Browse wiki

From Odp

Jump to: navigation, search
Reviews:StefanoDavid about OnlynessIsLoneliness (OIL)
CreationDate 10 September 2009  +
HasClearFigures None provided
HasClearProblemDescription No, it needs some rework.
HasClearRelevanceDescription yes
HasMissingInformation ER/UML diagram
HasProblems * I would rephrase the problem statement: * I would rephrase the problem statement: I would suggest to call "problem" the modeling error (which is obviously an Anti-Pattern, as it causes the ontology to become useless), and "pattern" the proposed solution. * There are different hydrontologies in the "Pattern solution example": I would point only to one of them, as they seem very similar, and use it also as use case. * Although the hydrontologies seem to be some official Spanish knowledge bases, I would rather use an english version of a part of them that clearly states the problem, as it is not so comfortable to search in the whole ontology the pattern. * I would extend the definition of this pattern by suggesting that it is allowed the use of multiple restrictions (i.e., C1 subClassOf R only C2, ... ,C1 subClassOf R only Cn) to be combined in a single disjointness axiom, e.g., for those languages, like OWL2, that allow DisjointClasses into a single axiom: C1 subClassOf R only (C2 or ... or Cn); disjointClasses (C2, ... Cn) * "We have categorized them into three groups:". There are no three groups in the remainder, but the description of three classes nder, but the description of three classes
HasRelevance Medium/High, since the wrong use and the misuse of disjointness is often difficult to spot.
HasReusability Yes, across different languages and every time a (wrongly defined) disjointness is involved
HasReviewScore 1 -needsminorrevision  +
HasReviewSummary The authors propose a solution to a common modeling error, the use of disjointness assertions, that causes inconsistencies.
HasReviewerConfidence Good knowledge in Description logics and OWL
HasUnderstandability The modeling problem and proposed solutions need a rewording, but the purpose is clear.
IsBestPractice High, as it solves modeling mistakes.
LastModifiedDate 10 September 2009  +
Modification dateThis property is a special property in this wiki. 10 September 2009 14:07:16  +
ReviewAboutSubmissionThis property is a special property in this wiki. OnlynessIsLoneliness (OIL) +
ReviewAboutVersion 5,787  +
SubmittedBy StefanoDavid +
Categories QCReview +
hide properties that link here 
  No properties link to this page.


Enter the name of the page to start browsing from.
Personal tools
Quality Committee
Content OP publishers