Reviews:GerdGroener about SimpleOrAggregated

From Odp

Jump to: navigation, search

GerdGroener about SimpleOrAggregated (Revision ID: 10097)

Overall suggestion (score): 2 - accept for certification

Review Summary: The pattern describes a disjoint partition of objects into simple and aggregated objects that consist of at least two objects.

The proposed solution seems to be sound.

There is just one minor remark (see problems).
Reviewer Confidence: high
Problems: I was a bit distracted by the terms "non-transitive fashion". What is non-transitive? Are the aggregated objects non-transitive connected? Is it relevant or why is it relevant? This should be clarified in the final version
Community Relevance: good
Relation to Best Practices: good
Relations to Other Patterns:
Overall Understandability: See the comment above (Problems)
Clear Problem Description:
Clear Relevance and Consequences:
Clear Figures and Illustrations:
Missing Information:

Posted: 2010/9/10 Last modified: 2010/9/10

All reviews | Add a comment at the bottom of this page
Personal tools
Quality Committee
Content OP publishers