| CreationDate
|
30 August 2012 +
|
| HasClearFigures
|
see comments above regarding Figure 1
|
| HasClearProblemDescription
|
The problem is clearly described.
|
| HasProblems
|
As mentioned above, the presentation needs … As mentioned above, the presentation needs some improvements:
- Figure 1: Text is missing, some annotations are cut
- Explanation of modelling principles (Explain modelling and design decisions of the patters, i.e., explain the modelling rationale of Figure 1. plain the modelling rationale of Figure 1.
|
| HasRelevance
|
The pattern is relevant.
|
| HasReusability
|
The pattern is reusable.
|
| HasReviewScore
|
1 -needsminorrevision +
|
| HasReviewSummary
|
Pattern Summary
The proposed pattern desc … Pattern Summary
The proposed pattern describes modelling guidelines
to describe a standard and the process that enforce the standard.
Evaluation of the Pattern
The pattern is useful and the example helps to understand the pattern.
I would suggest to elaborate the ontological presentation of the patter,
i.e., explain in more detail the modelling principles (in OWL) of the pattern
as depicted in Fig. 1.
Furthermore, Fig. 1 is not readable as some text is missing (not completely displayed).
Thus, for the final submission, both the Figure and the explanation of
the OWL-modelling principles have to be improved/added. ling principles have to be improved/added.
|
| HasReviewerConfidence
|
high
|
| HasUnderstandability
|
The graphical representation (Figure 1) and the textual explanation of the pattern could be improved.
|
| LastModifiedDate
|
30 August 2012 +
|
| Modification dateThis property is a special property in this wiki.
|
30 August 2012 08:29:48 +
|
| ReviewAboutSubmissionThis property is a special property in this wiki.
|
Standard Enforcer Pattern +
|
| ReviewAboutVersion
|
11,149 +
|
| SubmittedBy
|
GerdGroener +
|
| Categories |
QCReview +
|
