Reviews:BenedictoRodriguezCastro about Template Instance - Revision history

BenedictoRodriguezCastro at 17:24, 28 August 2012

2012-08-28T17:24:15Z

BenedictoRodriguezCastro at 17:07, 28 August 2012

2012-08-28T17:07:06Z

BenedictoRodriguezCastro at 17:00, 28 August 2012

2012-08-28T17:00:37Z

BenedictoRodriguezCastro at 16:54, 28 August 2012

2012-08-28T16:54:15Z

BenedictoRodriguezCastro: New page: {{Content OP Proposal Review Template |CreationDate=2012/8/28 |SubmittedBy=BenedictoRodriguezCastro |ContentOPUnderReview=Template Instance |RevisionID=11158 |Score=0 - needs major revisio...

2012-08-28T16:53:03Z

New page: {{Content OP Proposal Review Template |CreationDate=2012/8/28 |SubmittedBy=BenedictoRodriguezCastro |ContentOPUnderReview=Template Instance |RevisionID=11158 |Score=0 - needs major revisio...

New page

{{Content OP Proposal Review Template
|CreationDate=2012/8/28
|SubmittedBy=BenedictoRodriguezCastro
|ContentOPUnderReview=Template Instance
|RevisionID=11158
|Score=0 - needs major revision
|ReviewSummary=This pattern describes how to reify a reoccurring set of instances in a given ontology model. The pattern allows to minimize the number of times that the reoccurring instances need to be instantiated in the ontology model by creating the notion of an "instance template".
|ReviewConfidence=High. The pattern is given only in abstract terms. It is applicable to any domain. Domain-specific knowledge is not needed.
}}

@@ Line 11: / Line 11: @@
 Therefore, because of the reasons above, I would recommend to provide a major revision of the pattern to address them.
 |ReviewRelevance=Upfront, the modelling scenario addressed comes accross as very likely to occur and therefore the pattern can be very relevant to the community.
 |ReviewUnderstandability=There is opportunity to improve the understandability by providing a concrete example of the pattern in addition to the abstract one.
 |ReviewClearProblem=The problem can be also better characterized by giving a clear real world example of the modelling problem addresed.
 |ReviewFigures=The illustrations provided are very helpful. But again, lack of illustrations of a concrete example are missing.
 }}

@@ Line 11: / Line 11: @@
 Therefore, because of the reasons above, I would recommend to provide a major revision of the pattern to address them.
 |ReviewRelevance=Upfront, the modelling scenario addressed comes accross as very likely to occur and therefore the pattern can be very relevant to the community.
 }}

@@ Line 10: / Line 10: @@
 On the other hand, there are some aspects that hinders the applicability and understandability of the pattern, such as: (a) lack of a concrete example of the pattern supported by a corresponding graphical representation (b) the reusable building block in OWL provided contains only the annotation property mentioned in the pattern (c) the examples OWL files also refer to the implementation of the pattern in abstract terms (d) the known uses provided simply point to the landing website of two medical classifications but it is not clear how the pattern is actually used by these classification resources.
 Therefore, because of the reasons above, I would recommend to provide a major revision of the pattern to address them.
 }}

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 {{Content OP Proposal Review Template
 |SubmittedBy=BenedictoRodriguezCastro
 |ContentOPUnderReview=Template Instance
 |RevisionID=11158
 |Score=0 - needs major revision
 |ReviewSummary=This pattern describes how to reify a reoccurring set of instances in a given ontology model. The pattern allows to minimize the number of times that the reoccurring instances need to be instantiated in the ontology model by creating the notion of an "instance template".
 |ReviewConfidence=High. The pattern is given only in abstract terms. It is applicable to any domain. Domain-specific knowledge is not needed.
 }}