Reviews:MariaPoveda about TransportPattern Revision as of 07:48, 6 August 2013 by MariaPoveda (Talk | contribs) (New page: {{Content OP Proposal Review Template |CreationDate=2013/8/6 |SubmittedBy=MariaPoveda |ContentOPUnderReview=TransportPattern |RevisionID=11661 |Score=0 - needs major revision |ReviewSummar...) (diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

{{#reviewabout:Submissions:TransportPattern|}}

MariaPoveda about TransportPattern (Revision ID: 11661)

Overall suggestion (score): 0 - needs major revision

Review Summary: The goal of this pattern is modelling the movement of mass or energy from one place to another. Two competency questions are presented however the pattern does not seem to represent the information needed for answering them. Also, several fields are missing (e.g. scenarios, examples, related CPs)

Reviewer Confidence: High confidence in ontology patterns and low confidence in the given domain.

Problems: My main problems about this pattern are:

1) The solution proposed is that general that needs a lot of effort to extend and specialize it so that the proposed competency questions could be answered.

2) The authors do not reuse or mention the already existing pattern "Move"

Community Relevance: Fair

Relation to Best Practices: Low

Reusability: Fair

Relations to Other Patterns: part-of, Move

Overall Understandability: The pattern is not described in detail in the wiki page, it is difficult to understand it without the corresponding paper.

Clear Problem Description: Good

Clear Relevance and Consequences: Fair

Clear Figures and Illustrations: There is no diagram nor illustration.

Missing Information: Diagram

Scenarios Web references Examples

Related CPs

Posted: 2013/8/6 Last modified: 2013/08/6

All reviews | Add a comment at the bottom of this page