Browse wiki
From Odp
| Reviews:GerdGroener about SynonymOrEquivalence (SOE) |
| CreationDate | 8 September 2009 + |
|---|---|
| HasClearFigures | Figures are missing. |
| HasClearProblemDescription | The problem is clearly described. |
| HasClearRelevanceDescription | The relevance of the pattern and its benefits are given. |
| HasMissingInformation | Provide simple examples: ontology + description. |
| HasProblems | Due to the simplicity of the pattern I doubt that the notion of a design pattern somehow changes to a collection of simple modeling primitives. |
| HasRelevance | Definitely relevant for the community. |
| HasReusability | The pattern is reusable. |
| HasReviewScore | 0 -needsmajorrevision + |
| HasReviewSummary | The proposed pattern (or anti-pattern) is … The proposed pattern (or anti-pattern) is useful for ontology engineering, especially for less experienced developers. It focuses a common modeling problem. The proposed anti-pattern is technical sound. However, it is quite simple. Due to the simplicity of the pattern there are few discussion issues at WOP. rn there are few discussion issues at WOP. |
| HasReviewerConfidence | The reviewer is familiar with ODPs in general and with the described modeling issue and proposed solution. |
| HasUnderstandability | The motivation of the pattern is well written. Unfortunately there is a breakup in the text. The overall description of the pattern is well understandable. |
| IsBestPractice | Relevant to best practice modeling. |
| LastModifiedDate | 10 September 2009 + |
| Modification dateThis property is a special property in this wiki. | 10 September 2009 13:04:46 + |
| ReviewAboutSubmissionThis property is a special property in this wiki. | SynonymOrEquivalence (SOE) + |
| ReviewAboutVersion | 5,709 + |
| SubmittedBy | GerdGroener + |
| Categories | QCReview + |
| show properties that link here |
