamps] for writing vocabularies for the Semantic Web.

== Topics ==
The main aim of the workshop is to discuss and collect best practices and experiences, hence submissions should focus on some notion of best practices. Original research papers and poster papers are invited to consider the following (non exhaustive) list of topics:

* Good practices of ontology design
* Good practices for Linked Data and related applications
* Good practices for hybridization of semantic web and NLP techniques
* Software patterns for semantic web applications
* Good Practices and Patterns of semantic social networks, semantic wikis, semantic blogs
* Pattern-based methodologies for Semantic Web ontologies and software engineering
* Ontology Design Patterns and Linked Data
* Ontology Patterns and Microformats
* Application Profiles
* Patterns for using different vocabularies together e.g. FOAF, SIOC, DC, etc.

* Software patterns and good practices for semantic web applications
* Ontology design patterns (ODPs) for specific knowledge domains e.g. multimedia, fishery and agriculture, user profiling, business modeling, etc.

* Tools support for pattern-based knowledge engineering
* Collaboration patterns in ontology design and engineering
* Pattern-based ontology evaluation and selection
* Domain specific applications based on patterns and successful stories

* Correspondence patterns for ontology matching and integration
* Automatic ontology construction (ontology learning) based on patterns
* Lexico-syntactic patterns
* Reasoning patterns (workflows made of reasoning steps for addressing specific goals)
* Processes and services - process patterns
* Re-engineering patterns for conceptual models, folksonomies, lexicons, thesauri

* Contextual reasoning and patterns as context
* Knowledge patterns and knowledge re-engineering based on patterns
* Pattern-based information extraction
* Problem solving methods and patterns

* Quality evaluation of patterns
* Benefits of ontology patterns and knowledge patterns
* Web semantics from a pattern perspective

Pattern proposals for the “pattern writing” sessions will be collected through the [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) | ODP portal]], and templates for submission are provided for the following types of patterns (see general [[OPTypes | typology]] for explanation of the types):
* Content patterns
* Structural patterns: logical and architecture patterns
* Correspondence patterns: re-engineering and alignment patterns
For other types of patterns, or if the author wishes to elaborate on theoretical rather than practical aspects, a pattern description may be submitted as either a research paper or poster paper.

== Related references ==

* [http://wiki.loa-cnr.it/images/3/31/ERPaperODP.pdf Valentina Presutti and Aldo Gangemi. Content Ontology Design Patterns as Practical Building Blocks for Web Ontologies (ER 2008)]
* [http://www.w3.org/TR/swbp-n-aryRelations/ Natasha Noy and Alan Rector. Defining N-ary Relations on the Semantic Web (2006)]
* [http://books.google.com/books?id=VKXKvlalq5UC&pg=PA262&lpg=PA262&dq=ontology+design+patterns+for+semantic+web&source=bl&ots=HY1qG6-_Bx&sig=-e2MGBjRMWnLhhjsqJHfJK-X9pc&hl=en&ei=7LZASu3gMYW8jAe2_cWQCQ&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=7 Aldo Gangemi. Ontology Design Patterns for Semantic Web Content (ISWC 2005).]
* [http://www.w3.org/TR/swbp-classes-as-values/ Natasha Noy, Michael Uschold, Chris Welty. Representing Classes As Property Values on the Semantic Web (2005)]
* [http://www.w3.org/TR/swbp-specified-values/ Alan Rector. Representing Specified Values in OWL: "value partitions" and "value sets" (2005)]
* [http://www.scharffe.fr/pub/phd-thesis/manuscript.pdf Francois Scharffe. Correspondence Patterns Representation. PhD Thesis (2009)]
* [http://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/pclark/papers/handbook03.pdf Peter Clark, John Thompson, and Bruce Porter. Knowledge Patterns. In Handbook of Ontologies (2003)]
* [http://www.springerlink.com/content/d2lp476v0p281q73/?p=f9d5500ce8b24589b2baf5eef213b0f5&pi=3 Mikel Egaña, Alan Rector, Robert Stevens, Erick Antezana. Applying Ontology Design Patterns in bio-ontologies. (EKAW 2008).]

== Important Dates and Submission ==
For details on how to submit to WOP2009 see the [[WOP2009:Submission | submission page]]. Research papers and poster submissions, as well as extended abstracts describing the accepted patterns, will be published online in the CEUR-Workshop Proceedings.

'''Important dates'''
* Submission deadline (papers and patterns) - '''August 9'''
* Notification of acceptance (papers and patterns) - '''September 7'''
* Camera ready deadline (papers and pattern abstracts) - '''September 21'''
* Upload of final pattern version (patterns) - '''October 9'''
* Online proceedings published (papers and pattern abstracts) - '''October 9'''
* Workshop date - '''October 25'''

== WOP Organisation ==

==== Steering Committee ====

The workshop series is arranged by a fixed steering committee, appointing the chairs and adjusting the focus of the workshop on a yearly basis.

The WOP Steering committee consists of:
* Eva Blomqvist, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Aldo Gangemi, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Alan Rector, University of Manchester (UK)
* Francois Scharffe, INRIA (FR)
* Steffen Staab, University of Koblenz (DE)
* Chris Welty, IBM Watson Research Center (US)

==== WOP2009 Chairs ====

* Paper chair - Kurt Sandkuhl, Jönköping University (SE) [http://www.jth.hj.se/doc/6771 ''contact'']
* Poster chair - Vojtech Svatek, University of Economics, (CZ) [http://nb.vse.cz/~svatek/welcom_e.htm ''contact'']
* Pattern chairs - Eva Blomqvist, ISTC-CNR (IT) [http://stlab.istc.cnr.it/stlab/User:EvaBlomqvist ''contact''] and Francois Scharffe, INRIA (FR) [http://www.scharffe.fr/ ''contact'']

==== Program Committee ====

(To be completed...)

