http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/index.php?action=history&feed=atom&title=Reviews%3AGerdGroener_about_Standard_Enforcer_Pattern 2026-06-04T19:33:34Z Revision history for this page on the wiki MediaWiki 1.25.6 http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/index.php?title=Reviews:GerdGroener_about_Standard_Enforcer_Pattern&diff=11209&oldid=prev 2012-08-30T08:29:48Z

<p>New page: {{Content OP Proposal Review Template |CreationDate=2012/8/30 |SubmittedBy=GerdGroener |ContentOPUnderReview=Standard Enforcer Pattern |RevisionID=11149 |Score=1 - needs minor revision |Re...</p> <p><b>New page</b></p><div>{{Content OP Proposal Review Template<br /> |CreationDate=2012/8/30<br /> |SubmittedBy=GerdGroener<br /> |ContentOPUnderReview=Standard Enforcer Pattern<br /> |RevisionID=11149<br /> |Score=1 - needs minor revision<br /> |ReviewSummary=Pattern Summary<br /> <br /> The proposed pattern describes modelling guidelines<br /> to describe a standard and the process that enforce the standard.<br /> <br /> Evaluation of the Pattern<br /> <br /> The pattern is useful and the example helps to understand the pattern.<br /> I would suggest to elaborate the ontological presentation of the patter,<br /> i.e., explain in more detail the modelling principles (in OWL) of the pattern<br /> as depicted in Fig. 1.<br /> Furthermore, Fig. 1 is not readable as some text is missing (not completely displayed).<br /> Thus, for the final submission, both the Figure and the explanation of <br /> the OWL-modelling principles have to be improved/added.<br /> <br /> |ReviewConfidence=high<br /> |ReviewProblems=As mentioned above, the presentation needs some improvements:<br /> - Figure 1: Text is missing, some annotations are cut<br /> - Explanation of modelling principles (Explain modelling and design decisions of the patters, i.e., explain the modelling rationale of Figure 1.<br /> |ReviewRelevance=The pattern is relevant.<br /> |ReviewReusability=The pattern is reusable.<br /> |ReviewUnderstandability=The graphical representation (Figure 1) and the textual explanation of the pattern could be improved.<br /> |ReviewClearProblem=The problem is clearly described.<br /> |ReviewFigures=see comments above regarding Figure 1<br /> }}</div>

GerdGroener