Training:Legal Ontology Design/LegalPersonExercise - Revision history

AldoGangemi at 23:27, 8 September 2009

2009-09-08T23:27:26Z

MeritxellFernandez at 17:36, 8 September 2009

2009-09-08T17:36:45Z

MeritxellFernandez: New page: {{Exercise Description Template |Tutorial=Legal Ontology Design |Title=LegalPersonExercise |Problem=To model one of the following sentences by reusing content patterns. Each sentence is as...

2009-09-08T17:16:42Z

New page: {{Exercise Description Template |Tutorial=Legal Ontology Design |Title=LegalPersonExercise |Problem=To model one of the following sentences by reusing content patterns. Each sentence is as...

New page

{{Exercise Description Template
|Tutorial=Legal Ontology Design
|Title=LegalPersonExercise
|Problem=To model one of the following sentences by reusing content patterns. Each sentence is associated to a set of compentency questions that target legal concepts:

* '''s1''': FIAT (Fabbrica Italiana Automobili Torino) was founded in Turin in 1899 by Bricherasio, Goria, Biscaretti, Ferrero, Ceriana-Mayneri, Racca, Scarfiotti, Damerino, Agnelli and the Bank di Sconto e Sete.
* '''instance-free s1''':
# Legal persons are founded by persons (legal or physical) with legal capacity.
# Legal persons are founded at a certain point in time.
# Legal persons have a location.
* '''s1 competency questions'''
** '''cq1''': Who founded the legal person?
** '''cq2''': When was the legal person founded?
** '''cq3''': Where is the legal person based?

* '''s2''': The deed of constitution was drafted by a public notary, signed by all the founders and registered on the 11th July 1899.
* '''instance-free s2''':
# Legal persons are created by a deed of constitution.
# The deed of constitution is drafted by a public notary.
# The deed is signed by the founder persons at a certain point in time.

* '''s2 competency questions'''
** '''cq4''': Who signed the deed of constitution of a certain legal person?
** '''cq5''': Who prepared the deed of constitution?
** '''cq6''': When and where was the deed signed and registered?

* '''s3''': In 1902 Giovanni Agnelli was director of FIAT.
* '''instance-free s3''':
# A person has a role.
# Persons can be directors of a legal person during a certain time interval.

* '''s3 competency questions'''
** '''cq7''': Who was director of a legal person?
** '''cq8''': When was someone director of a legal person?

* '''s4''': In 1984 FIAT acquired Alfa Romeo.
* '''instance-free s4''':
# Legal persons can acquire other legal persons.
# Acquisitions take place at a certain point in time.

* '''s4 competency questions'''
** '''cq9''': Who acquired a certain legal person?
** '''cq10''': When did a certain legal person acquire another legal person?

}}

@@ Line 8: / Line 8: @@
 # Legal persons are founded by persons (legal or physical) with legal capacity.
 # Legal persons are founded at a certain point in time.
-# Legal persons have a location.
+# Legal persons are founded at a location.
 * '''s1 competency questions'''
-** '''cq1''': Who founded the legal person?
+** '''cq1''': Who founded a legal person?
-** '''cq2''': When was the legal person founded?
+** '''cq2''': When was a legal person founded?
-** '''cq3''': Where is the legal person based?
+** '''cq3''': Where was a legal person founded?
-* '''s2''': The deed of constitution was drafted by a public notary, signed by all the founders and registered on the 11th July 1899.
+* '''s2''': The deed of constitution of FIAT, showing the Savoy coat of arms and the original company name on its cover, was drafted by the public notary Ernesto Torretta, signed by all the founders, and registered on the 11th July 1899.
 * '''instance-free s2''':
 # Legal persons are created by a deed of constitution.
-# The deed of constitution is drafted by a public notary.
+# A deed of constitution shows text and pictures.
-# The deed is signed by the founder persons at a certain point in time.
+# A deed of constitution is drafted by a public notary.
 * '''s2 competency questions'''
 ** '''cq4''': Who signed the deed of constitution of a certain legal person?
-** '''cq5''': Who prepared the deed of constitution?
+** '''cq5''': What is shown in a deed of constitution?
-** '''cq6''': When and where was the deed signed and registered?
+** '''cq6''': Who prepared a deed of constitution?
-* '''s3''': In 1902 Giovanni Agnelli was director of FIAT.
+* '''s3''': In 1902 Giovanni Agnelli was CEO of FIAT.
 * '''instance-free s3''':
-# A person has a role.
+# A person is CEO of a legal person.
-# Persons can be directors of a legal person during a certain time interval.
+# Persons can be CEO of a legal person during a certain time interval.
 * '''s3 competency questions'''
-** '''cq7''': Who was director of a legal person?
+** '''cq8''': Who is CEO of a legal person?
-** '''cq8''': When was someone director of a legal person?
+** '''cq9''': In what time interval is someone CEO of a legal person?
 * '''s4''': In 1949 FIAT started producing the models 500C, 1100E and 1500E.
 * '''instance-free s4''':
-# Legal persons perform actions.
+# Automotive companies produce car models.
-# Actions take place at certain points in time.
+# Car models start being produced from a certain time on.
 * '''s4 competency questions'''
-** '''cq9''': Who produced a certain car model?
+** '''cq10''': What company produces a certain car model?
-** '''cq10''': When did someone produce a certain car model?
+** '''cq11''': When did a company start producing a certain car model?
-* '''s5''': In 1984 FIAT acquired Alfa Romeo.
+* '''s5''': In 1984 FIAT acquired Alfa Romeo for £750 billion.
 * '''instance-free s5''':
-# Legal persons can acquire other legal persons.
+# Legal persons acquire other legal persons at a certain time and a certain cost.
-# Acquisitions take place at a certain point in time.
 * '''s5 competency questions'''
-** '''cq11''': Who acquired a certain legal person?
+** '''cq12''': Who, when, and for how much acquired a certain legal person?
-** '''cq12''': When did a certain legal person acquire another legal person?
-−
-−
 }}