Reviews:AldoGangemi about VesselWaterArea

From Odp

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(New page: {{Content OP Proposal Review Template |CreationDate=2009/3/17 |SubmittedBy=AldoGangemi |ContentOPUnderReview=VesselWaterArea |RevisionID=3687 |ReviewText=After Aureliano's evaluation, here...)
Current revision (09:12, 5 August 2009) (view source)
m (Text replace - '|ReviewText=' to '|ReviewSummary=')
 
(One intermediate revision not shown.)
Line 4: Line 4:
|ContentOPUnderReview=VesselWaterArea
|ContentOPUnderReview=VesselWaterArea
|RevisionID=3687
|RevisionID=3687
-
|ReviewText=After Aureliano's evaluation, here you need to link vesseltypes to geartypes to species to water areas, therefore the pattern requires at least four classes, with relations between vesseltypes to geartypes, geartypes to species and species to water areas respectively.
+
|Score=2 - need major revision
 +
|ReviewSummary=After Aureliano's evaluation, here you need to link vesseltypes to geartypes to species to water areas, therefore the pattern requires at least four classes, with relations between vesseltypes to geartypes, geartypes to species and species to water areas respectively.
The synthetic relation can then be instantiated by using SPARQL CONSTRUCT.
The synthetic relation can then be instantiated by using SPARQL CONSTRUCT.
Alternatively, it can be generated with a SWRL rule, or by using an OWL2 alternate pattern, in which a property chain is defined (best practice).
Alternatively, it can be generated with a SWRL rule, or by using an OWL2 alternate pattern, in which a property chain is defined (best practice).
}}
}}

Current revision


AldoGangemi about VesselWaterArea (Revision ID: 3687)

Overall suggestion (score): 2 - need major revision

Review Summary: After Aureliano's evaluation, here you need to link vesseltypes to geartypes to species to water areas, therefore the pattern requires at least four classes, with relations between vesseltypes to geartypes, geartypes to species and species to water areas respectively.

The synthetic relation can then be instantiated by using SPARQL CONSTRUCT.

Alternatively, it can be generated with a SWRL rule, or by using an OWL2 alternate pattern, in which a property chain is defined (best practice).
Reviewer Confidence:
Problems:
Community Relevance:
Relation to Best Practices:
Reusability:
Relations to Other Patterns:
Overall Understandability:
Clear Problem Description:
Clear Relevance and Consequences:
Clear Figures and Illustrations:
Missing Information:

Posted: 2009/3/17 Last modified: 2009/8/5

All reviews | Add a comment at the bottom of this page
Personal tools
Quality Committee
Content OP publishers