Reviews:Biological Entities Review ValentinaPresutti

From Odp

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 2: Line 2:
|SubmittedBy=ValentinaPresutti
|SubmittedBy=ValentinaPresutti
|ContentOPUnderReview=Biological Entities
|ContentOPUnderReview=Biological Entities
 +
|RevisionID=2011
|CreationDate=10/04/2008
|CreationDate=10/04/2008
|ReviewText=* The CP needs to be improved. 
* All ontology elements have to be associated with a description. 
* The domain and range is the same for the three object properties: [[Submissions:Biological_Entities/biological_entity| biological_entity]]. However, there is a local restriction on their usage. It seems to me that domain and range should be personalized for each object properties as the classes you restrict on are disjoint. In other words, you do not want to allow for example the assigment of a value of [[Submissions:Biological_Entities/includesOrder| includesOrder]] for a certain [[Submissions:Biological_Entities/family| family]]. 
This is now possible as the [[Submissions:Biological_Entities/includesOrder| includesOrder]] property has domain [[Submissions:Biological_Entities/biological_entity| biological_entity]].
* The CP should import the CP annotation schema (http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/schemas/cpannotationschema.owl). 
* Which are the competency questions of this CP? And examples?
|ReviewText=* The CP needs to be improved. 
* All ontology elements have to be associated with a description. 
* The domain and range is the same for the three object properties: [[Submissions:Biological_Entities/biological_entity| biological_entity]]. However, there is a local restriction on their usage. It seems to me that domain and range should be personalized for each object properties as the classes you restrict on are disjoint. In other words, you do not want to allow for example the assigment of a value of [[Submissions:Biological_Entities/includesOrder| includesOrder]] for a certain [[Submissions:Biological_Entities/family| family]]. 
This is now possible as the [[Submissions:Biological_Entities/includesOrder| includesOrder]] property has domain [[Submissions:Biological_Entities/biological_entity| biological_entity]].
* The CP should import the CP annotation schema (http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/schemas/cpannotationschema.owl). 
* Which are the competency questions of this CP? And examples?
}}
}}

Revision as of 15:03, 10 June 2008


ValentinaPresutti about Biological Entities (Revision ID: Entities?oldid=2011 2011)

Overall suggestion (score):

Review Summary:
Reviewer Confidence:
Problems:
Community Relevance:
Relation to Best Practices:
Reusability:
Relations to Other Patterns:
Overall Understandability:
Clear Problem Description:
Clear Relevance and Consequences:
Clear Figures and Illustrations:
Missing Information:

Posted: 10/04/2008 Last modified: 2008/6/10

All reviews | Add a comment at the bottom of this page
Personal tools
Quality Committee
Content OP publishers