| CreationDate
|
9 September 2009 +
|
| HasClearFigures
|
clear enough.
The enriched definition is not graphically linked to the class it originates from.
|
| HasClearProblemDescription
|
description is clear.
|
| HasClearRelevanceDescription
|
Consequences are unclear.
|
| HasMissingInformation
|
there is no owl ontology, nor a scenario description
|
| HasProblems
|
The problems and discussion points associa … The problems and discussion points associated with this pattern are the same as those mentioned for the "Define Hybrid Class Resolving Disjointness due to Subsomption" pattern.
The additional problem I see with this particular pattern is that, once the definition from the disjoint superclass has been added, the subclass relation between the enriched subclass and its original superclass may be compromised. ts original superclass may be compromised.
|
| HasRelations
|
related to the "Define Hybrid Class Resolving Disjointness due to Subsomption" pattern.
|
| HasRelevance
|
high for best practise.
|
| HasReusability
|
very reusable if approved.
|
| HasReviewScore
|
0 -needsmajorrevision +
|
| HasReviewSummary
|
This pattern proposal deserves discussion, … This pattern proposal deserves discussion, in combination with the pattern proposal "Define Hybrid Class Resolving Disjointness due to Subsomption", which is a solution variant to the same problem proposed by the same authors.
I am not sure about the logical consequences of including definitions from a desired superclass for the hyponymic relation between the subclass enriched with this superclass definition and its orginal superclass. ass definition and its orginal superclass.
|
| HasReviewerConfidence
|
medium
|
| HasUnderstandability
|
good, although a very clear definition of what "definition" means is crucial for a proper understanding.
|
| IsBestPractice
|
none that I know of.
|
| LastModifiedDate
|
9 September 2009 +
|
| Modification dateThis property is a special property in this wiki.
|
9 September 2009 14:18:44 +
|
| ReviewAboutSubmissionThis property is a special property in this wiki.
|
Enlarge Class Definition for Resolving Disjointness due to Subsomption +
|
| ReviewAboutVersion
|
5,731 +
|
| SubmittedBy
|
WimPeters +
|
| Categories |
QCReview +
|
