Reviews:BorisVillaz�n-Terrazas about TransportPattern
Revision as of 04:37, 6 August 2013 by {{| (Talk | contribs)}} (New page: {{Content OP Proposal Review Template |CreationDate=2013/8/6 |SubmittedBy=BorisVillazón-Terrazas |ContentOPUnderReview=TransportPattern |RevisionID=11643 |Score=1 - needs minor revision |...)

(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

BorisVillazón-Terrazas about TransportPattern (Revision ID: 11643)

Overall suggestion (score): 1 - needs minor revision

Review Summary: The author claims that the goal of the pattern is to facilitate modelling the movement of mass or energy from one location to another, based on a common persistent frame of reference. However, I'm not sure if the property transportEvent fully covers the aspect of the movement mass. The authors should clarify and improve the description of this.

Reviewer Confidence: I have a medium knowledge of patterns, but I'm not an expert on the energy domain.

Problems: I think the pattern needs a bit more explanation and probably a very interesting use case description.

Community Relevance: Fair

Relation to Best Practices: Fair

Reusability: Good

Relations to Other Patterns: part-of

Overall Understandability: Good

Clear Problem Description: Good

Clear Relevance and Consequences: Fair

Clear Figures and Illustrations: Fair

Missing Information: You neeed to improve the use case scenario.

Posted: 2013/8/6 Last modified: 2013/08/6

All reviews | Add a comment at the bottom of this page