http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/index.php?action=history&feed=atom&title=Reviews%3AEnricoMotta_about_Literal_Reification 2026-06-18T06:52:15Z Revision history for this page on the wiki MediaWiki 1.25.6 http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/index.php?title=Reviews:EnricoMotta_about_Literal_Reification&diff=10127&oldid=prev 2010-09-19T19:24:12Z

<p>New page: {{Content OP Proposal Review Template |CreationDate=2010/9/19 |SubmittedBy=EnricoMotta |ContentOPUnderReview=Literal Reification |RevisionID=10110 |Score=1 - needs minor revision |ReviewSu...</p> <p><b>New page</b></p><div>{{Content OP Proposal Review Template<br /> |CreationDate=2010/9/19<br /> |SubmittedBy=EnricoMotta<br /> |ContentOPUnderReview=Literal Reification<br /> |RevisionID=10110<br /> |Score=1 - needs minor revision<br /> |ReviewSummary=Useful pattern supporting the reification of literal values within OWL, so that they can be used as 'first class objects' in OWL models. The pattern seems valid, however I had trouble trying to browse it in both NeOn and Topbraid, which made my life a bit painful. I am also surprised that the pattern does not clarify how to link the resulting reified literals to the obvious related entities - e,g, an entity such as http://dbpedia.org/resource/Hilton%2C_Paris, which describes ParisHilton.<br /> |ReviewConfidence=High<br /> |ReviewProblems=The OWL source does not load properly in either topbraid or neon. This should be fixed. <br /> |ReviewRelevance=This is very useful pattern applicable to zillions of scenarios<br /> |ReviewBestPractice=There are a lot of proposals about how to talk about tags and link web2.0 systems to the semantic web and a comparison with the way other people have tackled this problem would be useful.<br /> |ReviewReusability=The pattern is very reusable<br /> |ReviewUnderstandability=The pattern is reasonably easy to understand although the description, context and motivation are rather minimalist<br /> |ReviewClearProblem=I think the scenario could be made clearer and more meaningful by showing how to link tags to the owl entities denoting the same object as the tag<br /> |ReviewMissing=How do I link the tag :parisTag2 in your scenario to http://dbpedia.org/resource/Hilton%2C_Paris?<br /> }}</div>

EnricoMotta