|
|
| Line 34: |
Line 34: |
| | ** '''cq8''': When was someone director of a legal person? | | ** '''cq8''': When was someone director of a legal person? |
| | | | |
| − | * '''s4''': In 1984 FIAT acquired Alfa Romeo. | + | * '''s4''': In 1949 FIAT started producing the models 500C, 1100E and 1500E. |
| | * '''instance-free s4''': | | * '''instance-free s4''': |
| | + | # Legal persons perform actions. |
| | + | # Actions take place at certain points in time. |
| | + | |
| | + | * '''s4 competency questions''' |
| | + | ** '''cq9''': Who produced a certain car model? |
| | + | ** '''cq10''': When did someone produce a certain car model? |
| | + | |
| | + | * '''s5''': In 1984 FIAT acquired Alfa Romeo. |
| | + | * '''instance-free s5''': |
| | # Legal persons can acquire other legal persons. | | # Legal persons can acquire other legal persons. |
| | # Acquisitions take place at a certain point in time. | | # Acquisitions take place at a certain point in time. |
| | | | |
| − | * '''s4 competency questions''' | + | * '''s5 competency questions''' |
| − | ** '''cq9''': Who acquired a certain legal person? | + | ** '''cq11''': Who acquired a certain legal person? |
| − | ** '''cq10''': When did a certain legal person acquire another legal person? | + | ** '''cq12''': When did a certain legal person acquire another legal person? |
| | + | |
| | | | |
| | }} | | }} |
Revision as of 17:36, 8 September 2009
Problem:
To model one of the following sentences by reusing content patterns. Each sentence is associated to a set of compentency questions that target legal concepts:
- s1: FIAT (Fabbrica Italiana Automobili Torino) was founded in Turin in 1899 by Bricherasio, Goria, Biscaretti, Ferrero, Ceriana-Mayneri, Racca, Scarfiotti, Damerino, Agnelli and the Bank di Sconto e Sete.
- instance-free s1:
- Legal persons are founded by persons (legal or physical) with legal capacity.
- Legal persons are founded at a certain point in time.
- Legal persons have a location.
- s1 competency questions
- cq1: Who founded the legal person?
- cq2: When was the legal person founded?
- cq3: Where is the legal person based?
- s2: The deed of constitution was drafted by a public notary, signed by all the founders and registered on the 11th July 1899.
- instance-free s2:
- Legal persons are created by a deed of constitution.
- The deed of constitution is drafted by a public notary.
- The deed is signed by the founder persons at a certain point in time.
- s2 competency questions
- cq4: Who signed the deed of constitution of a certain legal person?
- cq5: Who prepared the deed of constitution?
- cq6: When and where was the deed signed and registered?
- s3: In 1902 Giovanni Agnelli was director of FIAT.
- instance-free s3:
- A person has a role.
- Persons can be directors of a legal person during a certain time interval.
- s3 competency questions
- cq7: Who was director of a legal person?
- cq8: When was someone director of a legal person?
- s4: In 1949 FIAT started producing the models 500C, 1100E and 1500E.
- instance-free s4:
- Legal persons perform actions.
- Actions take place at certain points in time.
- s4 competency questions
- cq9: Who produced a certain car model?
- cq10: When did someone produce a certain car model?
- s5: In 1984 FIAT acquired Alfa Romeo.
- instance-free s5:
- Legal persons can acquire other legal persons.
- Acquisitions take place at a certain point in time.
- s5 competency questions
- cq11: Who acquired a certain legal person?
- cq12: When did a certain legal person acquire another legal person?
Solutions:
'Ontology Design Patterns'