* Alessandro Adamou, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Marie-Aude Aufaure, Ecole Centrale Paris (FR)
* Fabio Ciravegna, University of Sheffield (UK)
* Mathieu D'Aquin, Open University (UK)
* Enrico Daga, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Violeta Damjanovic, Salzburg Research (AT)
* Rim Djedidi, Paris-Sud University (FR)
* Henrik Eriksson, Linköping University (SE)
* Aldo Gangemi, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Jose-Manuel Gomez, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid (ES)
* Gerd Groener, University of Koblenz (DE)
* Luigi Iannone, University of Manchester (UK)
* Holger Lewen, AIFB University of Karlsruhe (DE)
* Pierluigi Miraglia, Gerson Lehrman Group (US)
* Mark Musen, Stanford University (US)
* Natasha Noy, Stanford University (US)
* Wim Peters, University of Sheffield (UK)
* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Alan Rector, University of Manchester (UK)
* Marta Sabou, Open University (UK)
* Guus Schreiber, VU University Amsterdam (NL)
* Steffen Staab, University of Koblenz (DE)
* Mari Carmen Suárez-Figueroa. Universidad Politécnica de Madrid (ES)
* Boris Villazón-Terrazas, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid (ES)
* Holger Wache, University of Applied Sciences Northwestern Switzerland (CH)
* Chris Welty, IBM Watson Research Center (US)

WOP:2009

2009-06-25T19:11:10Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Related references */

== Welcome to the Workshop on Ontology Patterns - WOP2009 ==
This is the first edition in a series of yearly workshops addressing the emerging topic of ontology patterns as best practices, related to the [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) |''ontologydesignpatterns.org'']] initiative. Patterns need to be shared by a community in order to provide a common language and stimulate pattern usage and development. Hence, the aim of this workshop is twofold; both providing an arena for proposing and discussing good practices, patterns, pattern-based ontologies, systems etc., and broadening the pattern community that will develop its own “language” for discussing and describing relevant problems and their solutions.

The first workshop will be held in conjunction with [http://iswc2009.semanticweb.org/ ISWC], at a [http://iswc2009.semanticweb.org/wiki/index.php/Westfields_Conference_Center venue] in the Washington DC area (US), on October 25th 2009. It will be a full-day workshop consisting of three parts; paper presentations, posters, and “pattern writing” sessions. For the pattern writing sessions ontology design patterns will be submitted and reviewed at [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) |''ontologydesignpatterns.org'']], including the assignment of an advisor for each accepted pattern submission.

__TOC__

== Workshop Focus and Relevance ==
As interest in the Semantic Web increases and technologies for realizing the semantic web become more mature, the need for high-quality and reusable semantic web ontologies increases. To address the quality and reusability issues, different types of Ontology Design Patterns (ODPs) have emerged. Patterns can supply ontology designers with several kinds of benefits, including a direct link to requirements, reuse, guidance, and better communication. ODPs are well on their way to providing those benefits. ODPs have been [http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/BestPractices/OEP/ proposed by the W3C] and are currently being collected in various repositories, such as the [http://www.gong.manchester.ac.uk/odp/html/index.html catalogue maintained by the University of Manchester] and the ODP portal at [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) |ontologydesignpatterns.org]]. However, pattern catalogues are still small and do not cover all types of patterns and all domains. Semantic Web applications could also benefit from additional types of patterns, such as knowledge patterns and specialized software patterns for semantic applications. In addition, to achieve communication benefits, patterns need to be shared by a community in order to provide a common language for discussing and understanding modeling problems. The workshop can leverage the activities conducted in the ontologydesignpatterns.org initiative, and aims to use the portal as its main means of communication, e.g. for pattern submission, reviewing and discussions outside the workshop schedule.

Reuse has been an important research subject in ontology engineering for many years, and this is also true for the semantic web community. Patterns are an approach to knowledge reuse that has proved feasible and very profitable in many other areas such as software engineering and data modeling. During the past few years, patterns for semantic web ontologies and ontology-based applications have been introduced, and at this point in time we believe that the community would highly benefit from a series of workshops focusing on this particular topic. An earlier workshop, [http://www.research.ibm.com/people/w/welty/OPSW-05/ Ontology Patterns for the Semantic Web] , was arranged at ISWC2005, however at that time the community was considerably smaller. The focus then was on discussing reusable OWL and RDF ontologies addressing general open problems. The WOP series broadens this scope to include all patterns related to ontology design and knowledge engineering for the Semantic Web. This is in line with the successful [http://ekaw2008.inrialpes.fr/ EKAW2008] conference (with the sub-title Knowledge Patterns). Topics of this conference included ontology engineering patterns but also patterns for re-engineering of knowledge resources, process knowledge, social and cognitive aspects of semantics.

A workshop should be a practical and interaction-rich event, hence the workshop will have three parts: regular papers, posters, and “pattern writing”, with a focus on the latter. The inspiration for this model comes from the [http://hillside.net/patterns/patternworkshop.htm pattern writing workshops for software patterns]. The aim is to promote development and review of actual patterns, rather than papers describing patterns. Related events are also [http://vocamp.org/wiki/VoCampIbiza2009 VoCamps] for writing vocabularies for the Semantic Web.

