http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/index.php?action=history&feed=atom&title=Reviews%3AVojtechSvatek_about_ConceptTerms 2026-04-25T10:40:08Z Revision history for this page on the wiki MediaWiki 1.25.6 http://ontologydesignpatterns.org/index.php?title=Reviews:VojtechSvatek_about_ConceptTerms&diff=5742&oldid=prev 2009-09-08T20:21:22Z

<p>New page: {{Content OP Proposal Review Template |CreationDate=2009/9/8 |SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek |ContentOPUnderReview=ConceptTerms |RevisionID=5714 |Score=0 - needs major revision |ReviewSummary=F...</p> <p><b>New page</b></p><div>{{Content OP Proposal Review Template<br /> |CreationDate=2009/9/8<br /> |SubmittedBy=VojtechSvatek<br /> |ContentOPUnderReview=ConceptTerms<br /> |RevisionID=5714<br /> |Score=0 - needs major revision<br /> |ReviewSummary=First of all, the pattern looks quite unfinished and/or sloppy in terms of documentation. Only when the modelling choices are explained, a true review could be done. <br /> |ReviewConfidence=The pattern is currently so simple that not much special expertise is needed. I am confident in my assessment.<br /> |ReviewProblems=It is not clear what a compound non preferred term looks like and why it is only made of preferred terms.<br /> <br /> The reification of the relation between a concept and the terms should be clearly justified.<br /> <br /> The scenario is too brief.<br /> |ReviewRelevance=The solution is kind of trivial. There are numerous efforts related to handling lexical aspects of ontologies.<br /> |ReviewReusability=High degree of reuse.<br /> |ReviewRelations=The pattern should probably mention the SKOS vocabulary, which addresses most of the problems in question.<br /> |ReviewUnderstandability=Simple and understandable, except for clearly missing information.<br /> |ReviewClearProblem=Could do, although I would imagine something a bit different under 'language complexity'.<br /> |ReviewClearRelevance=Not much information about consequences.<br /> |ReviewFigures=Only the basic diagram, which looks OK.<br /> |ReviewMissing=Especially information (and examples) on compound non-preferred terms.<br /> }}</div>

VojtechSvatek