ArmirBujari (Talk | contribs) |
ArmirBujari (Talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 14: | Line 14: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| − | | 4 || CQ: During what time period was a certain album of a certain band recorded?|| || Ontology graph reasoning, property and dataProperty check|| There is not a well defined notion of time for a recorded album, albumRecordedIn is a property that seems suited for this but has not been defined accordingly (no domain or range), which could lead to strange definitions by users of the ontology.|| || | + | | 4 || CQ: During what time period was a certain album of a certain band recorded?|| || Ontology graph reasoning, property and dataProperty check|| There is not a well defined notion of time for a recorded album, albumRecordedIn is a property that seems suited for this but has not been defined accordingly (no domain or range), which could even lead to strange definitions by users of the ontology.|| || |
|- | |- | ||
| − | | 5 || || || || || || | + | | 5 || Reasoning requirement: attribute Genre to Band || || || There is no (property/attribute) of type genre for a Band so it can be inferred|| || |
| Number | Requirement tested | Method used | Test applied | Error(s) found | Suggestions/ideas for solution | Additional notes |
| 1 | Contextual Statement: A track has only one genre | Unit test(Track, genre) Query:SELECT ?p ?y WHERE { ?p a :Track . ?p :genre ?y } | The ontology does not guarantee the genre uniqueness of a track | |||
| 2 | Contextual Statement: A track realizes only one song | Unit test(Track, recordingOf) Query:SELECT ?p ?y WHERE { ?p a :Track . ?p :recordingOf ?y } | The ontology does not guarantee the uniqueness of song-track | |||
| 3 | CQ: What role does a certain person have in a certain band at a certain point in time? | Ontology graph reasoning | I cannot deduce the role of the band member, there is no trace of historical roles. |
| ||
| 4 | CQ: During what time period was a certain album of a certain band recorded? | Ontology graph reasoning, property and dataProperty check | There is not a well defined notion of time for a recorded album, albumRecordedIn is a property that seems suited for this but has not been defined accordingly (no domain or range), which could even lead to strange definitions by users of the ontology. |
| ||
| 5 | Reasoning requirement: attribute Genre to Band | There is no (property/attribute) of type genre for a Band so it can be inferred |
'Ontology Design Patterns'