== Topics ==
The main aim of the workshop is to discuss and collect best practices and experiences, hence submissions should focus on some notion of best practices. Original research papers and poster papers are invited to consider the following (non exhaustive) list of topics:
* Good practices of ontology design
* Good practices for hybridization of semantic web and NLP techniques
* Software patterns for semantic web applications
* Ontology design patterns (ODPs) and pattern-based ontology design
* Tools and applications for pattern-based knowledge engineering
* Collaborative ontology design and collaboration patterns
* Pattern-based ontology evaluation and selection
* Correspondence patterns for ontology matching and integration
* Automatic ontology construction (ontology learning) based on patterns
* Lexico-syntactic patterns
* Reasoning patterns
* Web semantics from a pattern perspective
* Patterns of semantic social networks, semantic wikis, semantic blogs
* Contextual reasoning and patterns as context
* Knowledge patterns and knowledge re-engineering based on patterns
* Re-engineering patterns for conceptual models, folksonomies, lexicons, thesauri
* Pattern-based information extraction
* Processes and services - process patterns
* Problem solving methods and patterns
* Quality evaluation of patterns
* Benefits of ontology patterns and knowledge patterns

Pattern proposals for the “pattern writing” sessions will be collected through the [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) | ODP portal]], and templates for submission are provided for the following types of patterns (see general [[OPTypes | typology]] for explanation of the types):
* Content patterns
* Structural patterns: logical and architecture patterns
* Correspondence patterns: re-engineering and alignment patterns
For other types of patterns, or if the author wishes to elaborate on theoretical rather than practical aspects, a pattern description may be submitted as either a research paper or poster paper.

== Related references ==

* [http://wiki.loa-cnr.it/images/3/31/ERPaperODP.pdf Valentina Presutti and Aldo Gangemi. Content Ontology Design Patterns as Practical Building Blocks for Web Ontologies (ER 2008)]
* [http://www.w3.org/TR/swbp-n-aryRelations/ Natasha Noy and Alan Rector. Defining N-ary Relations on the Semantic Web (2006)]
* [http://books.google.com/books?id=VKXKvlalq5UC&pg=PA262&lpg=PA262&dq=ontology+design+patterns+for+semantic+web&source=bl&ots=HY1qG6-_Bx&sig=-e2MGBjRMWnLhhjsqJHfJK-X9pc&hl=en&ei=7LZASu3gMYW8jAe2_cWQCQ&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=7 Aldo Gangemi. Ontology Design Patterns for Semantic Web Content (ISWC 2005).]
* [http://www.w3.org/TR/swbp-classes-as-values/ Natasha Noy, Michael Uschold, Chris Welty. Representing Classes As Property Values on the Semantic Web (2005)]
* [http://www.w3.org/TR/swbp-specified-values/ Alan Rector. Representing Specified Values in OWL: "value partitions" and "value sets" (2005)]
* [http://www.scharffe.fr/pub/phd-thesis/manuscript.pdf Francois Scharffe. Correspondence Patterns Representation. PhD Thesis (2009)]
* [http://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/pclark/papers/handbook03.pdf Peter Clark, John Thompson, and Bruce Porter. Knowledge Patterns. In Handbook of Ontologies (2003)]

== Important Dates and Submission ==
For details on how to submit to WOP2009 see the [[WOP2009:Submission | submission page]]. Research papers and poster submissions, as well as extended abstracts describing the accepted patterns, will be published online in the CEUR-Workshop Proceedings.

'''Important dates'''
* Submission deadline (papers and patterns) - '''August 9'''
* Notification of acceptance (papers and patterns) - '''September 7'''
* Camera ready deadline (papers and pattern abstracts) - '''September 21'''
* Upload of final pattern version (patterns) - '''October 9'''
* Online proceedings published (papers and pattern abstracts) - '''October 9'''
* Workshop date - '''October 25'''

== WOP Organisation ==

==== Steering Committee ====

The workshop series is arranged by a fixed steering committee, appointing the chairs and adjusting the focus of the workshop on a yearly basis.

The WOP Steering committee consists of:
* Eva Blomqvist, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Aldo Gangemi, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Alan Rector, University of Manchester (UK)
* Francois Scharffe, INRIA (FR)
* Steffen Staab, University of Koblenz (DE)
* Chris Welty, IBM Watson Research Center (US)

==== WOP2009 Chairs ====

* Paper chair - Kurt Sandkuhl, Jönköping University (SE) [http://www.jth.hj.se/doc/6771 ''contact'']
* Poster chair - Vojtech Svatek, University of Economics, (CZ) [http://nb.vse.cz/~svatek/welcom_e.htm ''contact'']
* Pattern chairs - Eva Blomqvist, ISTC-CNR (IT) [http://stlab.istc.cnr.it/stlab/User:EvaBlomqvist ''contact''] and Francois Scharffe, INRIA (FR) [http://www.scharffe.fr/ ''contact'']

==== Program Committee ====

(To be completed...)

* Alessandro Adamou, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Marie-Aude Aufaure, Ecole Centrale Paris (FR)
* Fabio Ciravegna, University of Sheffield (UK)
* Mathieu D'Aquin, Open University (UK)
* Enrico Daga, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Violeta Damjanovic, Salzburg Research (AT)
* Rim Djedidi, Paris-Sud University (FR)
* Henrik Eriksson, Linköping University (SE)
* Aldo Gangemi, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Jose-Manuel Gomez, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid (ES)
* Gerd Groener, University of Koblenz (DE)
* Luigi Iannone, University of Manchester (UK)
* Holger Lewen, AIFB University of Karlsruhe (DE)
* Pierluigi Miraglia, Gerson Lehrman Group (US)
* Mark Musen, Stanford University (US)
* Natasha Noy, Stanford University (US)
* Wim Peters, University of Sheffield (UK)
* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Alan Rector, University of Manchester (UK)
* Marta Sabou, Open University (UK)
* Guus Schreiber, VU University Amsterdam (NL)
* Steffen Staab, University of Koblenz (DE)
* Mari Carmen Suárez-Figueroa. Universidad Politécnica de Madrid (ES)
* Boris Villazón-Terrazas, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid (ES)
* Holger Wache, University of Applied Sciences Northwestern Switzerland (CH)
* Chris Welty, IBM Watson Research Center (US)

WOP:2009

2009-06-25T09:43:35Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Related references */ added Clark

== Welcome to the Workshop on Ontology Patterns - WOP2009 ==
This is the first edition in a series of yearly workshops addressing the emerging topic of ontology patterns as best practices, related to the [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) |''ontologydesignpatterns.org'']] initiative. Patterns need to be shared by a community in order to provide a common language and stimulate pattern usage and development. Hence, the aim of this workshop is twofold; both providing an arena for proposing and discussing good practices, patterns, pattern-based ontologies, systems etc., and broadening the pattern community that will develop its own “language” for discussing and describing relevant problems and their solutions.

