Latest revision as of 08:29, 31 May 2010

Warning!

This is an old revision. Go to current revision

Last modified date is: 2010-05-31

Graphical representation

Diagram (this article has no graphical representation)

Name	DisjointnessOfComplement (DOC)
Also known as
Author(s)
SubmittedBy	CatherineRoussey, OscarCorcho

Motivation	We have identified a set of patterns that are commonly used by domain experts in their DL formalisations and OWL implementations, and that normally result in unsatisfiable classes or modelling errors. As aforementioned all these antipatterns come from a misuse and misunderstanding of DL expressions by ontology developers. Thus they are all Logical AntiPatterns (LAP): they are independent from a specific domain of interest, but dependent on the expressivity of the logical formalism used for the representation.
Aim	The ontology developer may want to say that C1 and C2 cannot share instances, instead of defining C1 as the logical negation of C2. Hence it could be more appropriate to state that C1 and C2 are disjoint.
Solution description	C1 isEquivalentTo not C2 should be replace by C1 disjointWith C2
Elements
Implementation
Reusable component
Component type

Problem example	Salt_Lagoon isEquivalentTo not Fresh_Waters see concept Laguna_Salada in Hydrontology
Pattern solution example	http://www.dia.fi.upm.es/~ocorcho/OWLDebugging/
Consequences

Scenarios about DisjointnessOfComplement (DOC)

No scenario is added to this Content OP.

Reviews about DisjointnessOfComplement (DOC)

There is no review about this proposal.

Some subquery has no valid condition.

This revision (revision ID 9703) takes in account the reviews: none

Modeling issues about DisjointnessOfComplement (DOC)

There is no Modeling issue related to this proposal.

Some subquery has no valid condition.

	Submission to event WOP:2009

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 {{Logical_OP_Proposal_toolbar}}
-{{Include Image}}
+{{Graphical representation header}}
+{{Graphical representation}}
 {{Logical OP General Template
 |Name=DisjointnessOfComplement (DOC)
 |SubmittedBy=CatherineRoussey, OscarCorcho,
 }}
 {{Logical OP Description Template
@@ Line 18: / Line 19: @@
 }}
 {{Logical OP Reference Template}}
+{{Additional information header}}
+[[Category:Review assigned]]
 {{Scenarios about me}}
 {{Reviews about me}}
+{{Modeling issues about me}}
+{{My references}}
 {{Submission to event
-|Event=WOP2009:Main
+|Event=WOP:2009
 }}
-[[Category:Review assigned]]