From Odp

Jump to: navigation, search

This is a property of type Text.

(previous 25) (next 25)

Pages using the property "HasClearRelevanceDescription"

Showing 25 pages using this property.


AldoGangemi about ConceptGroup +Must be explained better
AlessandroAdamou about DisjointnessOfComplement (DOC) +As per problem description, the authors should display how such bizarre phenomena should not occur if disjointness is used instead.
AlessandroAdamou about Inverse n-ary relationship +Clear if we don't take into account that the "bridge" property pair does not show a connection to those between the main participants and the n-ary relationship class.
AlessandroAdamou about Object with states +The requirement of modeling states as individuals is a significant example of conformance to best practices. The current ODP has a strict limitation to tripartite states - if this is not relaxed, it should be mentioned in the consequences.
AlessandroAdamou about OnlynessIsLoneliness (OIL) +Perhaps ontology developers should be help Perhaps ontology developers should be helped a little more in finding out when this patterns applies to their case. The authors suggest to replace two or more anonymous classes with a single one "if it makes sense", but not everyone might have a clue as to when it makes sense and when it doesn't. If the statements can be considered equivalent (which is my impression), then this should be made clear, otherwise an example, describing how different facts can be inferred from using different methods, is needed. d from using different methods, is needed.
AlessandroAdamou about Reactor pattern +Clear. Thers's one extra newline in the "Consequences" field.
AlessandroAdamou about Symmetric n-ary relationship +As stated earlier, this proposal seems to be generating side effects with rspect to redundancy. If the authors can rule out these side effects, they should make a clearer statement about them.
AndreaNuzzolese about Faceted Classification Scheme +High.


BenedictoRodriguezCastro about Object with states 2 +The relevance and consequences are not dis The relevance and consequences are not discussed. These two aspects could be addressed providing some background and overall outlook of how this object with states modeling scenario have been handled (if at all) prior to the proposed solution by the author. What were the main shortcomings of those previous approaches? shortcomings of those previous approaches?
BenedictoRodriguezCastro about TransportPattern +See section "Review Summary".
BorisVillazón-Terrazas about Define Hybrid Class Resolving Disjointness due to Subsomption +Yes
BorisVillazón-Terrazas about Faceted Classification Scheme +Good
BorisVillazón-Terrazas about Normalization +Good
BorisVillazón-Terrazas about TransportPattern +Fair
BorisVillazón-Terrazas about Xsd:sequence embedding +Not clear


CatherineRoussey about SimpleOrAggregated +The consequence on individual are not well The consequence on individual are not well described. If a whole is composed of two aggregatedMembers which are fixed as equivalent, the whole is still classified as a aggregatedObject. Is it what do you expect from the reasoner? Moreover if the whole is classified as a simple Object and is composed of two objects that are equivalent to each other there are an unconsistency... So I do no think that the reasoning about number of parts is possible with this pattern... of parts is possible with this pattern...


EnricoDaga about Xsd:sequence embedding +Not clear at the moment.


FrancoisScharffe about Classification scheme - adjacency list model - to Taxonomy +Not clear. Please state this pattern is only valid if the adjacency list supposes a subsumption between the entities.
FrancoisScharffe about ConceptGroup +Here it misses a statement about the pattern usage together with SKOS
FrancoisScharffe about Enlarge Class Definition for Resolving Disjointness due to Subsomption +Relevance is clear. However logical consequences of enlarging definition is a bit obscure.


GerdGroener about Classification scheme - path enumeration model - to Taxonomy +medium
GerdGroener about DisjointnessOfComplement (DOC) +medium
GerdGroener about SynonymOrEquivalence (SOE) +The relevance of the pattern and its benefits are given.


HenrikEriksson about Partition +No.


JoseEmilioLabraGayo about LicenseLinkedDataResources +This pattern or some variation of this pattern should be adopted in order for the linked data project to success.
(previous 25) (next 25)
Personal tools
Quality Committee
Content OP publishers