The first workshop will be held in conjunction with [http://iswc2009.semanticweb.org/ ISWC], at a [http://iswc2009.semanticweb.org/wiki/index.php/Westfields_Conference_Center venue] in the Washington DC area (US), on October 25th 2009. It will be a full-day workshop consisting of three parts; paper presentations, posters, and “pattern writing” sessions. For the pattern writing sessions ontology design patterns will be submitted and reviewed at [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) |''ontologydesignpatterns.org'']], including the assignment of an advisor for each accepted pattern submission.

__TOC__

== Workshop Focus and Relevance ==
As interest in the Semantic Web increases and technologies for realizing the semantic web become more mature, the need for high-quality and reusable semantic web ontologies increases. To address the quality and reusability issues, different types of Ontology Design Patterns (ODPs) have emerged. Patterns can supply ontology designers with several kinds of benefits, including a direct link to requirements, reuse, guidance, and better communication. ODPs are well on their way to providing those benefits. ODPs have been [http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/BestPractices/OEP/ proposed by the W3C] and are currently being collected in various repositories, such as the [http://www.gong.manchester.ac.uk/odp/html/index.html catalogue maintained by the University of Manchester] and the ODP portal at [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) |ontologydesignpatterns.org]]. However, pattern catalogues are still small and do not cover all types of patterns and all domains. Semantic Web applications could also benefit from additional types of patterns, such as knowledge patterns and specialized software patterns for semantic applications. In addition, to achieve communication benefits, patterns need to be shared by a community in order to provide a common language for discussing and understanding modeling problems. The workshop can leverage the activities conducted in the ontologydesignpatterns.org initiative, and aims to use the portal as its main means of communication, e.g. for pattern submission, reviewing and discussions outside the workshop schedule.

Reuse has been an important research subject in ontology engineering for many years, and this is also true for the semantic web community. Patterns are an approach to knowledge reuse that has proved feasible and very profitable in many other areas such as software engineering and data modeling. During the past few years, patterns for semantic web ontologies and ontology-based applications have been introduced, and at this point in time we believe that the community would highly benefit from a series of workshops focusing on this particular topic. An earlier workshop, [http://www.research.ibm.com/people/w/welty/OPSW-05/ Ontology Patterns for the Semantic Web] , was arranged at ISWC2005, however at that time the community was considerably smaller. The focus then was on discussing reusable OWL and RDF ontologies addressing general open problems. The WOP series broadens this scope to include all patterns related to ontology design and knowledge engineering for the Semantic Web. This is in line with the successful [http://ekaw2008.inrialpes.fr/ EKAW2008] conference (with the sub-title Knowledge Patterns). Topics of this conference included ontology engineering patterns but also patterns for re-engineering of knowledge resources, process knowledge, social and cognitive aspects of semantics.

A workshop should be a practical and interaction-rich event, hence the workshop will have three parts: regular papers, posters, and “pattern writing”, with a focus on the latter. The inspiration for this model comes from the [http://hillside.net/patterns/patternworkshop.htm pattern writing workshops for software patterns]. The aim is to promote development and review of actual patterns, rather than papers describing patterns. Related events are also [http://vocamp.org/wiki/VoCampIbiza2009 VoCamps] for writing vocabularies for the Semantic Web.

== Topics ==
The main aim of the workshop is to discuss and collect best practices and experiences, hence submissions should focus on some notion of best practices. Original research papers and poster papers are invited to consider the following (non exhaustive) list of topics:
* Good practices of ontology design
* Good practices for hybridization of semantic web and NLP techniques
* Software patterns for semantic web applications
* Ontology design patterns (ODPs) and pattern-based ontology design
* Tools and applications for pattern-based knowledge engineering
* Collaborative ontology design and collaboration patterns
* Pattern-based ontology evaluation and selection
* Correspondence patterns for ontology matching and integration
* Automatic ontology construction (ontology learning) based on patterns
* Lexico-syntactic patterns
* Reasoning patterns
* Web semantics from a pattern perspective
* Patterns of semantic social networks, semantic wikis, semantic blogs
* Contextual reasoning and patterns as context
* Knowledge patterns and knowledge re-engineering based on patterns
* Re-engineering patterns for conceptual models, folksonomies, lexicons, thesauri
* Pattern-based information extraction
* Processes and services - process patterns
* Problem solving methods and patterns
* Quality evaluation of patterns
* Benefits of ontology patterns and knowledge patterns

Pattern proposals for the “pattern writing” sessions will be collected through the [[Ontology_Design_Patterns_._org_(ODP) | ODP portal]], and templates for submission are provided for the following types of patterns (see general [[OPTypes | typology]] for explanation of the types):
* Content patterns
* Structural patterns: logical and architecture patterns
* Correspondence patterns: re-engineering and alignment patterns
For other types of patterns, or if the author wishes to elaborate on theoretical rather than practical aspects, a pattern description may be submitted as either a research paper or poster paper.

