| CreationDate
|
11 September 2009 +
|
| HasClearFigures
|
Okay
|
| HasClearProblemDescription
|
Okay
|
| HasClearRelevanceDescription
|
Here it misses a statement about the pattern usage together with SKOS
|
| HasMissingInformation
|
The pattern description misses an example instanciation.
|
| HasProblems
|
The problem of modeling group membership is important
|
| HasRelations
|
It is only indicated that this pattern is extracted from SNOMED-CT.
|
| HasRelevance
|
relevant
|
| HasReusability
|
Yesm this pattern seem to be usable in a variety of situations
|
| HasReviewScore
|
0 -needsmajorrevision +
|
| HasReviewSummary
|
This pattern is meant to be used to repres … This pattern is meant to be used to represent group memberships of concepts. Sub and super groups can be represented, and both extensional (declared) and intensional (according to a property) memberships can be modeled.
The pattern seems interesting but present many shadowed areas. I can deduce from the usage of the terms concept ans broader/narrower relations that this pattern is to be used together with the SKOS vocabulary. If this is the case this should be made explicit. Otherwise, what is a concept wrt an owl:Class ?
I lack an example instantiation of the pattern.
The Solution Description contains questions ... Questions are no solutions...
In summary I think it is an interesting pattern which could certainly find applications when publishing terminologies with SKOS. The pattern however needs to be better described. This pattern can definitely lead to interesting discussions. efinitely lead to interesting discussions.
|
| HasReviewerConfidence
|
average
|
| HasUnderstandability
|
Okay
|
| IsBestPractice
|
If there are other solutions they are not mentioned by the pattern.
|
| LastModifiedDate
|
11 September 2009 +
|
| Modification dateThis property is a special property in this wiki.
|
11 September 2009 11:59:57 +
|
| ReviewAboutSubmissionThis property is a special property in this wiki.
|
ConceptGroup +
|
| ReviewAboutVersion
|
5,799 +
|
| SubmittedBy
|
FrancoisScharffe +
|
| Categories |
QCReview +
|