== Related references ==

* [http://wiki.loa-cnr.it/images/3/31/ERPaperODP.pdf Valentina Presutti and Aldo Gangemi. Content Ontology Design Patterns as Practical Building Blocks for Web Ontologies (ER 2008)]
* [http://www.w3.org/TR/swbp-n-aryRelations/ Natasha Noy and Alan Rector. Defining N-ary Relations on the Semantic Web (2006)]
* [http://books.google.com/books?id=VKXKvlalq5UC&pg=PA262&lpg=PA262&dq=ontology+design+patterns+for+semantic+web&source=bl&ots=HY1qG6-_Bx&sig=-e2MGBjRMWnLhhjsqJHfJK-X9pc&hl=en&ei=7LZASu3gMYW8jAe2_cWQCQ&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=7 Aldo Gangemi. Ontology Design Patterns for Semantic Web Content (ISWC 2005).]
* [http://www.w3.org/TR/swbp-classes-as-values/ Natasha Noy, Michael Uschold, Chris Welty. Representing Classes As Property Values on the Semantic Web (2005)]
* [http://www.w3.org/TR/swbp-specified-values/ Alan Rector. Representing Specified Values in OWL: "value partitions" and "value sets" (2005)]
* [http://www.scharffe.fr/pub/phd-thesis/manuscript.pdf Francois Scharffe. Correspondence Patterns Representation. PhD Thesis (2009)]
* [http://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/pclark/papers/handbook03.pdf Peter Clark, John Thompson, and Bruce Porter. Knowledge Patterns. In Handbook of Ontologies, (2003)]

== Important Dates and Submission ==
For details on how to submit to WOP2009 see the [[WOP2009:Submission | submission page]]. Research papers and poster submissions, as well as extended abstracts describing the accepted patterns, will be published online in the CEUR-Workshop Proceedings.

'''Important dates'''
* Submission deadline (papers and patterns) - '''August 9'''
* Notification of acceptance (papers and patterns) - '''September 7'''
* Camera ready deadline (papers and pattern abstracts) - '''September 21'''
* Upload of final pattern version (patterns) - '''October 9'''
* Online proceedings published (papers and pattern abstracts) - '''October 9'''
* Workshop date - '''October 25'''

== WOP Organisation ==

==== Steering Committee ====

The workshop series is arranged by a fixed steering committee, appointing the chairs and adjusting the focus of the workshop on a yearly basis.

The WOP Steering committee consists of:
* Eva Blomqvist, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Aldo Gangemi, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Alan Rector, University of Manchester (UK)
* Francois Scharffe, INRIA (FR)
* Steffen Staab, University of Koblenz (DE)
* Chris Welty, IBM Watson Research Center (US)

==== WOP2009 Chairs ====

* Paper chair - Kurt Sandkuhl, Jönköping University (SE) [http://www.jth.hj.se/doc/6771 ''contact'']
* Poster chair - Vojtech Svatek, University of Economics, (CZ) [http://nb.vse.cz/~svatek/welcom_e.htm ''contact'']
* Pattern chairs - Eva Blomqvist, ISTC-CNR (IT) [http://stlab.istc.cnr.it/stlab/User:EvaBlomqvist ''contact''] and Francois Scharffe, INRIA (FR) [http://www.scharffe.fr/ ''contact'']

==== Program Committee ====

(To be completed...)

* Alessandro Adamou, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Marie-Aude Aufaure, Ecole Centrale Paris (FR)
* Fabio Ciravegna, University of Sheffield (UK)
* Mathieu D'Aquin, Open University (UK)
* Enrico Daga, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Violeta Damjanovic, Salzburg Research (AT)
* Rim Djedidi, Paris-Sud University (FR)
* Henrik Eriksson, Linköping University (SE)
* Aldo Gangemi, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Jose-Manuel Gomez, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid (ES)
* Gerd Groener, University of Koblenz (DE)
* Luigi Iannone, University of Manchester (UK)
* Holger Lewen, AIFB University of Karlsruhe (DE)
* Pierluigi Miraglia, Gerson Lehrman Group (US)
* Mark Musen, Stanford University (US)
* Natasha Noy, Stanford University (US)
* Wim Peters, University of Sheffield (UK)
* Valentina Presutti, ISTC-CNR (IT)
* Alan Rector, University of Manchester (UK)
* Marta Sabou, Open University (UK)
* Guus Schreiber, VU University Amsterdam (NL)
* Steffen Staab, University of Koblenz (DE)
* Mari Carmen Suárez-Figueroa. Universidad Politécnica de Madrid (ES)
* Boris Villazón-Terrazas, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid (ES)
* Holger Wache, University of Applied Sciences Northwestern Switzerland (CH)
* Chris Welty, IBM Watson Research Center (US)

'Ontology Design Patterns':EB-1st-f2f-2009Feb23

2009-02-06T22:23:45Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Monday dinner attendees */

__FORCETOC__

= First Face 2 Face meeting of odp Editorial Board =

=== Agenda ===

=== Venue ===

The meeting will be held at the '''Institute for Cognitive Science and Technology''', '''Piaget''' room (first floor).

Via San Martino della Battaglia 44, Rome

=== Hotels ===

==== *** ====

'''Hotel Villa delle Rose'''
* Address: Via Vicenza 5
* Phone: +39-06-4451795

* Rates:
** Single room: Euro 75,00
** Double room: Euro 100,00
** Breakfast included

* Distance and Route: walking distance, 3 minutes

* Web site: http://www.villadellerose.it/it/index.htm

'''Hotel S. Marco'''
* Address: Via Villafranca 1
* Phone: +3906490437

* Services:
** Pay tv
** Internet access
** minibar
** From 29.01.2009 to 15.03.2009 (free of charge)

* Rates:
** Single room : Euro 80
** Double room single occupancy: Euro 90
** Double room : Euro 99,00

* Distance and route: 1 minute walking distance

* Web site: http://www.hotelsanmarcoroma.com/

'''Hotel Montecarlo'''
* Address: Via Palestro 17/a
* Phone: +39064460000

* Rates:
** Single room: Euro 70,00
** Double room :Euro 90,00

* Distance and route: 4 minutes walking distance

* Web site: http://laral.istc.cnr.it/address.htm

==== **** ====

'''Hotel Artemide'''

* Address: Via Nazionale 22
* Phone: +3906489911

* Services
** Internet access
** Mini-bar
** Room service
** Satellite TV
** Free daily newspaper

* Rates:
** Single room: Euro 170,00
** Double single use : Euro 170,00
** Breakfast included

* Distance and route: 10 minutes walking

* Web site: http://www.hotelartemide.it/en/index.htm

'''Hotel Cosmopolita'''
* Address: Via di Sant'Eufemia 5 (close to Piazza Venezia)
* Phone: +390699707606

* Services:
** Internet access
** Mini-bar
** Direct phone
** Satellite TV
** Room service

* Rates
** Single room : Euro 120,00
** Double room: Euro 130,00
** Breakfast included

Web site: http://www.leonardihotels.com/Pace-Elvezia/index2.jsp

* Distance and route: Take the bus 40 in Piazza Venezia and get off after three stops at Termini Station. From Termini walk for 5 minutes.

* Web site: http://www.hotel-cosmopolita.com/

'''Hotel Pace Elvetia'''
* Address: Via IV Novembre 104
* Phone: +39066795105

* Services:
** Wi-Fi in the hall
** Bar and Rooftop Terrace
** Remote control satellite tv
** Minibar
** Direct-dial telephone

* Rates:
** Single room : Euro 80,00
** Double room: Euro 100,00
** Breakfast included

* Distance and route: Take the bus 40 in Piazza Venezia and get off after three stops at Termini Station. From Termini just walk for 5 minutes.

* Web site: http://www.leonardihotels.com/Pace-Elvezia/index2.jsp

=== Editorial Board member ===
{{Group eb members}}

=== Attendees ===
* [[User:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]
* [[User:RimDJEDIDI| Rim Djedidi]]
* [[User:VojtechSvatek| Vojtech Svatek]]
* [[User:VioletaDamjanovic| Violeta Damjanovic]]
* [[User:EnricoDaga| Enrico Daga]]
* [[User:GerdGroener| Gerd Groener]]

=== Sunday dinner attendees ===

* [[USer:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]
* [[USer:RimDJEDIDI| Rim Djedidi]]
* [[User:VojtechSvatek| Vojtech Svatek]] (coming quite late, after 11pm, if at all)

=== Monday dinner attendees ===
* [[USer:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]
* <s>[[User:VojtechSvatek| Vojtech Svatek]]</s> (unfortunately, Alitalia cancelled my flight and replaced with quite an early one for Tuesday, so I will have to go to bed very soon...)
* [[User:VioletaDamjanovic| Violeta Damjanovic]]
* [[User:GerdGroener| Gerd Groener]]
* [[USer:RimDJEDIDI| Rim Djedidi]]

=== Process Modeling Pattern Seminar (attendees) ===
* [[USer:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]
* [[User:VioletaDamjanovic| Violeta Damjanovic]]
* [[User:GerdGroener| Gerd Groener]]

=== Minutes ===

'Ontology Design Patterns':EB-1st-f2f-2009Feb23

2009-02-04T16:18:07Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Monday dinner attendees */

__FORCETOC__

= First Face 2 Face meeting of odp Editorial Board =

=== Agenda ===

=== Venue ===

The meeting will be held at the '''Institute for Cognitive Science and Technology''', '''Piaget''' room (first floor).

Via San Martino della Battaglia 44, Rome

=== Hotels ===

==== *** ====

'''Hotel Villa delle Rose'''
* Address: Via Vicenza 5
* Phone: +39-06-4451795

* Rates:
** Single room: Euro 75,00
** Double room: Euro 100,00
** Breakfast included

* Distance and Route: walking distance, 3 minutes

* Web site: http://www.villadellerose.it/it/index.htm

'''Hotel S. Marco'''
* Address: Via Villafranca 1
* Phone: +3906490437

* Services:
** Pay tv
** Internet access
** minibar
** From 29.01.2009 to 15.03.2009 (free of charge)

* Rates:
** Single room : Euro 80
** Double room single occupancy: Euro 90
** Double room : Euro 99,00

* Distance and route: 1 minute walking distance

* Web site: http://www.hotelsanmarcoroma.com/

'''Hotel Montecarlo'''
* Address: Via Palestro 17/a
* Phone: +39064460000

* Rates:
** Single room: Euro 70,00
** Double room :Euro 90,00

* Distance and route: 4 minutes walking distance

* Web site: http://laral.istc.cnr.it/address.htm

==== **** ====

'''Hotel Artemide'''

* Address: Via Nazionale 22
* Phone: +3906489911

* Services
** Internet access
** Mini-bar
** Room service
** Satellite TV
** Free daily newspaper

* Rates:
** Single room: Euro 170,00
** Double single use : Euro 170,00
** Breakfast included

* Distance and route: 10 minutes walking

* Web site: http://www.hotelartemide.it/en/index.htm

'''Hotel Cosmopolita'''
* Address: Via di Sant'Eufemia 5 (close to Piazza Venezia)
* Phone: +390699707606

* Services:
** Internet access
** Mini-bar
** Direct phone
** Satellite TV
** Room service

* Rates
** Single room : Euro 120,00
** Double room: Euro 130,00
** Breakfast included

Web site: http://www.leonardihotels.com/Pace-Elvezia/index2.jsp

* Distance and route: Take the bus 40 in Piazza Venezia and get off after three stops at Termini Station. From Termini walk for 5 minutes.

* Web site: http://www.hotel-cosmopolita.com/

'''Hotel Pace Elvetia'''
* Address: Via IV Novembre 104
* Phone: +39066795105

* Services:
** Wi-Fi in the hall
** Bar and Rooftop Terrace
** Remote control satellite tv
** Minibar
** Direct-dial telephone

* Rates:
** Single room : Euro 80,00
** Double room: Euro 100,00
** Breakfast included

* Distance and route: Take the bus 40 in Piazza Venezia and get off after three stops at Termini Station. From Termini just walk for 5 minutes.

* Web site: http://www.leonardihotels.com/Pace-Elvezia/index2.jsp

=== Editorial Board member ===
{{Group eb members}}

=== Attendees ===
* [[User:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]
* [[User:RimDJEDIDI| Rim Djedidi]]
* [[User:VojtechSvatek| Vojtech Svatek]]

=== Sunday dinner attendees ===

* [[USer:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]
* [[USer:RimDJEDIDI| Rim Djedidi]]
* [[User:VojtechSvatek| Vojtech Svatek]] (coming quite late, after 11pm, if at all)

=== Monday dinner attendees ===
* [[USer:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]
* [[User:VojtechSvatek| Vojtech Svatek]]

=== Process Modeling Pattern Seminar (attendees) ===
* [[USer:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]

=== Minutes ===

'Ontology Design Patterns':EB-1st-f2f-2009Feb23

2009-02-04T16:17:09Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Sunday dinner attendees */

__FORCETOC__

= First Face 2 Face meeting of odp Editorial Board =

=== Agenda ===

=== Venue ===

The meeting will be held at the '''Institute for Cognitive Science and Technology''', '''Piaget''' room (first floor).

Via San Martino della Battaglia 44, Rome

=== Hotels ===

==== *** ====

'''Hotel Villa delle Rose'''
* Address: Via Vicenza 5
* Phone: +39-06-4451795

* Rates:
** Single room: Euro 75,00
** Double room: Euro 100,00
** Breakfast included

* Distance and Route: walking distance, 3 minutes

* Web site: http://www.villadellerose.it/it/index.htm

'''Hotel S. Marco'''
* Address: Via Villafranca 1
* Phone: +3906490437

* Services:
** Pay tv
** Internet access
** minibar
** From 29.01.2009 to 15.03.2009 (free of charge)

* Rates:
** Single room : Euro 80
** Double room single occupancy: Euro 90
** Double room : Euro 99,00

* Distance and route: 1 minute walking distance

* Web site: http://www.hotelsanmarcoroma.com/

'''Hotel Montecarlo'''
* Address: Via Palestro 17/a
* Phone: +39064460000

* Rates:
** Single room: Euro 70,00
** Double room :Euro 90,00

* Distance and route: 4 minutes walking distance

* Web site: http://laral.istc.cnr.it/address.htm

==== **** ====

'''Hotel Artemide'''

* Address: Via Nazionale 22
* Phone: +3906489911

* Services
** Internet access
** Mini-bar
** Room service
** Satellite TV
** Free daily newspaper

* Rates:
** Single room: Euro 170,00
** Double single use : Euro 170,00
** Breakfast included

* Distance and route: 10 minutes walking

* Web site: http://www.hotelartemide.it/en/index.htm

'''Hotel Cosmopolita'''
* Address: Via di Sant'Eufemia 5 (close to Piazza Venezia)
* Phone: +390699707606

* Services:
** Internet access
** Mini-bar
** Direct phone
** Satellite TV
** Room service

* Rates
** Single room : Euro 120,00
** Double room: Euro 130,00
** Breakfast included

Web site: http://www.leonardihotels.com/Pace-Elvezia/index2.jsp

* Distance and route: Take the bus 40 in Piazza Venezia and get off after three stops at Termini Station. From Termini walk for 5 minutes.

* Web site: http://www.hotel-cosmopolita.com/

'''Hotel Pace Elvetia'''
* Address: Via IV Novembre 104
* Phone: +39066795105

* Services:
** Wi-Fi in the hall
** Bar and Rooftop Terrace
** Remote control satellite tv
** Minibar
** Direct-dial telephone

* Rates:
** Single room : Euro 80,00
** Double room: Euro 100,00
** Breakfast included

* Distance and route: Take the bus 40 in Piazza Venezia and get off after three stops at Termini Station. From Termini just walk for 5 minutes.

* Web site: http://www.leonardihotels.com/Pace-Elvezia/index2.jsp

=== Editorial Board member ===
{{Group eb members}}

=== Attendees ===
* [[User:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]
* [[User:RimDJEDIDI| Rim Djedidi]]
* [[User:VojtechSvatek| Vojtech Svatek]]

=== Sunday dinner attendees ===

* [[USer:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]
* [[USer:RimDJEDIDI| Rim Djedidi]]
* [[User:VojtechSvatek| Vojtech Svatek]] (coming quite late, after 11pm, if at all)

=== Monday dinner attendees ===
* [[USer:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]

=== Process Modeling Pattern Seminar (attendees) ===
* [[USer:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]

=== Minutes ===

'Ontology Design Patterns':EB-1st-f2f-2009Feb23

2009-02-04T16:16:04Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Sunday dinner attendees */

__FORCETOC__

= First Face 2 Face meeting of odp Editorial Board =

=== Agenda ===

=== Venue ===

The meeting will be held at the '''Institute for Cognitive Science and Technology''', '''Piaget''' room (first floor).

Via San Martino della Battaglia 44, Rome

=== Hotels ===

==== *** ====

'''Hotel Villa delle Rose'''
* Address: Via Vicenza 5
* Phone: +39-06-4451795

* Rates:
** Single room: Euro 75,00
** Double room: Euro 100,00
** Breakfast included

* Distance and Route: walking distance, 3 minutes

* Web site: http://www.villadellerose.it/it/index.htm

'''Hotel S. Marco'''
* Address: Via Villafranca 1
* Phone: +3906490437

* Services:
** Pay tv
** Internet access
** minibar
** From 29.01.2009 to 15.03.2009 (free of charge)

* Rates:
** Single room : Euro 80
** Double room single occupancy: Euro 90
** Double room : Euro 99,00

* Distance and route: 1 minute walking distance

* Web site: http://www.hotelsanmarcoroma.com/

'''Hotel Montecarlo'''
* Address: Via Palestro 17/a
* Phone: +39064460000

* Rates:
** Single room: Euro 70,00
** Double room :Euro 90,00

* Distance and route: 4 minutes walking distance

* Web site: http://laral.istc.cnr.it/address.htm

==== **** ====

'''Hotel Artemide'''

* Address: Via Nazionale 22
* Phone: +3906489911

* Services
** Internet access
** Mini-bar
** Room service
** Satellite TV
** Free daily newspaper

* Rates:
** Single room: Euro 170,00
** Double single use : Euro 170,00
** Breakfast included

* Distance and route: 10 minutes walking

* Web site: http://www.hotelartemide.it/en/index.htm

'''Hotel Cosmopolita'''
* Address: Via di Sant'Eufemia 5 (close to Piazza Venezia)
* Phone: +390699707606

* Services:
** Internet access
** Mini-bar
** Direct phone
** Satellite TV
** Room service

* Rates
** Single room : Euro 120,00
** Double room: Euro 130,00
** Breakfast included

Web site: http://www.leonardihotels.com/Pace-Elvezia/index2.jsp

* Distance and route: Take the bus 40 in Piazza Venezia and get off after three stops at Termini Station. From Termini walk for 5 minutes.

* Web site: http://www.hotel-cosmopolita.com/

'''Hotel Pace Elvetia'''
* Address: Via IV Novembre 104
* Phone: +39066795105

* Services:
** Wi-Fi in the hall
** Bar and Rooftop Terrace
** Remote control satellite tv
** Minibar
** Direct-dial telephone

* Rates:
** Single room : Euro 80,00
** Double room: Euro 100,00
** Breakfast included

* Distance and route: Take the bus 40 in Piazza Venezia and get off after three stops at Termini Station. From Termini just walk for 5 minutes.

* Web site: http://www.leonardihotels.com/Pace-Elvezia/index2.jsp

=== Editorial Board member ===
{{Group eb members}}

=== Attendees ===
* [[User:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]
* [[User:RimDJEDIDI| Rim Djedidi]]
* [[User:VojtechSvatek| Vojtech Svatek]]

=== Sunday dinner attendees ===

* [[USer:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]
* [[USer:RimDJEDIDI| Rim Djedidi]]
* [[User:VojtechSvatek| Vojtech Svatek] (coming quite late, after 11pm, if at all)]

=== Monday dinner attendees ===
* [[USer:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]

=== Process Modeling Pattern Seminar (attendees) ===
* [[USer:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]

=== Minutes ===

'Ontology Design Patterns':EB-1st-f2f-2009Feb23

2009-02-04T16:14:26Z

VojtechSvatek: /* Attendees */

__FORCETOC__

= First Face 2 Face meeting of odp Editorial Board =

=== Agenda ===

=== Venue ===

The meeting will be held at the '''Institute for Cognitive Science and Technology''', '''Piaget''' room (first floor).

Via San Martino della Battaglia 44, Rome

=== Hotels ===

==== *** ====

'''Hotel Villa delle Rose'''
* Address: Via Vicenza 5
* Phone: +39-06-4451795

* Rates:
** Single room: Euro 75,00
** Double room: Euro 100,00
** Breakfast included

* Distance and Route: walking distance, 3 minutes

* Web site: http://www.villadellerose.it/it/index.htm

'''Hotel S. Marco'''
* Address: Via Villafranca 1
* Phone: +3906490437

* Services:
** Pay tv
** Internet access
** minibar
** From 29.01.2009 to 15.03.2009 (free of charge)

* Rates:
** Single room : Euro 80
** Double room single occupancy: Euro 90
** Double room : Euro 99,00

* Distance and route: 1 minute walking distance

* Web site: http://www.hotelsanmarcoroma.com/

'''Hotel Montecarlo'''
* Address: Via Palestro 17/a
* Phone: +39064460000

* Rates:
** Single room: Euro 70,00
** Double room :Euro 90,00

* Distance and route: 4 minutes walking distance

* Web site: http://laral.istc.cnr.it/address.htm

==== **** ====

'''Hotel Artemide'''

* Address: Via Nazionale 22
* Phone: +3906489911

* Services
** Internet access
** Mini-bar
** Room service
** Satellite TV
** Free daily newspaper

* Rates:
** Single room: Euro 170,00
** Double single use : Euro 170,00
** Breakfast included

* Distance and route: 10 minutes walking

* Web site: http://www.hotelartemide.it/en/index.htm

'''Hotel Cosmopolita'''
* Address: Via di Sant'Eufemia 5 (close to Piazza Venezia)
* Phone: +390699707606

* Services:
** Internet access
** Mini-bar
** Direct phone
** Satellite TV
** Room service

* Rates
** Single room : Euro 120,00
** Double room: Euro 130,00
** Breakfast included

Web site: http://www.leonardihotels.com/Pace-Elvezia/index2.jsp

* Distance and route: Take the bus 40 in Piazza Venezia and get off after three stops at Termini Station. From Termini walk for 5 minutes.

* Web site: http://www.hotel-cosmopolita.com/

'''Hotel Pace Elvetia'''
* Address: Via IV Novembre 104
* Phone: +39066795105

* Services:
** Wi-Fi in the hall
** Bar and Rooftop Terrace
** Remote control satellite tv
** Minibar
** Direct-dial telephone

* Rates:
** Single room : Euro 80,00
** Double room: Euro 100,00
** Breakfast included

* Distance and route: Take the bus 40 in Piazza Venezia and get off after three stops at Termini Station. From Termini just walk for 5 minutes.

* Web site: http://www.leonardihotels.com/Pace-Elvezia/index2.jsp

=== Editorial Board member ===
{{Group eb members}}

=== Attendees ===
* [[User:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]
* [[User:RimDJEDIDI| Rim Djedidi]]
* [[User:VojtechSvatek| Vojtech Svatek]]

=== Sunday dinner attendees ===

* [[USer:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]
* [[USer:RimDJEDIDI| Rim Djedidi]]

=== Monday dinner attendees ===
* [[USer:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]

=== Process Modeling Pattern Seminar (attendees) ===
* [[USer:ValentinaPresutti| Valentina Presutti]]

=== Minutes ===